El ciudadano solicitó al Ayuntamiento de El Puerto de Santa María información sobre la gestión de la limpieza viaria y el contrato de servicios. Tras la denegación parcial de la administración, el Consejo de Transparencia y Buen Gobierno estima la reclamación, obligando al ayuntamiento a entregar la documentación solicitada por no concurrir límites legales.

Puntos clave de la argumentación

1 La administración no justificó la inexistencia de la información, ya que el contrato de limpieza es un documento público y accesible.

2 El Consejo determina que la información solicitada no constituye un secreto profesional ni afecta a la confidencialidad de procesos de toma de decisión.

3 Se establece que el derecho de acceso a la información pública prevalece cuando la administración no acredita la concurrencia de un límite legal tasado.

4 La resolución subraya que la transparencia en la contratación pública es fundamental para el control ciudadano de la gestión municipal.

Texto completo

!"#$$ %# &'!"(')!+' '," ' $' +!- .'+/ (02$+' + 2 ! 3 4#! %# $' .5!+&'& 4'$#!+'!' .+""+/ #6#5&+4' !" # $" % & ' (* +, -". +/01 * 34 53 "- 6" &" 4 '-" 7 % 8' 4 2 99:+/09* 3 3 * 34 53 &" 5'-" 7 3 ; !"* 53 <= #" $5+/ '!&##%#!&" (77 < 3? "4 6" 5@3* 4 ; 56" + +/09* 53 6" 5'-" 7 < " A" 5? &4 32 ; " 6"@ 4 & ; 5'-" < 5@3 ' ' ' ($) , ' - ./ 0 1 '2 .# , ./ , # ' 10 + 3 2 A ?@ 6" ; & " " <" 3 3 " < B '@ * 3 ; 56" " 4 3 <4 3 6" ; &" 4 53 "8 3 5* ; &" 6" 5'-" 36"(* 5" * & 6" 5D 6" 3 6" ; &" 6"@ FG25 &H * 5 * 36"( & &4 6"@ &" " 6" 5 3 3 3 5I 6" 5 . 6"@* 3 ; -" 5"4* - 3* 3 " 3 6" & &4 A '@ @* 6" ; 7 5"( 5'-" 36"( 3<" &" A< 6" 3" &77 5'-" ; " 6" 5D 6" 3 6" ; &" 6"@ FG25 &H '@ * ; &" 6" 3 36"(* & 6" @ 5 +J K 0,:+/0K 3(* 0L &" A< ; & 3 A" &" 3 5 * ; 6" 36"(* @ * 36"( F " F & 3 &H " 4 3 6" ; &" 6"@ ; .* @ @* 6"* * A< 6" <" 3 ; ; 3 6" " M ? ?* 6" 5@ 36"( & &4* 6"; &4 3 5@I 6" 6" 3"< ; 3 & " 34 -" <" & 3 "4 5 " 3 97 5'-" ; " 6" 6"* 6" 6"@ 3 ; 5@3 4,-5678976:) -; 1 < '' 0 976:2 =+ -658 8976:> - (A '($) 976:% 1 ' 1 , 5@3 &@ <" 6"@ FG25 &H N @ 6" 5; 6" 5'-" ; " 3 53 "* * 3 4 3 ; 3. " "4 <" M " 3 3 5@ @6" A< 3.M 376"M "4 7 3 < <"3 @6" ' ; "4* 5'-" " @3 6" O5; 6" 3 5<" 5@"4 5 5" % B * @ @* 6" 3 6" ; &" G25 & ; ?@ "4 3 " 4 :; 3 A" 3 53 ; 56" "* & -" 5'-" 6" 6" ? 3 & &4 36"( O'6" ? <" 7 < 2 6" 3 * 3 6" 2 & 3 5@3* 6" 5 5& F * N '" * + * +//0* 3 1,R1,,* 6" ; 5'<( 34 * 2 J+* +//,H 5'-"* ;? N 5' /+/,+ /R:/R:+/09* & 3 & * " 6" & 53 &4 " A* 6" O53 2 37 " 6"@* 3 3(; "34 3 "B @I < 5? &4 A "; &" 4 5"3 ; 56" 4 @";* 6" - <" 3 3 32 " ( "" 56" I<* 53 3 "4 ; <= - !'.#!&" <5=%+" (77> N & 5 +J 0 4 J+ 0 +:+/0L 83(* ; 34 " " F5 ;* +:+/0L ;H* 5I< 3 3 6" 3 5" 3 5? &4* ? 4 @"; 7 3; " 3"<4 $"4 '; < 5 @3 * 53 ; - 5" 4 F 6" & & &( G25H 3 " 3 ; 5'-" 4 5@"4 5 5" < 5@3 ?* " ; & ; 5'-" 6" 53 O 3 " F"4 <HM @; @ @6" @6" 3 3" 3 7 3-B 5'-" ; 4 * 3? "4 6" ; 6" ; <" 3 3* ; 6" 5; O6" 3 5<" 5@"4 5 5" % B 53 ; A ?@ 6" ; <" " 3* &4 * 3 " < % 3 5@I* A" 3 3 ?@ "* 5'-" ; 6" O53 2 3 " 6"@* 3 3(; "34 3 " B @I ; < 5? &4 A* 6" ? - 4 ; 56" "8> 3" 3* <& 6" 5'-" ? " " "- < " &4 6" <4 3( '@ @* &4 A 57 &4 32 - 5? 5 0K 0,:+/0K ' 5&* 3" 6" O 5? 3 &4 32 <" "* < 6" < & "3* 6" <" 3 5<" "- 57 534 56" 6" < <" 6" 5@ " &" B 3 6"@ 3 6" &" " 6"@ 4 ; 5'-" &4 " ? " <" 6" 3 5'-" 4 5@ " &" * * 5&4 33 3 6" 6" '@I* ? * 3-" "( 3 " 54 * 3* 6" 3< &77 3 "3I 5 & ; 5? &4 32M 4 6" &4 A 7 ;" 3 3 @ -" 3 53 F +J H 5 @3* & @3 6" 6"@ 5? &4 A 3 " @ -" 3" - <" "4 6" ; 5@3 +0:+/01* @ 5? &4 ? . " ;"4 5? -" N &* 3" D 56" @ 5? &4 57 ; ; 5'" F ;4 5? &4* 334 32 3 5? -" "3 0,,R* 6" ? 3 3.H 5 < N S 8? . 8N! ; < S* , -". 0,,R* <" 3? F 9H ; 3; F RH 6"( A; ? 3 4 " 3; " S "3I 3" ; 8N! ; < S* 0, " +//L N ?* <" 6" & 3 3 &"( 5? &4 5? 34 * "( 5? &4 & 5 -" & 3 34 &4 34 5?* 6" "4 3 6" &4 3 " 34 3 ; &4 3 A 3 6" ; 3 4 4 &* DI ?* 6" < " "4 6" " " ? < 3& A % 6" 3"* ? 3* 6" @3 6" & "4 ; 5@3 +0:+/01 6" (< 3& 5? &4 33 3 " & T 6" 5 +J < 5 &* O6" (< -" & "* 6" ;@ 3 < 5? &4 32 &"@ <4 3( N 33; <4 3(* 6" (< -" 3& 3 ; 33 53 6" * 3 34 3 0,:+/0K O <" 3 5? &4 32B* 6" 53 + 3 6" O < 3 ; 3&* 3 6" 7 "3* 6" ( 6" <" 3; " (< -" 3& 5? &4 B 6=(* 3 (< 5? &4 32 6" 5< 3 "( 5" & F 5? 34 * 5? 4 33 "3 32* 5@34 &4* H 5 3 (< 3* 3-" 534 "3I* " 6" 3"<* 3(* ; ? 5? &4 <" " < 3 6" 6" 6" " <@ B 97 N 3" ; 6" ; F53 H & 3 3 "U 4 * ? * " 6" ; 5'-" A &4 4 4 6" 5 ; 3 3 3 5"4 6" 3 ; ; 53 3 &5 & M @ @* 3 6=( 3 6" 3 ; <" " & 6" & & 53 <" <" '@* 53 3 ; <" - 3 6=( &"" 326"* 6=( % <4 5" K,:+/0L 5 5@* ? 5? 6" 0,:+/0K* <" 5 LK 0 H K,:+/0L O " 3 "* <= VWX H ' ?@* 6"; * 5 4 3 6"( <" 4 5 B N ?* "( 5? &4 5? 5@3 5 ? & 34 -" 6" A &4* 6" 5 <"@ < 6" <4 5 5I< <* ? 6" '@ <" 4 5@3 "4 6" ; 5@3 2 0+ +/09* 0/ D +/01* 6" Y'6" <"4 "3 " @4 ; I< (< < 5? &4 3& 5?* 3 3 * 5@3* 6" ? 3I3 3 % ? 6" 3 5" (< 3 3;< 5? &4 32 <" " @3* VWX 3 6" 5 <" 5" (< 5? &4 3 * ? 3 " ; < 5? &4 32 " < ; @<( @ <4 3.* A 5&4 ; " A" F 01 K 0,:+/0KH* - 6" ? 5A< 6" 3 " A" 3 @3 6" 5 00 +:+/0L ;* O 5@ 56" 7 ; A" ; B '@ * 5 " 3 A &4 53 <4 < 5? &4* "- < "7 & &4 ; 3 34 @3 0J 0L 0,:+/0K* 3 A" 5&4 Z;* 3 6" ;4 7 3 6" 34 -" 5 &;7 3 5? &4 \ :; 3* 3 ; -" "7 ; 6" "3 4 6" ; &" 3 6" 3? ?@ ; & I ; @3 ;" 6" 5 Z;* @I 3 3;4 " 3* 3I ? " " 3* 3 ? 6" 3 " @3 ; 56" ;" 3 ? 3 3 " N @ * 4 F& 3H ; 3 5 4* O 4 ]"@ "<<B 53 O5^D <" <4 6"@ "<<B 5'-" % @I ? 3 36"( (< -" 4 <* <" <@ 3 (< 3& * "* 34 3& 3 6" &" 4 4 3 3" <4 & '@* ? <& 6" 3 "3I G25 &" 53 ? " 2 I F 36" 6" 3 @3 * <" 5 LR LR:+//K* 01 * 8"7H 83 5" "4 I & 6" & & 3 <" F 57 %34 8 <" H* - 6" 5 .* 5" 3 @ & 3 ; I % 56" 33; 5" "4 & 6" < < " (< & " '@ "@ 4 5 0L H ; 2 R0 5^<4 % 8* 6" 3 5<4 %34 " & 5< 6"; 6"@ 6" ?@ " &4 @ ? " &@ < 3 %34 < & 3 O 5< 6"; 6"@W 57 &"4 3B F 0/ +K:+/0L* ^ %34 8 <" H 83 6"@ 4 "4 & 6" 57 6" 3"@ 57 5'4 & 6" <" <@ @3 N6" 6" 09 K? 0R 0J:+//R* L ;* 5^& '&" ".* ? 00 +? 0J 00:+/09* +R ;* * 5'<( ;4 " #" "34 " 6" @ * 56" "4 <?* " "3 6" "7 3 4* " 34 %< " "34 4 N" '6" 2 33 4 " &@ 6" 2 3 " " 34 "* BC +B * * @;M ? * 34 3 6" & * "* ; 3 A 3 " " A 6" * 3 @3 3 4 : F+/0JH 1* ? 3 34 BC +B * K/ 5 +/0J* 6"(* * 3< & " F 0RH 3 3 @ 37 " A4 "7 2 6"; & 6" 3"< " " A" Z;* " 3 6" @@ " ]"; 34 3 3 5" " ; 3 ' ?* 6" & 3 ; 34 3 3 5 -" < ;< 3 6" & - @ " " & 6" & " " & @ " 3* 6"( 53 " (< -" 3* & " 34 -" 3 "7 6" "4 " "; ' 3 3 - 5 3 4 & 34 % ? 6" <" 5&4 5? 6" A @ 3 3 6" ; &" 6"@ * "* " D 3 3 & ? -" 5 # 5? 3" ; (< -" 34 ? " 4 3 3 & F 3 G"5H F 00 ^<7 0L:0,,, ^NH < 5 00 0 ^N* O 7 3 - ? 3 " " 3 3 & &" < 3; 5B '6" < ;"7 @3" "3I 6" 3;" 5 00 +* 6" 6" 6"( " < " 4 3<"* * 4 ; 3 3 0,:+/0K* "* 6" < 5? -" F +J H* * "* 5? 5@3 ' ? 3 " 3 6" " * ? 6" 5? &4* 5? -" 5? 5@3 3 3 6" A 6" ; 3 2 & 3 & 34 ? " O? <B % " O? <B ? 3 < " F H '@I ? @ 34 5 1 &H N; ,L:J9: * 6" 8$S* +J ; +/00* 8 * R & +/0+H 8 3 (< -" 3* 3 " 5 0L 0,:+/0K 53 K* 36"( "@ 6" 4 6" 3 5? &4 A 6" < D,<1 A ' ' E'F ' A F 1 4+ '1 1 ' 1 A 1 , ) 31 1 E' 1 'G - 2 I + ?K & 6:86@5? 9? L )M E L, +2& 1 A 1 ' 1 ' C E I I , 2 I 4 ' , 2&' ' ' ' , N,/ + + F 1 1 , ?, & 1 + +' ,O Z; 6" 33 < 5 53 ; 3 6" 5 ;D* 33 7@ 3(* ? & "4 6" @* 6" 34 5? &4 5? -" "; @ & 34 3 . 6" 5A" 0L K 0,:+/0K & &( " O3(; 34 3" 5? 32 ;"<4 &4B 6" 6" 5? &4 32 ? " "-"* 3 ;" 5? -" 5? 5@3 % 6" * "* 3 3; & 5" "-" 6" 3"* 5 O 5? 32B 6"( & &( 6" 33* "* 3 ; ; " ; 6" @ 6" < 5 @3* " 6" 34 0_* 0,:+/0K 3 "3I * & ? 32 5 6" "-"* 3 " " 3"<" &" & ;* 3 * 3 5 -" F +J 0 H 34 6" 3@ <" 5 0L K 0,:+/0K . 6" " 6" 3 & @ 5? &4 ? O-"&4 3 A " 34 5@ 5" B F H 6" 5 @3 &* A &4 -"& " 34 5? &4* @ 5? -" 5? 5@3 3 5 6" * 34 5 &; 5? &4 ]" 5? -"* 3@ 6" ; 6" 3" 5 < 3 5 ; 3 6" ; &" 4 FG25 &H 3 " & 6" 3? ; G25 6" 3? & ;* "* 3 ;7 & ;* 3 * 3 @3 (< 3( 57 &"" ; '@ @* G25 3 3 6=( -" * 3 6" 53 A 5&4 3"< "( 5<" 3" 3* ?@ 3 " ? 3 5" ? -" " "&" A &* ?* &; 34 " ' @I 5"@ &4 5? 4 5? 5@3 3 3 N "* 6" 34 5 &; @ 5? &4 ]" H 5 0L K* 5" A" "4 5& F G"5 6" ; &" 4H % 6" 4 O 7 &"B '@ * "* 6" 34 5 ; 3 &4 * - 6" 4 * 4 6" &; 6" ; 3 4 ?; N 33; 3 6" * 3 H* 5 0L K 0,:+/0K O 2&' ' ' ' ,O % 3 "7 6" * 3@ 6" & <" 3 " 3 6" < 5 % 3 5@I* 3 3 3 6" 6" 53" 6" 3 5@3 ? 6" - '@* ; &" 6" & 5 +J K 0,:+/0K* ; A @3 6" A< 6" ; ; 3 6" " M ? * 6" 5@ 36"( & &4* 6"; &4 3 5@I 6" 6" 3"< ; 3 & " 34 -" & 4 6" 3 3 3 ;* 6" * 6"; 3" "7 6" <" & 3 34 " 3 N @ * 4 G25 & ; 3 " &4 ; @3 < & Z; ; &* 3I 3 ?@ 6" <" 3 34 & 3 ? ; 6" 56" 6" 5 @3* 3 34 &" * ?@ 6" @ 5 ?@ 3 6" ; &" 4 7 3* "* 3 " @ 5? -" ! 5; 6" 6" "4 53 6" "7 3 * 6" <" @3 "4 3 ; <" * 3 @3* 5; <" " (< 53 < &* ? 7 34 <M 5<" 5" 2 &M G"5 F&H <" 3 ? & ; " ; 6" M 5? &4 6" ;" A* 5? -" 5? 5@3* * 6" ; 3 ; & ; 3 "4 !@; ' ? 5I 6" 5 @3* . 6" ; & 5'<( 3. 34 &4 " '@* 3 @3* & /+0J:+//, /KJ+:+/0+* @ <" -"3"( & 8 &* 5@3* & 4 3. "4 6" 6" 3 `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`? 37 4 56" @ 6" < ; 3 5@ 5* & 3 VWX 6" * ( 8" "3* ';* 4 1* +9 < +/00* 4 K/+:+/0/* " 6" KL H K/:0,,+ " & 3 < &* . ) G 1C P. ' 2 D? &%R8)( ' E ' + ' ' 0PE 2, $ 1 1 + F ' 3 + 1 D? &%R8)( 9N(, C + F D?,2' + ' F ' E ' 3 1 F + E , '@* 33 33* 6" & 3<" 3 F KL H K/:0,,+H ? < & 5" 3* ? " 6" 2 6" <" ; 3 5@ " T & 3 T* "7 3 - 2 53 5 6" 3 F"H 6" " 6" 3 4 & & * &;* 5" 34 &* & 5 +J 4 N 7 5 0R J 4 8 +,+:+/// N56" * & & 56" '<( L -" +/0/* " ; 6" 53" <" " 3 5@ &* 5 " 5" &; O'@ * 53* 5'N 6" 3@ & &; 3 3 5@ & a ?* 3- <" 56" &* 5 /KJ+:+/0+* <" &* 3" 3 ; "7 6" 3 & " 6" 3 6" O C ' ' C ' '. A P 1 ' E' C O %* 5 * 3 @ @34 3 ;" 3 3 6" ; 3 4 3?* 6" 6" 5 6" 8? &( ? 3 7 "3I 3* 3 5'<( 34 `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| Firmado digitalmente por RICARDO JESUS|GARCIA|MACHO GARCIA|MACHO Fecha: 2017.07.14 11:05:24 +02'00'