El solicitante pidió información sobre la gestión de la calidad del aire al Ayuntamiento de Madrid. Tras una respuesta insuficiente, el interesado reclamó ante el Consejo de Transparencia y Buen Gobierno. El Consejo estima la reclamación, obligando al Ayuntamiento a proporcionar la información solicitada por no haber justificado adecuadamente la denegación.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
El Consejo determina que la administración no ha justificado la denegación del acceso a la información basándose en los límites legales.
2
Se establece que la información solicitada no constituye un secreto profesional ni afecta a la confidencialidad de procesos de toma de decisión.
3
La administración no ha acreditado que la información se encuentre en curso de elaboración o que requiera una acción previa de reelaboración.
4
Se concluye que el Ayuntamiento de Madrid ha vulnerado el derecho de acceso a la información pública al no proporcionar los datos solicitados sin motivo legal válido.
Texto completo
"
! "
" " "
*, "\ !THP5 \
& '1\ 45\ A1\ 7>LE1\
#&
%&
"#!%!"& GFO5?5LW1\ 45\ 5O1LMGBCG\ .GOQ5F=2B5\ &RFQ1\ 45\
GERF=4145O\ 45\ 1OQ=CB1'1\ )1F3;1\
!%& "#& 3QR13>YF\ 45\ C1\ 14E=F=OQL13=YF\ 1RQGFYE>31\ L5OH53QG\ 45 B\
=F3REHC=E=5FQG\ 45\ B1O\ G2C=913=GF5O\ KR5\ L5315F\ OG2L5\ 5EHL5O1\ HGP5F3=1CE5FP5\
3GFQ1E>F1FP5\
#& & & !"$%& !.!./$)0+-%\
.59ZF\ O5\ 45OHL5F45\ 45\ B1\ 4G3RE5FP13=YF\ KR5\ G2M1\ 5F\ 5D\ 5TH54=5FP5\ 5F\ 653<1\ \ 45
FGS =5E2L5\ 45\ \ 5B\ L53B1E1FP5\ OGB>3>QY\ 1C\ 1EH1MG\ 45\ B1\ '5U\ \ 45\ \ 45
4>3=5E2L5\ 45\ QL1FOI1L5F3>1\ 1335OG\ 1\ C1\ =F8GLE13=YF\ J[2B=31\ V\ 2R5F\ :G2=5NFG
5F
145B1FP5\ (/$#\ 1\ B1\ GFO5@5LX1\ 45\ 5O1LLGBCG\ .GOP5F>2C5\ B1\ O>9R>5FP5\ >F6GLE13=YF
+
%+ + + #+ "#$"(+ %+ #"$ + + *" + + "#$" + +
+ #+ & &)+ + "#$""+ $" + #"$ + ! "+ + # + $& + + %" '+ +
+ + %" + + "#$" + # "+ + " $%"+ + #+ #+ +
!"#+ + + !"$+ $"#+
M
- CC9A GHG #7* *A# E A% =M %C : . :M /'
K,05!M M (+M M
86B+38M (+M >"6B;!>+6&0"M JM F+6M 8$1+>68M M
I &86B+48)+D ?!6B<!@+6&2 !+BM
LM
"D
!
! !
! !
9@D %''.32)7D 00):%2D 6)%0.=%(%7D -%78%D 0%D +)'-%D )2D 6)0%'.C2D %D 037D );4)(.)28)7D
1)2'.32%(37D %28)6.361)28)D $%D 59)D 7)D -%2D 46)7)28%(3D D )7'6.837D 436D )0D 1.713D
138.:3D )2D (37D 1)7)7D <D )0D .2'9140.1.)283D )7D 1%2.+.)783D 436D 4%68)D ()D 0%D )146)7%D
)2D )0D );4)(.)28)D <D '32D 291)63D ()D D
32D #D ()D 0%D 928%D ()D '3192.(%()7D ()D %78.00%%D %2'-%D
4%6%D )0D '9140.1.)283D (.'8%(3D 436D 0%D %9836.>%'.C2D '313D
)146)7%D 438)2'.%01)28)D '328%1.2%(36%D 8)28%1)28)D :)'.237D ()D 0%D %00)D %2D
6%2'.7'3D ()D 7A7D()D!%0%:)6%D 0%D 9):%D
,3? (? 42,$? ? 02.423? .-0? .03? ? (? +$,$230$=,? 43-,=+%? (? 2-*$$3,3
.02,3=? 4,? 0(+$=,? ,3? (? -,2&-? ? 0,2.0,$? 8? 4,? -%0,-? ,
(,3? ? ? (? /4? 2? ? ,30? ,? #? ? ? +09-? ? ? -,? ,>+0-?
7.%,3?
)? ? ? +0:-? ? ? (? ? 0+$3%=? (? 1(+ $=,? ? (? 030<? ,0(? ? (
-,2&0<? ? 210-))-? -23,$(? )? -'3-? ? /4? 2? .4$0,? .02,30? *2
("$-,2? /4? 2? -,2%02,? -.-034,2
%' ' ' '
)? ? ? 0$(? ? ? 2? 0$,? )2? ("%-,2? 0/40$2? /5? $,(58,? ,30? -30
-5+,3%=,? 5,? $,!-0+? 7.%-? .-0? (? 06$$-? ? -,30-)? ? ($? +%,3(
? ? ? +09-? ? ? ,-3$!$-? (? $,302-? /5? 2? .0-,5,$? ,? *-2? 2%"5$,32
3;0+$,-2
).8)6%137D 59)D 6)74)'83D %D 0%D 34)6%8.:.(%(D ()D '9%059.)6D 1)(.(%D '366)'836%D ()D 0%D
'328%1.2%'.C2D %8137+@6.'%D .149)78%D )2D 0%D %9836.>%'.C2D ()&)2D )78%6D :.,)28)7D ()7()D
59)D 7)D )1.8.CD 0%D %9836.>%'.C2D <D (96%28)D )0D +92'.32%1.)283D ()D 0%D .278%0%'.C2D 313D )7D
):.()28)D 49)()2D );.78.6D ):)289%0)7D .2(.7432.&.0.(%()7D ()D 0%7D 1)(.(%7D '313D
'327)'9)2'.%7D ()D %:)6B%7D <D 63896%7D ()D )59.437D <D 1%8)6.%0D 4)63D 8%0D .2(.7432.&.0.(%(D
23D ()&)D 4)61%2)')6D 1?7D %00?D ()0D 8.)143D )786.'8%1)28)D 2)')7%6.3D 4%6%D 79D
6)4%6%'.C2D
3&6)D 0%D 63896%D ()D 032%7D ()292'.%(%D ()7()D )78%D (1.2.786%'.C2D 7)D 6)59.6.CD )2D +)'-%D
D .2+361%'.C2D %D 73&6)D 7.89%'.C2D ()D 0%7D 1.71%7D
.278?2(30)D %D 59)D 0%D '%0.(%(D ()D 0%D 6)4%6%'.C2D 7)%D %()'9%(%D 4%6%D 59)D 6)7908)2D *'8.:%7D
)2D '9%283D %D 0%D ):.8%'.C2D ()D 0%D 437.&0)D '328%1.2%'.C2D 7.1.713D 7)D .2(.'CD 59)D )2D
'%73D ()D 63896%D 3D ()74)6+)'837D ()D 0%7D 1)(.(%7D '366)'836%7D 0%7D 6)4%6%'.32)7D ()&)2D
6)%0.>%67)D 03D %28)7D 437.&0)D 4%6%D ):.8%6D 4)6/9.'.37D %D 0%D 43&0%'.C2D )2D ,)2)6%0D 0D
D 7)D 6)'.&.CD '3192.'%'.C2D ()D 0%D )146)7%D .2+361%2(3D 59)D 0%7D 032%7D
59)(%632D 6)4%6%(%7D )2D 0%D 7),92(%D59.2')2%D ()D D
' ' ' $' "' ' '
# ! '
&'
!
<:S +*(.&S S )*S &'D06S )*S S F*S D*(1'*S *;S *FG*S <;F*2<S *F(D1G<S )*6S E*(6&9&;G*
9&:1+*FG&;)<S FHS )1F(<;,<D90)&)S (<:S 6&S D*F=H*FG&S )&)&S =<ES *;G*;)*DS BH*S :<S F*S (0P*
=D<=1&9*:G*S &S 5<FS GMD90;<FS *;S BH*S +H*S ,<D9H5&)&S FHS F<60(1GH)
*S (<;,<D91)&)S (<;S 6<S )1F=H*FG<S *:S *5S &DGN(H5<S (S )*S 6&S #S KS *:S *6S &DGN(H6<S
)*6S "*&6S *(D*G<S S )*S S )*S <(GH'D*S ><DS *6S CH*S F*S &?DH*'&S *6S FG&GHG<S )*5
<:F*3<S )*S #D&:F@&D*;(0&S H*;S <'1*D:<S
S
S *6S !D*F1)*;G*S )*S *FG&S &HG<D1)&)
&)91;0FGD&G0I&S 1;)*=*;)1*;G*S *FS (<9=*G*;G*S =&D&S D*F<6I*DS 5&FS D*(6&9&(1 <:*FS BH*S *;S
&=51(&(1Q;S )*6S &DGO(H6<S S )*S 5&S $
F*S =D*F*;G*;S +D*;G*S &S 6&FS D*F<6H(0<;*FS *J=D*F&FS
< =D*FH;G&FSD*(&N)&FS *;S 9&G*D0&S )*S &((*F<S &S 6&S1;,<D9&(1Q;
;S I1DGH)S )* 6S &@&DG&)<S S )*S 6&S )1FA<F0(0Q;S &)0(1<;&6S (H&DG&S )*S 7&S $S
S 5&F
(<9H;1)&)*FS &HGQ;<9&FS =H*)*:S &GD1'H1ES 5&S (<9=*G*;(1&S =&D&S 5&S D*F<5H(0Q;S )*S 6&FS
D*(5&9&(0<;*FS &5S #S 9*)0&:G*S 6&S (*6*'D&(1Q;S )*5S (<DD*F=<;)0*;G*S (<:I*;0<S (<:S 6&S
)91:1FGD&(0Q;S*;*D&6S )*6S FG&)<S ;S )*F&DD<56<S )*S )0(.&S =D*I0F1Q;S *J1FG*S (<;I*;1<
I0-*;G*S FHF(D0G<S (<;S 6&FS (<9H;0)&)*FS &HGQ;<9&FS )*S FGHD1&FS &;G&'D 1&S &S "1<4&S
JGD*9&)HD&S &FG066&&S &;(/&S *S 865*FS &6*&DFS &FNS (<9<S (<:S 6&FS (0H)&)*FS &HGQ:<9&FS
)*S *HG&S KS *5066&S
&S %S *;S FHS &DGO(H6<S
S D*-H6&S *6S )*D*(.<S )*S G<)&FS 6&FS =*DF<;&FS &S &((*)*DS &S 6&
0:,<D9&(1Q:S =R'61(&S *:G*;)1)&S F*-R:S *6S &DGN(H6<S S )*S 6&S 91F9&S ;<D9&S (<9<S
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
!<DS 6<S G&:G<S 5&S 6*KS )*,1;*S *6S <'4*G<S )*S H;&S F< 61(1GH)S )*S &((*F<S &S 6&S 1:,<D9&(0Q:S *:
D*5&(1Q;S (<;S 1:,<D9&(1Q;S BH*S K&S *J1FG*S =<DS (H&;G<S *FGLS *;S =<F*F1Q;S )*S H;S <D-&;0F9<
Kvvbr #~~„ :_EEr:{r=5j„ 5 =v cKc„ &MA%)1-'vZ%Vc%35!„
Kwwbs $ ~~~ :_F Fs ;{s>6 k 6>w cKd&MA%)-'! ! d%"wZ% 6„
K vver #~~ ~ :_E Er :{r=5l„ 5>v f L f„ &MA%)1-'!! „ e%!vZ%„ VA7?{55„
Kvvbr#~~=_ZrGS_BEvm5Zrc5lEZ=O5Et=x„ /_XEEr vn5[rg5kEZ?N5b_nv5Wxl5[rc5lE[=O5M[I`jX5=O_[‚
F>`Z >`Z}FZO`r>`Z}F\O`s++'' K yY W„
K wves$~~~ :_E Er: { r=5 k„5 =w c L c„ &MB%)1-'!! „ wZ%Vh%!5„
2ƒJP]8„ „ CH„ „
,a^uHTa„ CH„ 4o9^ui8oH^@P9„ „ *|H^„ .a<QHo^a„ ((0„
€ @aZuHUaDHz p8Zue8qHZ@ R8 Hu„
*2".<+#3H $2H 9<H A1!*:3H #$H 4.*" "+F2H !+$2H 4365<$H B/H 1*913H / H ( H $/ !36 #3H !+$2H 4365<$H
/ H ( H 3!:$2 +#3H $2H $,$6"+"*3H #$H . 9H %<2"+32$9H ?H "314$:$2"+ 9H 5<$H :+$2$H $2"31$2# # 9H
$'G2H 9$H $>46$9 H $2H $/H 46$A1!</3H #$H / H H / H :7 294 6$2"+ H $/H ""$93H H / H
*2&361 "+F2H 4G!/+" H ?H / 9H2361 9H#$H !<$2H '3!*$623H #$!$2H 9$7H /39H $-$9H %<2# 1$2: /$9H
#$H :3# H ""*F2H 43 / C:*" H F.3H "< 2#3H / H ""+F2H #$H /39H 6$94329 !/$9H 4G!/+"39H 9$H 931$:$H H
$9"8<:+2+3H "< 2#3H /39H "+<# # 239H 4<$#$2H "323"$6H "F13H 9$H :31 2H / 9H #$"+9+32$9H 5<$H
/$9H %$": 2H "F13H 9$H 1 2$, 2H .39H %32#39H 4G!/ +"39H 3H ! ,3H 5<BH "6*:$8*39H ":G 2H 2<$9:6 9H
*29:+:<"+32$9H 43#6$139H ( !. 6H #$ /H +2+"+3H #$H <2H 463"$93H $2H $/H 5<$H /39H 43#$6$9H 4G!0+"39H
"31+$2@ 2H H 6$9432#$6H H <2 H 93"+$# #H 5<$H $9H "6C:*" H $>+'$2:$H ?H 5<$H #$1 2# H
4 6:+"+4 "*F2H #$H /39H 43#$8$9H 4G!/+"39H
2H "< 2:3H H .3H 93/*"*:<#H "32"6$: H #$/H (36 H 6$". 1 2:$H " !$H +2#+" 6H 5<$H 23H =$89
4634+ 1$2:$H 93!6$H <2 H +2&381 "+F2H 4/ 91 # H $2H "< /5< +$6H : + 43H #$H %361 :3H 3H 93436;$
5<$H 3!6$H $2H 43#$8H $2H $9:$H " 93H "32"6$:3H #$H / H 329$,$6D H #$H $9 663/.3H 39:$2+!/$
9*23H 5<$H "313H 9$H #$946$2#$H #$H /39H 2:$"$#$2:$9H 9$H ( H &361</ #3H $2H &361 H #$
#$2<2"* H 2:$H . H % /: H #$H 6$:+6 # H #$H <2 9H /32 9H $2H 1 .H $9: #3H 436H 4 7:$H #$H / H $146$9
6$&$8+# H $2H . H 93/*"+:<#H *29: 2#3H / H ":< "+F2H #$H / H #1*2*9:6 "*F2H "314$:$2:$H H .39
$%$":39H #$H 1+:+' 7H /39H $&$":39H 43:$2"* .1$2:$H "32: 1*2 #36$9H $2H 6$/ "*F2H "32H /
":+=*# #H #$9 863.. # H 436H / H $146$9 H 2H $9:$H 9$2:*#3H " !$H 9$E / 8H 5<$H $9:$H 329$-3
? H ) H :$2+#3H / H 3438:<2+# #H #$H 4632<2"* 69$H $2H 9<4<$9:39H $2H 5<$H / H 4$:+"+F2H $9:A
#$9:+2 # H H 5<$H / H #1+2+9:6 "*F2H G!/*" H "32"$72*# H ./$=$H H " !3H <2 H ":< "*F2
1 :$8+ .H %<:<6 H &361</ # H $2H :B81+239H #$H <2 H 3!.+' "+F2H 439+:+= H #$H ( "$6H 9DH $2H 9<9
6$93/<"*32$9H H H #$H H #$H '39:3H #$H
H ?H H H #$H H #$
3":<!7$H #$H
H #$:$71+2 ! H 5<$H 4$:+"+32$9H #$H : /H 2 :<6 /$@ H #+9: 2H #$H :6 : 69$H #$
93/+"+:<#$9H #$H ""$93H H / H +2&361 "+F2H $2H .39H :B61+239H #$&*2*#39H 438H .39H 7:C"<.39H H
H #$H / H 4634* H
$H $9:$H 13#3H :31 2#3H $2H "329+#$6 "+F2H $/H 3!,$:3H #$H . H 93/*"+:<#H 46$9$2: #
"329*9:$2:$H $2H . H 6$ .+@ "*F2H #$H <2 H ":< "+F2H 436H 4 6:$H #$H . H #1+2+9:6 "*F2
<:32F1+" H ?H 23H $2H 4$61+:*6H $/H ""$93H H #$:$81+2 #39H "32:$2+#39H 3H #3"<1$2:39H ?
$>+9:$2:$9H " !$H "32".<+6H 5<$H . H 6$"/ 1 "+F2H 4. 2:$ # H #$!$H 9$6H #$9$9:+1 # H 436H 23H
( !$69$H 93/*"+: #3H $/H ""$93H H <2 H +2%361 "*F2H 4G!/+" H $2H /39H :B61+239H $9: !/$"*#39H $2H
$/H 6:C"</3H H #$H / H
\
6PP H N W WW *EAN1 =E-1PJ&BN H %J1A*8% 1N*Q\ E@2*Q8V9.%.#1NE?T*9FA1NJ1NE?T+8EA2N\ !\ !
\ 6R@?\
\
7PP H N WWW *EAN1 =F-3PJ&BN H %J3A+8% 3N +Q\ E@1*R8V9.%.#3NE?T*9 EA1NJ3NE?T+8EA3N\ !\ !
7R@?\
"Z5:C'\ \ /4\ \
GDO4>G\ /4\ $K(DOI'K4D,:(\ Y\ U4D\ G);4KDG\ \
X ,GDO4=G04S L 'DOH'M4D, <'4O\
[\
%>DX 9*X D*OV<X .K?I.GH*X =>X ?D>,.-.X *<*94O*DX 9>GX *D1I;.<H>GX *9.1*->GX ?>DX 9*X
*-;4<5GHD*,4V=X ,><,.D<5-*X LX BI.X /51IE*=X .=X .9X .K?.-4.<H.X -.9X ?E>,.-4;5.<H>X 5<4,4*->X
,><X 9*X ?D.G.<H*,5V<X -.X 9*X D.,:*;*,5V<X *<H.X .GH.X ><G.7>X
<X *H.=,4V<X *X 9>GX *<H.,.-.=H.GX LX 0I<-*;.<H>GX 7IDU-5,>GX -.G,E5H>GX ?D>,.-.X
:*X D.,9*;*,5V<X ?F.G.<H*-*X 0D.<H.X *X :*X >=G.8.DT*X -.X .G*DD>:9>X '>GH.<5+:.X
-.X 9*X I<H*X -.X >;I<5-*-.GX -.X *GH4:9*!*X #*<,3*X
.X *,I.D->X ,><X .9X *DHT,I:>X X =W;.D>X X -.X :*X ".MX X -.X X -.X -4,5.;+D.X -.X
HD*<G@*D.=,4*X *,,.G>X *X 9*X 5<0>D;*,4V<X AW+:5,*X NX +I.<X 2>+5.D<>X
9*X D.,:*;*,5V<X
?D.J5GH*X .<X .9X *DHU,I9>X X -.X 9*X ;5G;*X H4.<.X :*X ,><G4-.D*,4V<X -.X GIGH5HIH4J*X -.X 9>GX
D.,IDG>GX *-;5<4GHD*H5J>GX -.X ,><0>D;4-*-X ,><X :>X -4G?I.GH>X .<X .:X *DHU,I:>X X -.X 9*X !.MX
X -.X X -.X >,HI+D.X -.X %F>,.-4;4.=H>X -;4<5GHE*H5J>X >;W<X -.X 9*GX
-;4<5GHE*,5><.GX %W+94,*G
>=HD*X :*X ?D.G.<H.X D.G>9I,4V<X BI.X ?><.X 05<X *X 9*X JU*X *-;4<4GHE*H5J*X G.X ?>-ERX 5<H.E?><.EX
D.,IDG>X ,><H.<,4>G>*-;5<4GHD*H5J>X .<X .9X ?:*P>X -.X ->GX ;.G.GX -6E.,H*;.<H.X *<H.X 9*X
'*9*X -.X 9>X ><H.<,4>G>*-;4<4GHD*H4J>X -.X 9*X I-4.<,4*X $*,5><*:X -.X ,><0>D;4-*-X ,><X 9>X
?D.J5GH>X .<X .9X *?*DH*->X CI4<H>X -.X :*X 4G?>G5,4V=X *-4,4><*9X ,I*DH*
-.X 9*X ".LX X
-.X X -.X 7I:4>X &.1I9*->D*X -.X :*X IF4G-4,,5V<X >=H.<,4>G>*-;4=5GHD*H4J*X
!X %&'$(X "X )X
->X >GSX !I4GX &>-EU1I.OX Q9J*D.OX
t
@ eeVb kkk 0S9 9b 0hb3,[t , 3e W A Wt B6")% t eNJV ,
@eeXbkkk1S:9b1hc3,\t ,3et X@Yt C6")% fOt X,t t
")% t (:mt t 6;t t 6;t 6C3B;M0[;t 6;t e [-Nb W -];N3C- t ,33;bSt -t K-t DP=U^M,3CqPt W r0 LC4-t nt
1i9Nt >S1C9]NSt
*p?EQ.t t 7<t t
$TRd<HTt 7<t +_/RdZ._<R5E/t ot #j<Rt &T2F<_RTt !!'t
l 5TOd<IT8<g ` .OdV.a<O5 G. <dt
st