Estimada 22/05/2024 · 183 días en resolverse

Solicitud de acceso a información sobre la gestión de la calidad del aire en Madrid

El solicitante pidió información sobre la gestión de la calidad del aire al Ayuntamiento de Madrid. Tras una respuesta insuficiente, el interesado reclamó ante el Consejo de Transparencia y Buen Gobierno. El Consejo estima la reclamación, obligando al Ayuntamiento a proporcionar la información solicitada por no haber justificado adecuadamente la denegación.

Puntos clave de la argumentación

1 El Consejo determina que la administración no ha justificado la denegación del acceso a la información basándose en los límites legales.
2 Se establece que la información solicitada no constituye un secreto profesional ni afecta a la confidencialidad de procesos de toma de decisión.
3 La administración no ha acreditado que la información se encuentre en curso de elaboración o que requiera una acción previa de reelaboración.
4 Se concluye que el Ayuntamiento de Madrid ha vulnerado el derecho de acceso a la información pública al no proporcionar los datos solicitados sin motivo legal válido.

Texto completo

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vvbr #~~„ :_EEr:{r=5j„ 5 =v cKc„ &MA%)1-'vZ%Vc%35!„ Kwwbs $ ~~~ :_F Fs ;{s>6 k 6>w cKd&MA%)-'! ! d%"wZ% 6„ K vver #~~ ~ :_E Er :{r=5l„ 5>v f L f„ &MA%)1-'!! „ e%!vZ%„ VA7?{55„ Kvvbr#~~=_ZrGS_BEvm5Zrc5lEZ=O5Et=x„ /_XEEr vn5[rg5kEZ?N5b_nv5Wxl5[rc5lE[=O5M[I`jX5=O_[‚ F>`Z >`Z}FZO`r>`Z}F\O`s++'' K yY W„ K wves$~~~ :_E Er: { r=5 k„5 =w c L c„ &MB%)1-'!! „ wZ%Vh%!5„ 2ƒJP]8„ „ CH„ „ ,a^uHTa„ CH„ 4o9^ui8oH^@P9„ „ *|H^„ .a<QHo^a„ ((0„ € @aZuHUaDHz p8Zue8qHZ@ R8 Hu„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t @ eeVb kkk 0S9 9b 0hb3,[t , 3e W A Wt B6")% t eNJV , @eeXbkkk1S:9b1hc3,\t ,3et X@Yt C6")% fOt X,t t ")% t (:mt t 6;t t 6;t 6C3B;M0[;t 6;t e [-Nb W -];N3C- t ,33;bSt -t K-t DP=U^M,3CqPt W r0 LC4-t nt 1i9Nt >S1C9]NSt *p?EQ.t t 7<t t $TRd<HTt 7<t +_/RdZ._<R5E/t ot #j<Rt &T2F<_RTt !!'t l 5TOd<IT8<g ` .OdV.a<O5 G. <dt st