El solicitante pidió acceso a información sobre la gestión de fondos públicos al Ayuntamiento de Alcorcón. Tras una respuesta insuficiente, el interesado reclamó ante el Consejo Superior para la Garantía del Derecho de Acceso a la Información Pública, que estima la reclamación al considerar que la administración no justificó adecuadamente la denegación de los datos.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
La administración no puede denegar el acceso a la información basándose en conceptos genéricos sin acreditar la concurrencia real de los límites legales.
2
El derecho de acceso prevalece sobre la mera comodidad administrativa de no reelaborar la información si esta ya existe en formatos accesibles.
3
Se considera insuficiente una respuesta que no detalla concretamente qué parte de la información se deniega y bajo qué precepto legal exacto.
4
El Consejo determina que la administración reclamada no ha cumplido con la carga de probar que la divulgación de la información solicitada perjudicaría el interés público.
Texto completo
% F=C.M M
% !*M -.M 7*M /3@9*M
"%
$%
!" $ !% D:C*M -.M <9D:3-*-.BM -.M *BC478*M "*M $*:,2*M
<:B.5.@I*M -.M <9.:C< M
$% !"% ,C*BM -.M 7*M ,<94B4K:M =@<E3:,3*8M -.M DA+*;3B9<M -.M D*-*7*6*@* M
"% % % !#$% '($)%&M =<AM 9<C4E<BM /<@9*8.BM
'.1L:M B.M -.B=@.:-.M -.M 7*M -<,D9.:C*,3K:M ?D.M <+A*M .:M .8M .F=.-3.:C.M .:M /.,2*M M -.
*+@48M -.M M .8M *2<A*M @.,7*9*:C.M B<84,4CKM *M 7*M <:B.6.@J*M -.M <9.:C<M -.M 7*M D:C*M -.
<9D:4-*-.BM -.M *BC488*M #*M $*:,2*M *7M *9=*@<M -.M 8*M ".GM
M -.M M -.M -4,3.9+@.
-.M CA*:B>*@.:,4*M *,,.B<M *M 7*M 3:/<A9*,3K:M >L+74,*M HM +D.:M 0<+ 3.@:<M .:M *-.8*:C.
")M 8*M B41D3.:C.M 4:/<@9*,3K:M
L
- CC9A GHG #7* *A# E A% =L %C : . :L /'
K,05!L L (+L L
86B+38L (+L >"6B;!>+6&0"L JL F+6L 8$1+>68L L
I &86B+48)+D ?!6B<!@+6&2 !+BL
!
! !
! !
1a‹ RgaFKR‹ G‹ ziOFv‹ aFv‹ FKzFv‹ PR‹ aF‹ Kid[v[‰g‹ loi~[gK\Fa‹ OR‹ |pIFg[vdi‹ OR‹ 4|FOFaF_FoF‹
pRd\z\OFv‹ lip‹ bF‹ 0RbRWFK\‰g‹ :oi~[gL[Fa ‹ 89>-)‹ v[‹ U|RpF‹ KidlRzRgK\F‹ OR‹ izpi‹
ORlFpzFeRgzi‹ ORhaR‹ zoFvbFOi‹ ‹ K|RgzG‹ OR‹ Raai‹ F‹ d‡‹
*3!: ': 42!*#: !: /!2-4!23: : 24: 2,'#$34 : !(: 2,'$$3*3!: #+3!/-42,: 4+: /!()$8*
*3!: !': ,+2!%,: !: 0+2-/!+#: 6: 4!*: ,$!/+,: !*: !(+3!: : !(: : !: )6,
!: : ,*: +9)!/,: !: !5-! $!*3!: : !*: 24: 2! !: !'!3/8+#
': : !: )6,: !: : ! (: : /!)#3#8: (: 1!')$8+: : (: !/!3/7: !*!/(: !: (
,*2!&!/7: !: ,)!+3,: (: ,%!3,: !: .4!: 2!: -4 #!/+: -1!2!*30: (2: (!"$,+!2: .4!: 2!:
,+2# !/2!+: ,-,034+2
%& & & &
': : !: %4+$,: !: : 2!: /!$!: ,*3!23$8+: !: ': )#* $23/#8*: !+: (: .4!: 2!
-/!2!*3+: (2: '!"$,+!2: 2,($$3 2: 6: *,2: #+ #*
2g‹ LjhzRvzGL]‰g‹ F‹ v|‹ pRm|Rq]d]Rgzi‹ OR‹ (‹ OR‹ dFj‹ "‹ liq‹ dRO[i‹ PRb‹ m|S‹ wS‹ OF‹
zpFvaFOi‹ F‹ RvzF‹ =RKpRzFoˆF‹ 4RgRoFb‹ OR‹ aF‹ oRKaFdFK[‰g‹ [gzRol|RvzG‹ lio‹ 3RsFgOi‹
5GIigRoi‹ 9oGv\i‹ UoRgzR‹ F‹ aG‹ G|vRgK[F‹ OR‹ LihzRv{FL\‰g‹ lip‹ lFozR‹ OR‹ aG‹ 0[rRKK[Šg‹
4RgRpFa‹ OR‹ ;aFg[U[KFL[‰g‹ >Rop\zio[Fa‹ ‹ BoIFg\vdi‹ F‹ v|‹ via[K[z|O‹ OR‹ \gUipeFK[Šg‹ OR‹
URKZF‹ &‹ OR‹ FIq\a‹ OR‹ #‹ vR‹ Kie|g[KF‹
n
}R‹ O\KZF‹ 0\pRKK\‰g‹ 4RgToGb‹ z[RgR‹ l|Ia\LFOFv‹
bFv‹ FKzFx‹ OR‹ bFv‹ .id\v\igRv‹ OR‹ 9oORgFK[‰g‹ ORb‹ >Roo[zio[i‹ ‹ CoIFg[vdi‹ OR‹ aF‹ lpi~[gK[F‹
OR‹ 4}FOFbF`GoF‹ Rg‹ Ra‹ l†W]hF‹ SI‹ OSa‹ 4iI^Rti‹ OR‹ .Gv{\bbF6F‹ 7FgKZF‹
KigMqSzGdSgzR‹ Rg‹ Ra‹ w^W|]RgzR‹ RgaFKR)‹
Z{{lw*€KFw{[aaFaFdFhLZHRvWiI[Rti
V
ifRgziRvzr|L{|oFQ
Y
}GK{}FL\igR‹
v{SeHvzqHzFOivRhaFv."'-bz[eFvKjd]v]igRvORioORg HK[.#'"g„
ORbzRoo[zio\i|oIFg\vdi‹
1g‹ O\LZi‹ Z\lRo~‡gM|bi‹ FlGoSLSg‹ l|Ja]LGPGw‹ bFw‹ FL{Fv‹ zGhzi‹ OR‹ aF‹ .id[v^Šg‹ <R
X
^igFb‹
OS‹ 9oORgFK]‰g‹ ORa‹ ?Spo]zjo^j‹ ‚‹ BpIFh]wdi‹ Kidi‹ aFv‹ OR‹ aFv‹ /id[v]igRv‹ OS‹ LFOF‹
loi~[gK[F‹ OR‹ /Fvz\baF6F‹ 7FgKZF ‹ 1g‹ Ra‹ KFvk‹ PR‹ 4|FOFaF_FoF‹ vR‹ RgK|RgzpFg‹
P]wlig\IaRv‹ bFv‹ GK{Gv‹ ORwOR‹ Rb‹ $!%‹ ZFvzG‹ Ra‹ &(‹ -O[K[igGbeRgzR‹ ziOGv‹
aFv‹ FKzFv‹ OR‹ aFv‹ .id[v[ihRw‹ BoIFg‡vz[KFv‹ OR‹ aF‹ loi~\gK[F‹ OR‹ 4|FOFaF`FoG‹ vR‹
RgK|RgzoFh‹ l|Ia[KFOFv‹ Rg‹ cF‹ l†W[hG‹ RI‹ OR‹ :aFg[U\KFK[‰h‹ @oo[zip[Fa‹ ‹ BoIFg\vdi‹ bF‹
K}Fb‹ Rvz†‹ ~[gK|aFOF‹ Nih‹ Rb‹ ;iuFa‹ OR‹ AFgvlFoRgK[F‹ OR‹ .Fvz[bbF6F‹ 7FhKZF‹ ‹ K|iv‹
RgaFLRv‹ vR‹ oRd^zRh‹ F‹ Kig{[g|FK\‰g+‹ Z{{lv,|qIFh \vdiKFvz]aaFaFdFgMZFRvFKzFv…
Kid[w\igRy‹
Z{{lw*zoHgvlFqRgK[F‹ KFvz\aaGcFdFgKZF‹ Sv
l|Ib\K]OFOD‹ FL{\~F‹ ioORgFL[igD‹ ORaD‹zRoo\{‹
ip[i‹ E|oIFg\wdjE
ƒ
EdRO]jEFeI\RgzR‹
& & & $& "& & &
# ! &
*R (;9,;B8/)&)R (;9R 5;R )/D?F*DE;R *:R *6R &BEN(G6;R (R )*R 5&R #R JR *:R *5R &BEN(G5;R
)*5R "*&5R *(B*E;R R )*R R )*R ;(EF'B*R <;CR *5R @F*R D*R &=BG*'&R *5R DE&EFE;R )*6
;:D*2;R )*R $B&:D>&B*9(/&R KR F*9R ;'/*B9;R
R
R *5R B*D/)*9E*R )*R *DE&R &GE;B/)&)
&)8/90DEB&E0H&R 09)*?*9)0*9E*R *DR (;8?*E*9E*R ?&B&R B*D;5H*BR 6&DR B*(5&8&(0;9*DR AG*R *:R
&?6/(&(/P9R )*5R &CEO(F5;RR )*R 5&R $
D*R ?B*D*9E*9R +B*9E*R &R 5&DR B*D;5F(0;9*DR *I?B*D&DR
; ?C*DF9E&DRC*(&N)&DR *9R 8&E*B0&R )*R &((*D;R &R 5&R 09,;B8&(/P:
9R H/CEF)R )* 5R &=&BE&);R R )*R 5&R )/D<;D0(0P9R &)0(1;9&5R (G&BE&R )*R 6&R $R
R 6&D
(;8G:/)&)*DR &FEP9;8&DR ?G*)*:R &EB/'G/BR 6&R (;8?*E*9(/&R ?&C&R 6&R B*D;6G(0P9R )*R 5&DR
B*(6&8&(0;9*DR &6R $R 8*)0&9E*R 5&R (*5*'B&(/P9R )*6R (;BC*D?;9)0*9E*R (;9H*90;R (;9R 5&R
)8/:/D EC&(0P9R *9*B&5R )*5R DE&);R 9R )*D&BB;65;R )*R )0(.&R ?C*H0D/P9R *I/DE*R (;9H*9/;
H0-*9E*R DFD(B0E;R (;9R 5&DR (;8F91)&)*DR &GEP9;8&DR )*R DEFB/&DR &9E&'B /&R &R "/;3&R
IEB*8&)FB&R &DE055&&R &9(.&R *R 556*DR &5*&BDR &DNR (;8;R (;:R 5&DR (0F)&)*DR &FEP:;8&DR
)*R *FE&R JR *6/55&R
&R %R *9R DFR &BEO(F5;R
R B*-F5&R *5R )*B*(.;R )*R E;)&DR 5&DR ?*BD;9&DR &R &((*)*BR &R 5&
0:,;B8&(/P9R ?Q'5/(&R *:E*9)/)&R D*-Q9R *5R &BEN(G5;R R )*R 5&R 8/D8&R 9;B8&R (;8;R
!;BR 5;R E&:E;R 6&R 5*JR )*,/9*R *5R ;'4*E;R )*R F9&R D; 5/(/EF)R )*R &((*D;R &R 5&R /9,;B8&(0P9R *9
B*6&(/P9R (;9R /:+;B8&(/P9R AF*R J&R *I/DE*R ?;BR (F&9E;R *DELR *9R ?;D*D/P9R )*R F:R ;B-&90D8;
0:(6G/);R *9R DFR L8'0E;R )*R &?60(&(/P9R '/*:R ?;BAG *R M5R 80D8;R 5&R .&R *5&';B&);R '/*9R ?;BAF*
5&R .&R ;'E*9 /);R *9R *3*B(/(0;R )*R 6&DR +F9(/;9*DR JR (;8?*E*9(/&DR AG*R E/*:*R *9(;8*9)&)&D
9R *6R (&D;R )*R *DE&R B*(5&8&(/P9R 6&R 09+;B8&(0P9R D;6/(/E&)&R E0*9*R 5&R (;:D0)*B&(/P9R )*
09+;C8&(/P9R ?Q'6/(&R J&R AG*R ;'C&R *9R ?;)*CR )*R G9R DF3*E;R ;'6/-&);R ?;BR 5&R $R 5&
;9D*3*BN&R )*R ;8*9E;R )*R &DE/55&&R &9(.&R AF/*9R ) /D?;:*R )*R *56&R *9R *5R *3*C(0(/;R )*
5&DR +F9(0;9*DR AF*R E/*9*R 7*-&58*9E*R B*(;9;(/)&D
Pzzgv %‚ƒ‚ˆ ?dJJv?vB9oˆ 9 B| hPhˆ )RF'-51*z_'[h'7:#ˆ
P{{gw & ‚‚‚ ?eK Kw @wC;o;C{ hPi)RF'-1+##"i'$!{_(;ˆ
P zzjv %‚‚ ‚ ?eJ Jv ?vB9pˆ <Cz k Qkˆ )RF'-51*##"ˆ j'#!z_'ˆ [F9D:9ˆ
Pzzgv%‚ƒ‚Bd_vLXdG Jzo9_vh9oJ_BT9JxB|ˆ 3d]JJvzq9`vl:oJ_DS: gdqz 9\|o9`vh:oJ`BT:S`Ndr]:BTd`†
KCd_ Cd_K_TevCe_KaTdw//++ P }^ \ˆ
P {zjw &‚‚‚ ?eJ Jv? vB: pˆ: B{ h Q hˆ )RG'-51*##"ˆ {_'[m'#!:ˆ
6‡OUb=ˆ ˆ HMˆ ˆ
0fcyMYfˆ HMˆ 8s>cyn=sMcEU>ˆ …ˆ .€Mcˆ 2fAVMscfˆ,,4ˆ
„ Ef_yMZfIM~ t=_yj=uM_E W=Myˆ
!
5D 2 #)5D # . 2* 5D )D 03/ %-% .6/D D ' 2&%/D )D 3 $/D D 5/D D )
%."/2-&B.D 0C *%D 5 D/2.D .D )/5D 26?7 ) /5D
D
D )D D 50 &!&=./5
.D )D 26@7)/D
*/5D 0 +;/5D 02D )D 2 5/*7%B.D D )5D 5/+%&67 5D D %."/2-&B.
)D .6 2%/3D 03 06/D 5 D %."& 3 .D /5D /.5 & 2&/. 5D D 02&- 3D /.5&56 D .D )
9&56 .%D D 7.D 3 #)D 02/ &- .6*D 50 ?"%D 0)&) D D 17 )+/5D 5/5D
/.5% 2) 5D 5/)&%67 5D D &.!/2-&B.D .D 6 .&B.D D 57D 8/)7- .D /D /-0) (%D .
! 6/D .D *D 5 #7./D 0=32"/D *D 26@7)/D D D )D D 5 D 02 8>D 17 D 7./
/.722D )D 5707 56/D D $ $/D D 17 D )D 8/*7- .D /D )D /-0+ (&D D )D %."/3-&B.
17 D 5 D 5/)%&6D 5?D */D $#.D . 52%/D :D 02 8&D ./6&"%%B.D *D 5/)&%6.6 D +
/.5 7 .&D (72@&D 5 2=D 17 D )D -&.&562&B.D 0C*&D 17 D D 2 5/+8 2D +D 5/)&&67
D 5/D D )D %."/2-&B.D 6& . D )D 0/5&&)&D D -0)%2D )D 0+</D D 7.D - 5D *D 17
%50/. D 03D &62D :D ./6&"%2D )D 2 5/)7&B.D 0/2D /62/D - 5D &%/.)D .D 56 D 5/D ./D 5
0*&BD *D -0)%&B.D )D 0);/D D D 3 5 A2D 6)D :D /-/D 5 D 7 D D )/5
.6 .6 5D 17 D /2.D .D )D 90 % .6 D D -//D 17 D )D - &.&562&B.D &50/.?D
7.D - 5D 02D &62D :D ./6%"&2D *D 2 5/)7%B.D .D -6 2%D D 5/D D )D &."/2-%B.
5/)&%6
D 5 #7.D /.5 7 .&D 17 D 5 D 3%8D *D 5 A)/D 02 06/D 17 D #72D 2 )%B.D /.
)D .6 2&/2D /.5&56 D .D 17 D *D 26@7)/D D 2 " 2 .&D 8&.7+D +D /-% .;/D )D B-076/
)D 0)</D D 7.D - 5D )D 17 D &50/. D *D -&.&562&B.D 02D 2 5/*8 2D - &.6
2 5/ ) 7%B.D 902 5D /D 0/2D 5&) .&/D -%.%5626&8/D D +D " $D .D 17 D *D 5/) &&67D 6 .#
.62D .D )D 2 #&562/D *D B3#./D /-0 6 .6 D 02D 4 5/)8 3D .D *D 5/D D 56
2 *-%B.D 6)D " $D 2D )D D D 2&)D D D D -. 2D 17 D )D B2#./D /-0 6 .6
%50/.@D D 7.D - 5D 02D %63D :D ./6&!&2D )D /22 50/.% .6 D 2 5/*7&B.
#C.D /.56D .D *D 90 & .6 D D )D 2 )-&B.D *D /.5 ( 2@D D /- .6/D $
02/0/2&/./D )D &.!/4-&B.D 5/*%%6D )D D D (7.&/D D D .D 56/5D 5/5D .D 17
)D &."/2-&B.D 5 D /. D 0 2/D "7 2D *D 0)</D 56* &/D .D )D D 02/
56%-2D )D 2 )-&B.D 0).6 D 0/2D -/6&8/5D !/4-* 5D )D $ 25 D 87). 2/D *
2 $/D )D 5/)%%6.6 D D /6 . 2D 7.D 2 5/)7&B.D .D *D 0);/D -=9&-/D ) #*- .6
56* &/D $% ./D5%/D . 52%/D 02 5 .62D 7.D 2 )-%B.D .6 D *D D 02D 8 2
0, .- .6 D2 /./&/D 57D 3 $/
c
<\\JU ___c /G8 8U/ ] U 2+Qc + 2Y J<Kc =5"(% c YDCJ+c
c
<\\LV
___c /H99V 0]V3,Qc ,3Z L < Mc =5"(% c ZDCN,
<\\LU___c /G88W/]V2+Qc
+2YL<Kc =5"(% c YDCL+c
)b
;
>E-c c 6:c c
$IFX:
A
Ic 6:c *R.FX
O
-R:F4>.c
ac
#^:Fc &I1?:RFIc !!'c
` 4IFX:
B
I7:[ S-FX
P
-T:F4 @-:Xc
;U (F,;*2S;U (U 8<EU (;F,*,+,;F,EU JU -H;+(:,;F<EU 5HAQ+2*<EU +,E*A2F<EU =A<*,+,U
8(U A,*8(:(*3S;U =A,E,;F(+(U -A,;F,U (U 9(U <;E,6,CR(U +,U <:,;F<U +,U
8(U H;F(U +,U <:H; 2+(+,EU+,U (EF298((U !(;*1( U
,U (*H,A+<U *<;U ,8U (AFR*H8<U U ;T:,A<U U +,U 8(U ,KU
+,U U +,U +2*3,:)A,U +,U
FA(;E>(A,;*2(U (**,E<U (U 9(U 2;-<A:(*3S;U >T)82*(U LU )H,;U / <) 2,A;<U
9(U A,*9(:(*2S;U
=A,I2EF(U ,;U ,8U (AFR*H8<U U +,U 8(U :2E:(U F2,;,U 8(U *<;E2+,A(*3S;U +,U EHEF3FHF2I(U +,U 8<EU
A,*HAE<EU (+:2; 2EFB(F2I<EU +,U *<;.<A:2+(+U *<;U 8<U +3E=H,EF<U ,;U ,9U (AGQ*H8<U U +,U 8(U ,KU
+,U U +,U <*FH)A,U +,U #A<*,+2:3,;F<U +:3;3EFA(F3I<U <:T;U +,U 9(EU
+:2;2EFC(*2<;,EU #T)82*(E
<;FB(U 9(U =A,E,;F,U A,E<8H*2S;U ?H,U =<;,U .3;U (U 8(U IQ(U (+:3;2EFA(F3I(U E,U =<+COU 3;F,A=<;,AU
A,*HAE<U *<;F,;*2<E<(+:3;2EFA(F3I<U ,;U ,8U =9(M<U +,U +<EU :,E,EU +4A,*F(:,;F,U (;F,U 8(U
%( 8(U +,U 9<U <;F,;*2<E<(+:2;2EFA(F2I<U +,U 8(U H+2,;*2(U "(*3<;(9U +,U *<;.<A:3+(+U *<;U 8<U
=A,I3EF<U ,;U ,9U (>(AG(+<U @H2;F<U +,U 9(U 3E><E3*2S;U (+2*2<;(8U *H(DF(U +,U 8(U ,KU
+,U
U +,U 7H92<U $,/H8(+<A(U +,U 9(U HB2E+2**2S;U <;F,;*2<E<(+:3;2EFA(F3I(
U
U #$%"&U U 'U
+< U <EPU H2EU $<+CR0H,MU N8I(A,MU
@\\NY ccc3K<<Y 3aY6.T .6\N@N"B9!%(# ]H!N!.g
@\^OZ ccc3L==Z4aZ7/Ug 07\ P@Qg "B9!%+(#_H!gP!/g g
@\^OY cc c3K< <Y3aZ6.Tg .6\g OAQg "B9!%+(#]H!g O!.g
,f?CI1g g :>g g
'MJ[>FMg :>g -V2J[R1V>J8C2g eg &b>Jg )M5D>VJMg $$*g
d 8MH[>GM;>` W1H[S1X>H8E 1>[g