El interesado solicitó acceso a información sobre el uso de fondos europeos en el marco de la Estrategia de Desarrollo Local en el Ayuntamiento de Alcorocos. Tras una respuesta insuficiente, el Consejo de Transparencia y Buen Gobierno estima la reclamación, obligando al ayuntamiento a facilitar la información solicitada.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
El derecho de acceso a la información pública prevalece sobre la alegación de que la información se encuentre en proceso de elaboración si no se acredita un perjuicio real.
2
La administración no justificó adecuadamente la denegación, limitándose a alegar que la información estaba en fase de redacción sin aportar pruebas de dicha circunstancia.
3
El Consejo determina que la solicitud es concreta y no requiere una reelaboración desproporcionada por parte del organismo.
4
Se concluye que la respuesta del Ayuntamiento fue evasiva y no dio cumplimiento al derecho de acceso al no proporcionar los datos solicitados.
Texto completo
% D8A)L L
% %L ()L 1%L *.<4%L
"%
$%
!"$ !% EB5A%4/)5A7L ()L )I%4)12)=%L 1A%L @AB<.%@ L
$%!"% .@A%(7L ()L %(4.A.(7@L EL )D'1B/(7@L )5L )1L 8<7')@7L '75C7'%(7L 8%<%L
'B&<.<L 1%@L C%'%5A)@L ()L B)HL ()L %HL #.AB2%=L EL ()L B)HL ()L %HL "[email protected] ()L )I%4)31)<%L
1A%L
"% % % !#$% "$#!L 87=L 47A.C7@L *7<4%2)@ L
")+K5L @)L ()@8>)5()L ()L 1%L (7'B4)6A%'/J5L ;B)L 7&<%L )5L )1L )D8)(.)5A)L )5L *)'-%L L ()
(/'.)4&<)L ()L L )2L <)'2%4%6A)L @71/'/AJL %1L %48%<7L ()L 1%L )FL L ()L L ()
(/'.)4&<)L ()L A<%6@9%<)5'/%L %'')@7L %L 2%L .5*7<4%'.J5L :K&10'%L GL &B)5L ,7&.)?57
)5
%()1%5A)L #L %1L EB5A%4.)6A7L ()L )I%4)22)=%L 1A%L 1%L @.+B.)5A)L .5*7<4%'/J5
& & & & & & & & $& & & & #& & #& &
%& & & & & & & & & "& & & & & &
& & & & & & & & & & & & &
& "& !& & & &
O
0 FF<D JKJ &:- -D& H D(# @O# (F =1=O 2*
!N/38$O O +.O O
;9E.6;O +.O "A%9E>$A.9)3%O MO I.9O ;'4.A9;O O
L );9E.7;,.G B$9E?$C.9)5 $.EO
O
!
! !
! !
?K0X ;,X ,LJ0?.6,X /0X G0JAL0JK,X ,X JLX J@;5.5KL/X 0;X J@;6.5K,?K0X AG0J0?KVX /0X ,.L0G/@X .@?X ;@
/6JAL0JK@X 0?X 0;X ,GKS.L<@X X
X
/0X ;,X #* X L?,X H0.;,>,.6V?X ,?K0X 0;X @?J08@X /0
*G,?JA,G0?.6,X OX L0?X @-50G?@X 0?X ,/0;,?K0X *X 0;XX /0X ,-G6<X /0X X .@?X ?W>0G@
/0X 0NA0/60?K0X
<X X /0X ,-G5;X /0X X 0;X *X G0>5K5VX <,X G0.;,>,.6V?X ,X ;,X )0.G0K,GT,X 0?0G,;X *R.?6.,
/0;X OL?K,>50?K@X /0X '0U,>0;<0H,X ;K,X ,<X @-90K@X /0X EL0X A@GX 0<X VG2,?@X .@>A0K0?K0
AL/50G,?X AG0J0?K,GJ0X <,JX ,;02,.6@?0JX EL0X J0X .@?J5/0G,J0?X @A@GKL?,J
<X X /0X >,O@X /0X X J0X G0.6-0X .@?K0JK,.6V?X ,;X H0EL0G6>50?K@X /0X ,<02,.6@?0JX H0,<5Q,/@
EL0X 5?.;LO0X L?X 0J.H5K@X /0;X )0.H0K,G6@!?K0GM0?K@GX 6?K0G5?@X /0<X OL?K,>50?K@X /0
'0U,>0<;0G,X ;K,X /0X X /0X >,O@X /0X X 0?X 0;X EL0X J0X 3,.0X .@?JK,GX EL0X ;,X AL-;6.,.5V?
/0;X [email protected]@X /0X 0<0..5V?X /0X "L0QX /0X ',QX 1L0X H0,<5Q,/,X 0?X 0<X @;0KS?X &16.5,;X /0;X 'G6?.5A,/@
/0X JKLG5,JX )0X ,/8L?K,X ,J5>5J>@X ;,X /@.L>0?K,.5V?X .@GG0JA@?/50?K0X ,X ;,JX .,?/5/,KLG,J
AG0J0?K,/,J
0X .@?1@G>5/,/X .@?X ;@X /5JAL0JK@X 0?X 0;X ,GKT.L;@X .X /0X ;,X #* X OX 0?X 0<X ,GKS.L<@X
/0;X (0,;X 0.G0K@X X /0X X /0X @.KL-G0X B@HX 0;X FL0X J0X ,CGL0-,X 0;X JK,KLK@X /0<
@?J0:@X /0X *H,?JD,G0?.5,X PX L0?X @-50H?@X
X
X 0<X 'G0J7/0?K0X /0X 0JK,X LK@G5/,/
/>5?5JKH,K5M,X ?/0A0?/ 50?K0X 0JX .@>A0K0?K0X A,G,X G0J@<M0GX ;,JX G0.;,>,.6@?0JX EL0X 0?
,A<5.,.5V?X /0<X ,GKS.L;@X X /0X ;,X $+ X J0X AG0J0?K0?X 1H0?K0X ,X ;,JX H0J@<L.6@?0JX 0NAI0J,J
@ AH0JL?K,JX H0.,S/,JX 0?X >,K0G6,X /0X ,..0J@X ,X <,X 6?1@G>,.6V?
?X M5HKL/X /0;X ,D,GK,/@X X /0X ;,X /[email protected]?X ,/6.5@?,;X .L,GK,X /0X =,X #*!X
X <,J
.@>L?5/,/0JX ,LKV?@>,JX AL0/0?X ,KG5-L5IX <,X .@>A0K0?.5,X A,H,X <,X G0J@<L.6V?X /0X ;,J
G0.<,>,.6@?0JX ,<X *X >0/6,?K0X ;,X .0;0-G,.5V?X /0<X .@GH0JA@?/60?K0X .@?M0?6@X .@?X ;,
/>5?5JKH,.6V?X 0?0G,;X /0;X JK,/@X ?X /0J,GG@<;@X /0X /6.3,X AH0M6J5V?X 0N5JK0X .@?M0?5@
M620?K0X JLJ.G6K@X .@?X ;,JX .@>L?6/,/0JX ,LKV?@>,JX /0X JKLG5,JX ,?K,-G 5,X #,X (5@8,
NKG0>,/LG,X ,JK6;<,$,X %,?.4,X 0X <;<0JX ,;0,GJX ,JSX .@>@X .@?X ;,JX 6L/,/0JXLKV?@>,J
/0X 0LK,X OX %0<5;;,
€
M ssao #
{{{ <^GGo <xo?6i€ 6 ?s bNb€ 'OC%*2.("" €sY%Va%"6
€
M stc o #
{{{ <^H H o
<xo?6i€ 7 ?s d N d€ 'OC%*2.(sY%V c%46"
Mstep${{{ =_H Hq
=xp@7i€
7@s b N f€ 'OC&*2.(""!€ f&"uY%€ VC8@y88
Mss c o #
{{{ ?^YpI T^DGsi6Yo c 9iGY?P6 Go As€ 0^XGGosi6Zoc6iGY?P6
g
^n9Wvi6[oc6iGZ?P6P[K^jX6?P^[~
G?_Y@^YzGYP^o?^YzHYP^o,,(( MsX W€
3
L
Q\:€ € EJ€ €
-`]rJ
U
`€ EJ€ 5k;]r
h
:kJ]BQ;€
}€
+yJ]€ /`>RJk]`€ ))1€
| B`]rJT`FJw l :]rc:mJ]B S:Jr€
&T $T *;T ADT &?BN(D4<T
?*-D4&T *4T )*?*(.<T )*T B<)&AT 4&AT =*?A<;&AT &T &((*)*?T &T 4&
0;,<?:&(1R;T =S'41(&T *;B*;)1)&T A*-S;T *4T &?BO(E4<T T )*T 4&T :1A:&T ;<?:&T (<:<T
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
*T &(D*?)<T (<;T *5T (0B&)<T &?BN(D4<T T )*T 6&T $T (&'*T (<;(5D1?T >D*T 4&T 0;,<?:&(1R;
A<41(0C&)&T )*'*T (<;A0)*?&?A*T ! ! =D*AC<T >E*T <'?&?O&T *;T =<)*@T )*T E;
AD2*B<T <'41-&)<T =<?T 4&T $T *5T HD;B&:1*;C<T )*T "*Q&:*55*@&T 7C&T >E1*;T )1A=<;*T )*
*45&T *;T F0?CE)T )*T 5<T *AC&'4*(0)<T *;T *5T &?CO(D4<T T )*5T (D*?)<T )*T T )*T 2D;1<T )*T T )*5
"4*;<T )*5T <;A*3<T *;*?&5T )*4T "<)*@T D)0(1&8T =<?T *4T >E*T A*T <?)*;&T 5&T =D'51(&(1R;T )*T 5<A
#*-4&:*;C<AT )*T 5&T &??*?&T D)1(0&6T )*T 5&T A(D*4&T D)1(0&4T )*T 4<AT E*(*AT )*T "&IT )*T 5<A
K?-&;<AT )*T <'1*?;<T )*T $?1'D;&4*AT HT )*T 4<AT A=*(C<AT ((*A<?0<AT )*T 6&AT (BD&(1<;*A
D)1(0&4*AT &AOT (<:<T )*T 4&T ?*6&(1R;T )*T +1(/*?<AT )*T (&?L(C*?T =*?A<;&6T *G0AC*;B*AT *;T *5
<;A*3<T *;*?&5T )*5T "<)*?T D)1(1&4T
!&AT ?*-4&AT -*;*?&5*AT )*4T =?<(*)0:0*;C<T )*T *2*?(1(0<T )*4T )*?*(.<T )*T &((*A<T &T 6&
0;,<?:&(1R;T =S'51(&T A*T &'<?)&;T *;T 4<AT &?BO(E 4<AT
&T
)*T 4&T %T *A=*(1+1(L;)<A*
*;T *4T &?BN(D4<T
4<AT =4&J<AT =&?&T 5&T ?*A<4E(1R;T )*T 4&AT A<50(0BE)*AT )*T 1;+<?:&(1R;
*4T &;C*?0<?T =?*(*=C<T A*T 0;,1*?*;T )<AT (<;A1)*?&(1<;*AT &T =?1:*?&T (<;A1AB*T *;T 4&
*G1AB*;(0&T )*T D;&T ?*-4&T =?<(*)1:*;C&5T *A=*(O,0(&T &=41(&'4*T &T &>E*46<AT (&A<AT )*
(<;A0)*?&'4*AT A<41(0CD)*AT )*T 1;+<?:&(0R;T *;T &B*;(1R;T &T ADT F<9E:*;T <T (<:=4*31)&)T ;
*+*(C<T *;T *5T A*-D;)<T =L??&,<T )*5T &?BN(D4<T T )*T 4&T $T A*T =?*FMT >D*T (D&;)<
(<;(D??&T *4T AD=E*AC<T )*T .*(.<T )*T >D*T *4T F<5D:*;T <T 4&T (<:=5*31)&)T )*T 4&T 0;,<?:&(1R;
>D*T A*T A<40(1C&T &APT 5<T .&-&;T ;*(*A&?1<T HT =@*F 1&T ;<C1,0(&(1R;T &5T A<61(1C&;B*T 4&
(<;A*(E*;(1&T 3D?N)1(&T A*?LT >D*T 4&T &):1;1AC?&(1R;T =S'51(&T >D*T )*'*T ?*A<6F*?T 6&T A<41(1BE)
)*T &((*A<T &T 4&T 0;,<?:&(1R;T C1*;*T 4&T =<A1'141)&)T )*T &:=40&?T *6T =6&I<T )*T D;T :*AT )*5T >D*
)0A=<;*T =&?&T )1(C&?T HT ;<C1,0(&?T 4&T ?*A<4D(1R;T =<?T <B?<T :*AT &)1(0<;&4T ;T *AC*T (&A<T ;<T A*
&=51(RT 5&T &:=40&(1R;T )*4T =4&I<T &(&'&)&T )*T ?*A*Q&?T B&4T HT (<:<T A*T )*)D(*T )*T 4<A
&;B*(*)*;C*AT >D*T <'?&;T *;T *4T *G=*)0*;C*T )*T :<)<T >D*T 4&T &):1;1AB?&(1R;T ) 1 A=<;O&T )*
%°
b šš„– - ¤¤¤
P€[
[– PŸ–SK° K Sš
…c…° 2dW06D<3!))'° šz
p„
)&K
6D<3,,#'° 3T [‘W° W[° '° W[°
k
¡{e° X[° ,,#
°
W[q° Eq[z° X[q° 9z—[
l
€° ?\|[Lr° W[r° E€X[‘° BŸXdSeLv
°
†° [s°
¢[° –[° €X[}K° qL° „ŸPtfSKTe®z° W[° q€–° H[_qKx[zš€–° X[° sK° :K[’K° CŸWgTgKw
X[° qK° =–SŸ[sK° BŸXgSeLw
W[° q€–° B¢[S[–°W[°
EK©
W[° q‚–° ª`K|€–° W[° ?Pd[z° W[° IeQŸzKq[–° §° W[° q–° 3–†[Uš—° 3TS[–e€–° W[° qL—° 3Tš¡LSdz[—° BŸWeTeKq[–° L–°
Ty‚° X\° qK° [qLTe®z° X[° ^eSb\’€—° W\° SK’«Sœ[’° ‡\—zLq° [¦e—›[z›[—° \z° [q° 9z—[
m
° ?[{[’Kq° W[q° FW\‘° B XfUfLr°
*°
b ššˆ– .¤¤¤° Q€[ [–Q Ÿ — TK° L Sœ …b…° 2eW17D>4"))(° š{1u…
)&K° (°
bšš‰˜-
¤¤¤° Q€\[–QŸ—TK° LS ‰ b Š° 2eW
6D>3"))'° š{1u
‹
)&L°
bœš
Œ
— / ¤¤ ¤ Q\ [—
PŸ—TK‘° M T‰b…° 2 eX
6D< 3 ! )+'° z
u‰
)&L°
G¬
a
h~N° ° Y]° $°
;Ī]
n
ƒ° Y]° J“O™
N“]VhO°
¨°
8£]° @ƒRi]“ƒ° 55A°
¥ Vƒ™]
ƒZ]ž ” Nz™
Ž
N•]}V jN]™°
¯°
!
:0G /"8G 25G !) 95G =G 019*#) 5G ,G 5"81-: *E0G "0G /9"5*G !"G "81G G -G )0#15/ *E0G
81-) *9!G
G 8"%:0!G 108" :"0 )G 4:"G 8"G !"6*;G !",G 8"D-!1G 25" "291G 4:"G %:5!G 5"- *E0G 10G
-G 09"5)15G 108)89"G "0G 4:"G ",G 59B :-1G !"G 5"#"5"0 )G ;)0 :-G ".G 1/*"0@1G !"-G E/2:91G
!"-G 2-@1G !"G :0G /"8G !"-G 4:"G !)8210"G ,G !/)0)895 )E0G 25G 5"81,;"5G /"!)09"G
5"81 -: *E0G "<25"8G 1G 215G 8)-"0 )1G !/*0)8959*;1G G -G #" 'G "0G 4:"G -G 81-) *9:!G 9"0%G
"095!G "0G "-G 5"%)8951G !",G E6%01G 1/2"9"09"G 25G 7"81,;"6G 0G "-G 81G !"G "89G
5" ,/ *E0G 9-G #" (G "5G "-G G !"G !) )"/5"G !"G G !"G /0"5G 4:"G ",G E5%01G
1/2"9"09"G !)8210BG !"G :0G /"8G 26G !) 95G =G 019)#* 5G ,G 155"8210!)"09"G 5"81-: )E0G
"%F0G 1089G "0G "-G "<2"!*"09"G "0G /=1G !"G G 8"G (G 2:"891G G !*8218* )E0G !",G
5" ,/09"G 91!G ,G !1 :/"09 )E0G 4:"G )09"%6G ",G 261 "81G !"G "," )E0G !"G :"@G !"G @G
!"G "D/"--"6G ,9G (*"0!1G 8*!1G !"/A8G 2:-* !1G "89"G 251 "81G "0G "-G 1-"9B0G
#* )-G !",G 5)0 )2!1G !"G 89:5)8G 215G ,1G 4:"G 8"G "89)/G 4:"G 8"G (G !!1G 89*8$ )E0G G -G
81-) *9:!G !"G )0#15/ )E0G 25"8"09!G
0G "8918G 818G "0G 4:"G 91!G -G )0#16/ )E0G 8"G 10 "!"G 2"51G #:"5G !",G 2,@1G "89," )!1G
"0G -G G 251 "!"G "89)/5G ,G 6" -/ )E0G 2,09"!G 215G /19*;18G $16/-"8G -G
("58"G ;:,0"5!1G "-G !"6" (1G !"-G 81,* )909"G G 19"0"7G !) (G )0$15/ *E0G !1 :/"09,G
!"0951G !",G 2-@1G /A<*/1G -"%,/"09"G "89-" *!1G ( )"0!1G 8)!1G 0" "85)1G 25"8"095G
:0G 5" -/ )E0G 09"G "-G G 25G ;"5G 2-"0/"09"G 5" 101 )!1G 8:G !"5" '1G
0G 9"0 )E0G G -18G 09" "!"09"8G =G $:0!/"0918G +:5B!) 18G !"8 5)918G 251 "!"G
-G 6" ,/ *E0G 25"8"09!G
"G :"5!1G 10G "-G 59B :,1G
0F/"51G
!"G ,G ">G
!"G G !"G !* )"/5"G !"G
950836"0 )G "81G G ,G )0$15/ *E0G 3F,) G ?G :"0G &1 )"501G
G -G 5" ,/ )E0
25";*89G "0G ",G 59C :-1G G !"G -G /*8/G 9)"0"G ,G 108)!"5 )E0G !"G 8:89*9:9);G !"G -18G
5" :5818G !/*0)8959*;18G !"G 10#15/)!!G 10G ,1G !)82:"891G "0G ".G 59C :,1G G !"G -G ">G
!"G G !"G 1 9:5"G !"G 71 "!)/*"091G !/)0)8969*;1G 1/F0G !"G -8G
!/)0*896 *10"8G F,) 8
G
2JJ?H OOO'=..H'MH)#DT $)JT ?2@T 3+ T K:T 9@#T
2JJ?H OO O'=. /H'MH)#DT $)J ?2AT 3+ K:T 9?#T T
!R14;%T T ,0T T
><I07>T ,0T "E&<IB%E0<*4&T QT N0<T >(50E<>T T
P *><I08>-0L F%<IC%G0<*6 %0IT
ST
31>9!I -!I 4:$=$2>$I :$=3.?")H2I 7?$I 432$I%(2I !I .!I @F!I !#0(2)=>:!>(@!I =$I 43#;DI (2>$:432$:I
:$"?:=3I "32>$2")3=3!#0(2)=>:!>(@3I $2I $.I 4-!B3I #$I #3=I 0$=$=I #)<$">!0$2>$I !2>$I .!I
!.!I #$I -3I 32>$2")3=3!#0)2)=>:!>)@3I #$I .!I ?#)$2")!I !"*32!-I #$I "32%3:0)#!#I "32I .3I
4:$@(=>3I $2I $-I !5!:>!#3I 8?)2>3I #$I .!I (=63=(")H2I !#)")32!.I "?!<>!I #$I /!I $AI I #$I
I #$I ,?-)3I $&?.!#3:!I #$I -!I ?9)=#)""+H2I 31>$2")3=3!#0(2)=>:!>(@!
I
I I I I
#3I 3=EI ?)=I 3#;G'?$BI C.@!:$BI
Q
0GG=E LL L&;- -E&JE("AQ #(GQ=0>Q 1*H8Q 7="
O/29$Q Q +.Q Q
<:F.5<Q +.Q !B%:F?$B.:)2%Q NQ K.:Q <'3.B:<Q Q
M )<:F.6<,.I C$:F@$D.:)4 $.FQ
PQ