El ciudadano solicitó acceso a información sobre la gestión de subvenciones y contratos en el Ayuntamiento de Alcorcón. Tras la denegación de la administración, el Consejo de Transparencia Española estima la reclamación, obligando al Ayuntamiento a facilitar la información solicitada.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
El derecho de acceso a la información pública es la regla general, debiendo interpretarse los límites de forma restrictiva.
2
La administración no puede denegar la información basándose en la existencia de datos personales si es posible anonimizarlos.
3
La solicitud de información no puede ser considerada repetitiva o abusiva si el solicitante persiste en obtener datos que no han sido facilitados correctamente.
4
El Ayuntamiento de Alcorcón no justificó adecuadamente la denegación de la información, limitándose a alegar la protección de datos sin aplicar la técnica de anonimización.
Texto completo
JK
!
!
! ! !
# @6=(H H
# $H '(H /$H ).93$H
"#
"
# A>4=$3.(4=5H '(H D&(9(<H
"# # 4*5:3$&-E4H ;(0$&-54$'$H &54H >4H 4>(?5H ><5H '(1H ('-).&.5H '(0H
$4=-+>5H (4=:5H (4-=(4&.$;-5H '(H D&(:(< H
# # # !"# !"" H 659H 35=.?5<H )5:3$1(<H
!(+F4H <(H '(<69(4'(H '(H 0$H '5&>3(4=$&.E4H 8>(H 5%9$H (4H (1H (@6('-(4=(H 1$H 9(&1$3$4=(
<50-&-=EH $0H $36$95H '(H 0$H (BH H '(H H '(H '-&-(3%9(H '(H =9$4<7$9(4&-$H $&&(<5H $H 0$
.4)5:3$&-E4H 7G%0.&$H CH %>(4H ,5%-(945H
(4H $'(1$4=(H #H $2H A>4=$3.(4=5H '(
D&(9(<H (0H H '(H '-&.(3%9(H '(H H 0$H <-+>-(4=(H.4)5;3$&-E4
*5 #*()'5 ($3#5 !!+5 (5 5 2$(5 ($!)#$5 &*5 !5 $5 !5 #)*$5
#)'$5 #)#'$5 5 /'(5 #)*5 '(3#5 '$+#!5 5 /'(5 ()*$5 #5 !5
+#50'$(5 5 !'5 (5 $#+')5 #5*#5#)'$5 "$'!5 5 ))*!'5 %4!5
$'5 )$$5 !!$5 ,5
!5 "%'$5 !5 ')1*!$5 5 -5 (*#)(5 5 !5 -5 5 5 5 5 "'5 5
'#(%'#5 ($5 5 !5 #$'"3#5 %4!5 -5 *#5 $'#$5 $#5 (5 '$#$5
-5 '#).5 !5 '$5 5 ($5 5 !5 #$'"3#5 %4!5
K
,AA7> EFE !5( (>!C>%;K %A8,8K -&
I+.3 K K ')K K
64?)16K '*K< 3?9 <)4#. K HK D*3K 6"/)<36KK
E
G$64@)26')B= 4?: <)4$0 )?K
D ,D -0 2/D #$,D 26@"7,/D D :D 5(&7($.6$5D #$D , D $:D D #$D D #$D - :/D #$D /!($3/D
!($4/D #$D 962$- #72 D 17$D 2$"/./"$D :D & 2 .6(< D $,D -+-/D #$2$"'/D #$D ""$5/D D , D
(.%/2- "(A.D0B!,(" D
D
$D 5$ D % "(,(6 # D 8@ D 6$,$-=6(" D ,D "/22$/D $,$"62A.("/D -=5D 22(! D -$."(/. #/D , D
#/"7-$.6 "(A.D #-(.(562 6(8 D &$.$2 # D 02/:$"6/5D (.%/2-$5D"/-7.(" "(/.$5D $6"D
#$5#$D $,D :7.6 -($.6/D #$D ="$2$5D 2$, "(/. # D "/.D 7. D 0/5(!,$D 2$76(,(< "(A.D ;/D 7.D
.7$8/D 75/D #$,D $#*)"(/D #$,D .6(&7/D$.62/D$.(6$."( 2(/D #$D >"$2$5D
#Ui>~ N2~ 2lg>U7G3~ :>~ a>g\l>gi2~ 4~ >gi4~ gZOF7Gim:~ N2~ gZNG7Fi2Vi>~ ]a>g>Ui{~ mU2~ a>7N2R27G{W
2Uj>~ ?N~ &ZWg>MZ~ ;>~ 0a2Ug\2a>W8G2~ s~ %n>U~ )Z5G>cWZ~ >U~ 2:>O2Ui>~ &0%)~ ?O~ ~ <>~ 46bHN
:>~ ~ a>C Fgia2:2~ 7ZU~ U}R>cZ~ :>~ >r\>:G>Ui>~
'N~ ~ :>~ R2sZ~ =>~ ~ >N~ &1%)~ a>RFiF{~ N3~ a>7O2R37F{U~ 2~ O2~ />7a>i2ax2~ )>W>a2O~ :>O
#smUj2RF>UiZ~ :>~ &v7?c>g~ 2N~ Z6M>iZ~ :>~ ^m>~ \l:F>a2U~ \a>g>Ui2a~ N2g~ 2 Q>C27FZU>g~ _l>~ g>
7ZUgF:?a2g>U~ Z\ZdilU3g
$% % % %
'O~ ~ :>~ R2sZ~ ;>~ ~ g?~ a>7F6>~ ZAF7GZ~ :>O~ />7a>i2aGZ~ ;>O~ #smUi3RF>Wi[~ `o>~ a?AF>c>~ _m>
?N~ ~ :>~ 26aFN~ g>~ D2~ d>RGjH:Z~ P2~ :Z7mR>Ui27F{U~ ;Gg][UF6P>~ 2~ O2~ 2gZ8G27G{U~ gZNF7Fi2Ui>~ 2N
7m2O~ g>~ 2U?r3U~ <Zg~ FWB[aR>g~ a?O>q2Ui>g ~ mU~ FUBZaR?~ 1w7UF7Z~ <>Q~ ua>2~ :>~ '<FAL727F{U~ s
-2Ui>UHRH>UjZ~ AGcR2:Z~ ]Zc~ 2a_lFj>7j[~ ;FcFCF:[~ 2~ N2~ />7c>i2cx2 ~ :>~ ~ :>~ :F7H>R6c>~ :>
"~ s~ lU~ FXAZaS>~ :>~ O2~ />87H{U~ ;>~ *Uq>Uj2aIZ~ ;>~ ~ :>~ R2tZ~ ;>~
'U~ ?N~ GUBZcR>~ iw7WF7[~ :>N~ 3a^m Fi>7i[~ RmUF7F]2O~ g>~ :>i2NQ2U~ NZg~ gm7?gZg~ >U~ c>N47F|U~ 2~ mW
]ZgG6N>~ Wl>qZ~ lgZ~ :>N~ FURn>5O>~ :>g;>~ ~ RZR?UiZ~ >U~ ^m>~ g>~ 62c2M|~ N2~ 7>gJ{U~ :>N
GWRm>6N>~ 2N~ 2spWk2RH>Ui[~ ]Zc~ \2aj?~ :>~ O2~ /Z7G>:2;~ ;>~ +YAd2?hkel7jla2h~ s
(_lF\2RH>WjZg~ .?UGi>U7F2bFZg~ /#~ /,(. E2hi2~ "~ s~ h>~ 27ZR\2z2U~ 2N~ RFgSZ~ lW
GWAZaT>~ ]f>qF[~ _l>~ Am>~ a@RFiG:Z~ 2~ N2~ $N72O:y3~ >U~ ~ s~ lU3~ ->R[dG2~ :@~ A>6a>aZ~ ;@
~ _l>~ GV8Nms>~GWAZaR27K{U~ :>g8aF\iFq2~ s~ CavAG83
.Za~ ZicZ~ O2;[~ >U~ >O~ JUAZaS>~ g[6a@~ O2~ hGil28F{W~ Mmax:G92~ N2~ h>88G{U~ ;>~ LUq>Ui2aFZ~ \d@8Gg3
NZ~ gGClG@Wi@!
D D D 5$D (.%/2- D
,D $#(%("(/D #$,D .6(&7/D $.62/D $.(6$."( 2(/D #$D ="$2$5D 5(6/D $.D , D 8$.(# D ?2/$5D
#$D ,$2D .CD ./D "/.56 D $.D $,D .8$.6 2(/D 7.("(0 ,D
/.57,6 #/5D # 6/5D $.D , D 5$#$D $,$"62A.(" D #$D " 6 562/D $,D "(6 #/D (.-7$!,$D 6($.$D
2$%$2$."( D " 6 562 ,D
:7.6 -($.6/D #$D ="$2$5D
./D "/.56 .#/D "/-/D 6(67, 2D $,D
% % % #% !% % %
" %
( &( "( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
( ( $( ( ( ( ( (
.Y +A@/AG?5-)-Y +A@Y :AY -5KCM.KLAY .@Y .;Y )GLT+M:AY ,Y -.Y :)Y &Y PY .@Y .;Y )GLT+M:AY
-.:Y %.):Y .+G.LAY Y -.Y Y -.Y A+LM*G.Y DAGY .:Y EM.Y K.Y )BGM.*)Y .:Y KL)LMLAY -.;
[email protected] -.Y 'G)@KB)G.@+6)Y QY M.@Y A*6.G@AY
.:Y [email protected] -.Y .KL)Y )MLAG5-)-
)-?5@6KLG)L6N)Y [email protected].@[email protected] .KY [email protected] C)G)Y G.KA;N.GY :)KY G.+<)?)[email protected] FM.Y .@
)C;6+)+5W@Y -.;Y )GLU+M;AY Y -.Y :)Y !(
K.Y CG.K.@L.@Y /[email protected] )Y ;)KY G.KA:[email protected] .OCH.K)K
A CI.KM@L)KY I.+)U-)KY .@Y ?)L.I5)Y -.Y )++.KAY )Y :)Y 5@/AI?)+5W@
@Y N5GLM-Y -. :Y )B)GL)-AY Y -.Y :)Y -6KDAK6+5W@Y )-5+5A@):Y +M)GL)Y -.Y :)Y !(Y
Y <)K
+A?M@5-)-.KY )MLW@A?)KY CM.-.@Y )LG5*M6HY ;)Y +A?C.L.@+5)Y C)G)Y :)Y G.KA:M+5W@Y -.Y :)KY
G.+;)?)[email protected] );Y (Y ?.-5)@L.Y :)Y +.;.*G)+5W@Y -.:Y +AIG.KCA@[email protected] +A@N.@6AY +A@Y ;)Y
-?5@6KLG)+5W@Y [email protected]):Y -.:Y KL)-AY -.K)GGA:;AY -.Y -5+2)Y CH.N5K5W@Y .O5KL.Y +A@N.@5A
[email protected] KMK+G5LAY +A@Y :)KY +A?M@5-)-.KY )MLW@A?)KY -.Y KLMG5)KY )@L)*J 5)Y )Y %5A8)Y
OLG.?)-MG)Y )KL6::) )Y #)@+3)Y .Y >:;.KY ):.)GKY )KUY +A?AY +A@Y :)KY +6M-)-.KY )MLW@A?)KY
-.Y .ML)Y PY #.;6::)Y
Y L.@AIY -.Y :AY -5KCM.KLAY .@Y KMY CG.R?*M:AY :)Y "(Y L [email protected] CAGY A*8.LAY (
( ( ( ( !( '( ( "( #( ( ( ( ( (
&( !( ( (!( "( ( ( ( ( (
( ( ( ( ( '( %( ( ( ( !(
( ( .Y .KL.Y ?A-AY KMY )GLU+M:AY Y G.+A@A+.Y .;Y -.G.+4AY -.Y LA-)KY <)K
C.GKA@)KY )Y )++.-.GY )Y :)Y 5@/AI?)+5W@Y CX*;6+)Y .@Y :AKY LSG?6@AKY CG.N5KLAKY .@Y .:Y )JLV+M;A
*Y -.Y :)Y A@KL5LM+5W@Y PY -.K)GGA;:)-AKY CAIY -5+4)Y @AG?)Y :.1)<Y .KL.Y K.@L5-AY .;
)ILU+M;AY Y -.Y :)Y &Y [email protected] :)Y 6@0AG?)+6W@Y CX*=5+)Y +A?AY <AKY +A@L.@5-AKY AY
-A+M?.@LAKY +M):FM5.G)Y FM.Y K.)Y KMY 0AG?)LAY AY KACAGL.Y FM.Y A*G.@Y .@Y CA-.GY -.Y );1M@AY
-.Y :AKY KM8.LAKY 5@+:M5-AKY .@Y .;Y R?*5LAY -.Y )C;5+)+5W@Y -.Y .KL.Y LULM=AY PY FM.Y 4)P)@Y K5-AY
.:)*AG)-AKY AY )-FM6I5-AKY .@Y .:Y .9.G+5+6AY -.Y KMKY /M@[email protected]
Lssan # |}| :^FFn :yn=7j 7=s b L c'NC%+/)s Y% d %7"‚
Lssan #|}| :^F Gn :yn=7j‚ 8=xeLe‚ 'OC%+40)"" ‚ e%"tY%‚ U7‚
Lsufo $| }|‚ ;_GGp;yo>8j‚ 7 >s e M g‚ (ND&+4/)""!g&"tZ%‚ UD8>z88‚
Lssfn # |}| =^[nFS^CF sj7[ne7jFY=O7Fn=s‚ 2^WFFnsk8Y ng8jFYBO8f^js7Vvj7[ne7jF[=O7O[J^kX7=O^[€
F=_Y?^Y{FYO^p=^ Y{GYO^n--))LsWV‚
5KP\9‚ ‚ EH‚ ‚
.`]qHT`‚ EI‚ 6l9\qh9lH]@P9‚ ‚ ,zI]‚ 1`<QHl\`‚ **3‚
|
~ A`]rHS`EHwm9]qi9lHZAR9 Hq‚
B #,-0+$@,B 4-'#$5B 4B $,-1+$@,B .A'$B ,B 'B +$B ,B /6B -0B ,B .-1B B
6,B 46%5-B -'# -B .-0B (B B (B 96,5+$,5-B B ;04B 9B 4B !B ,0-B ,B
%1#$-B B 464B -+.5,$4B +6,#$.'4B +50$B B 60,$4+-B 9B .50#+-,#'B .A'#B
(B .0-.$-B 96,5+#,5-B "B 40#5-B '4B 56$-,4B #,50+#,#4505#74B 564B 9B
!B (0-B (B 45564B &60=#-B 56'B (B #,+6'B .-0B '-B /6B 4B ,5#,B 45#4!B 'B
4-'##56B 6,/6B $!B -+6,##@,B (B !9B 0'#:-B B (B .05B #,504B -,B
.-450$-0$B B (B .24,5#@,B B )B 0'+$@,B ,5B (B B
4B 1 '4B ,2(4B 'B .0-$+$,5-B B %0##-B 'B 0"-B B 4-B B '
$,-1+#@,B .A'#B 4B -1,B ,B '-4B 05=6(-4B
B
B 'B B 4.##;,-4
,B 'B 05=6(-B
'-4B .(:-4B .1B 'B 04-'6$@,B B '4B 4-'$#564B B #,-0+#@,
'B ,50#-0B .1.5-B 4B $,#1,B -4B -,4#2 #-,4B B .1$+0B -,4#45B ,B '
8$45,$B B 6,B 1 (B .0-#+,5'B 4.=#B .(#'B B /6''-4B 4-4B
-,4$0'4B 4-'#$564B B #,-0+#@,B ,B 5,#@,B B 46B 7-'6+,B -B -+.*%#B ,
5-B ,B 'B 4 6,-B .;00-B (B 05=6'-B B B 'B B 4B .07<B /6B 6,-
-,611B 'B 46.645-B B !!-B B /6B 'B 7-'6+,B -B 'B-+.'%#B B 'B $,-0+#@,
/6B 4B 4-'$#5B 4>B (-B ! ,B ,40$-B 9B .07#B ,-5#$#@,B (B 4-'##5,5B '
-,46,#B &60>#B 40;B /6B 'B +#,$450$@,B .A'$B /6B B 04-'70B 'B 4-'$#56
B 4-B B (B $,-0+$@,B 5#,B (B .-4#$'#B B +.'$0B 'B .':-B B 6,B +4B (B /6
$4.-,B .1B #51B 9B ,-5#$0B 'B 14-'6#@,B .-0B -50-B +4B $$-,(B ,B 45B 4-B ,-B 4
.($@B 'B +.'##@,B 'B .':-B B B 04?0B 6,/6B 4B ,0@B 6,B #,-0+
$,51,-
B 4 6,B -,46,#B /6B 4B 0$7B (B 4?'-B .0.5-B /6B 60B 3($@,B -,
'B ,50$-0B -,4#45B ,B /6B 'B 05>6'-B B 00,#B 7#,6'B *B -+$,:-B (B @+.65-
'B .':-B B 6,B +4B (B /6B #4.-,B 'B +#,$450$@,B .0B 04-(70B +#,5
04- '6$@,B 8.04B -B .-0B 4#',#-B +$,#4505#7-B B 'B !B ,B /6B 'B 4-'$#56B 5,
,50B ,B 'B 0 #450-B 'B @1 ,-B -+.5,5B .2B 04-'70B ,B 45B 4.5-B 'B 4-'#$56
0B B B B ##+2B B B +$,504B /6B 'B ,-5$#$@,B B 'B 04.645B 4 A,
+,#$45B 'B 96,5+#,5-B 4B .0-6%-B (B B B 0#'B B
,B 45-4B 4-4B ,B /6B 'B #,-1+#@,B 4B -,B .0-B 60B *B .':-B 45'#-B ,B '
B .0-B 45$+0B 'B 0(+#@,B .',5B .-0B +-5#7-4B -0+'4B *B !04
76',1-B (B 0!-B B 'B 4-(#$5,5B B -5,1B 6,B 04-*6#@,B ,B 'B .(:-B +;8 #+-
: RRFN XXX] -D66N-UN0*K] * 0R G:G] ;4 '#] RA] F*] ]
: RRFN XXX] -D67O.VO1+K] + 1R G : G] ;4 '$] SA] F+]
]
: RRHN XYX] -D6 6N- V N0*K] * 0R G : G] ;4 '#] RA] H*
(\9<B,] ] 58] ]
"ECP8?E] 58] )L,BPI,L8C2<,] [] !W8C] %E/=8LBE] &]
YZ3ECQ8@E58TM,CPJ,L8C3>,8P]
<25.<?2@L2Z 2KL./=2081AZ 7./92@1AZ K81AZ @202K.H9AZ [email protected] [email protected] H20<.?.08X@Z .@L2Z 2=Z
*!Z B.H.Z N2HZ B=2@.?2@L2Z H20A@A091AZ KMZ 12H207AZ
@Z .L2@09X@Z .Z <AKZ .@L20212@L2KZ OZ 3M@1.?2@LAKZ :MHV180AKZ 12K0H8LAKZ BHA0212Z
=.Z H20<.?.08X@Z [email protected] 4H2@L2Z .>Z OM@L.?82@LAZ 12Z T02I2KZ
2Z .0M2H1AZ 0A@Z 2<Z .HLV0M<AZ Z @Y?2HAZ Z 12Z <.Z $2PZ Z 12Z Z 12Z 18082?/H2Z 12Z
[email protected]@09. Z 002KAZ .Z =.Z "@4AH?.08X@Z 'Y/<90.Z QZ M2@Z !A/82H@A
Z <.Z (20<.?.08X@Z
BH2N9KL.Z 2@Z 2<Z .HLV0M<AZ Z 12Z <.Z ?9K?.Z L 82@2Z <.Z [email protected]@Z 12Z KMKL8LML8N.Z 12Z =AKZ
H20MHKAKZ [email protected] 12Z 0A@3AH?81.1Z 0A@Z <AZ 18KBM2KLAZ 2@Z 2=Z .HLW0M<AZ Z 12Z <.Z $2PZ
Z 12Z Z 12Z A0LM/H2Z 12Z 'HA021 8?82@LAZ [email protected] A?Y@Z 12Z <.KZ
[email protected]@2KZ 'Y/<80.K
Z
[email protected] <.Z BH2K2@L2Z H2KA<M09X@Z FM2Z BA@2Z 39@Z .Z <.Z NW.Z [email protected] K2Z BA1HTZ 8@L2HBA@2HZ
H20MHKAZ 0A@[email protected][email protected] 2@Z 2<Z B=.RAZ 12Z 1AKZ ?2K2KZ 18H20L.?2@L2Z .@L2Z <.Z
).<.Z 12Z <AZ A@[email protected][email protected] 12Z =.Z [email protected] &.08A@.=Z 12Z 0A@3AH?91.1Z 0A@Z <AZ
BH2N9KLAZ 2@Z 2=Z .D.J.1AZ GM8@LAZ 12Z =.Z 9KEAK808X@Z .1808A@.<Z 0M.HL.Z 12Z =.Z $2PZ Z 12Z
Z 12Z ;M=8AZ (26M=.1AH.Z 12Z =.Z #MI8K18008X@Z A@[email protected][email protected].
Z
%Z '()"&,Z $Z -!Z
1AZ #AKUZ $M8KZ (A1H V5M2RZ S<N.H2RZ
k
C__Q[efe4N>>[4b[71Wk 17aRCRk "E;!&.*#k _K!k S!1
C__T\ eee5O? ?\5c\82Xk 28_ QCRk "E<!'.+#_K!k R!2k k
D__T[ ee f5N> >[
5b[71Xk 17_ TCRk "E<!'.+$_K!k T!1k
/jBFL3k k =@k k
)PM]@IPk =Ak 0Y3L]U3Y@M9F3k ik (dAMk ,P6G@YLPk %%-k
gh:PM^@JP=@`Z3K]V3Y@M:H3@]k