El ciudadano solicitó acceso a información sobre la gestión de la calidad del aire y el ruido en el municipio de El Prat de Llobregat. La administración denegó la solicitud alegando que la información estaba en curso de elaboración. El Consejo de Transparencia y Buen Gobierno estima la reclamación, obligando a la administración a entregar la información.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
La administración no puede denegar el acceso a la información basándose en que está en curso de elaboración si existen datos ya consolidados que puedan ser facilitados.
2
El derecho de acceso a la información pública prevalece cuando la administración no acredita que la divulgación de los datos parciales perjudique la calidad de la información final.
3
Se determina que la administración no ha justificado adecuadamente la denegación, limitándose a alegar la fase de elaboración sin analizar la posibilidad de entrega parcial.
Texto completo
!"
"
" " "
!#M F=C,M M
% (M +,M 7(M .4@9(M
"%
$%
!" $ !% GD:C(93,;C<M +,M D(+(7(6(@(M
$% !"% :.<@9(*3K:M B<)A,M ,7M :E,:C(@4<M +,M *(93;<BM +,8M
GD:C(93,:C<M +,M D(+(7(6(@( M
"% % % !#$% %& &"$M =<@M 9<C3E<BM .<A9(8,BM
%,/L:M B,M +,B=@,;+,M +,M 7(M +<*D9,;C(*3K:M ?D,M <)A(M ,;M ,8M ,F=,+3,:C,M ,;M -,*1(M M +,
9(AJ<M +,M M ,8M (2<@(M @,*7(9(;C,M B<73*3CKM (8M GD:C(93,:C<M+,M D(+(8(6(@(M (7M (9=(@<
+,M 8(M ,HM
M +,M M +,M + 3*3,9)@,M +,M C@(:B>(@,;*3(M (**,B<M (M 7(M 3:-<@9(*3K:M >L)85*(
IM )D,:M 0<) 3,@;<M ,:M (+,8(;C,M 'M 8(M B4/D3,;C,M 3:-<@9(*3K:
" " " " " " " " " " " " "
" " " " " " " " " " "
" ! " " " " " " " " " " " " " "
" " " " " " " " " " " "
" " " " " " " " " " " " "
L
- CC9A GHG #7* *A# E A% =L %C : . :L /'
K,05!L L (+L L
86B+38L (+L >"6B;!>+6&0"L JL F+6L 8$1+>68L L
I &86B+48)+D ?!6B<!@+6&2 !+BL
!
! !
! !
&(0 '%,"0 " #'"0 "&0 !"&0 &"%0 "&0 $(0 &0 &"'0 &'0 !"% /!0 &"!0 "&0
$(0 &0 !!0 0 "!'!(/!0 0 '%).&0 0 &(0 %%!0 '&'%0
0:%A -!A !;9%0#(!A $%A 7%92;%9:!A !A 9;A 91.(#):;$A %.A 91-)#):!0:%A *0:%72;91A ;0!A 7%#.!/!#)?0
!0:%A %.A 109%+1A $%A 8!092!7%0#)!A =A ;%0A 1") %701A %0A !$%-!0:%A A %-A A $%A /!=1A $%
A #10A 0@/%71A $%A %<2%$)%0:%A A %0A 9;A 9%$%A %-%#:7?0)#!
.A A $%A /!=1A $%A A %.A A 7%/):)?A .!A 7%#-!/!#)?0A !A -!A %#7%:!7>!A %0%8!.A $%-
=;0:!/)%0:1A $%A ;!$!.!,!7!A !.A 1"+%:1A $%A 5;%A 9%A 2;$(%7!0A 27%9%0:!7A .!9A !.%'!#)10%9
5;%A 9%A #109)$%7!9%0A 1217:;0!9
-A A $%A /!=1A $%A A 9%A 8%#("%A #10:%9:!#(?0A $%A .!A !$/(0)9:7!#)?0A %0A -!A 5;%A 9%
27%9%0:!0A .!9A !-%'!#)10%9A 91-)#):!$!9A %A )0$)#!0A -1A 9)'; )%0:%
&'0 0 % /!0 &0 !"% 0 "0 &(!'0 !0 ),0 %,0 0 " #%"/!0!0
0 !)!'%"0 (!#0 #"%0 0 /!0 0 '% "!"0 &0 " #%(0 $(0 '""&0 "&0
!"&0 !'"&0 &"!0 0 ''(%0 (!#0 *#'"0 "&0 '%&0 $(0 &0 '!0 0
"!'!(/!0
&'0 &!0 !"0 &0 !(!'%0 !0 0 !)!'%"0 (!#0
#%"0 !0 0 "( !'/!0 %0 !0 0 &0 '%/!0 0 '&'%"0 (%0 " "0
0 ''(%0 0 +(!' !'"0 0 (%0 #"%0 "0 $(0 &0 &'0
#%' !'"0 &0 #%"%-0 0 !)&'%0 0 #%"!0 0 &(0 !(&/!0
& & "0 &0 '!0 "#&0 0 &0 &0 0 !)!'%"0 %%!'&0 0 "&0 !"&0
%&'!'&0
%A #10&17/)$!$A #10A .1A $)92;%9:1A %0A %-A !7:>#;-1A #A $%A .!A A =A %0A %.A !7:>#;.1A
$%.A %!.A %#8%:1A A $%A A $%A 1#:;"7%A 318A %.A 6;%A 9%A !47;%"!A %.A 9:!:;:1A $%-
%& & & &
& & & $& "& & &
# ! &
54>#+5M "#M ;4>6;#4!*M DM @#4M 5 )#;45M
M
M #.M ;#>*"#4?#M "#M #>?M A?5;)""
"3)4*>?;?*BM *4"#7#4")#4?#M #>M !537#?#4?#M 7;M ;#>5.B#;M />M ;#!.3!*54#>M :@#M #4M
7/)!!)K4M "#.M <[email protected] M "#M /M
>#M 7;#>#4?#4M $;#4?#M M .>M ;#>5.@!*54#>M #C7;#>>M
5 7<#>@4?>M <#!J">M #4M 3?#;*M "#M !!#>5M M .M *4%5;3!)K4
4M B);?@"M "# .M 8;?"5M M "#M .M ")>95>*!*K4M "*!)54.M !A;?M "#M .M M
M />
!53@4)""#>M @?K453>M 7A#"#4M ?;) A)=M /M !537#?#4!)M 7<M /M ;#>5/@!*K4M "#M .>
;#!/3!*54#>M /M M 3#"*4?#M .M !#.# ;!)K4M "#/M !5;<#>754"*#4?#M !54B#4*5M !54M .
"3)4)>?<!*K4M #4#;.M "#.M >?"5M 4M "#>;;5/.5M "#M "*!'M 7<#B*>)K4M #C)>?#M !54B#4)5
B*?#M >@>!;*?5M !54M .>M !53@4*""#>M A?K453>M "#M >?@;)>M 4? ; )M M )5-
C?;#3"A;M >?*..M 4!(M #M ../#>M .#;>M >JM !535M !54M .>M !*@""#>M @?K453>
"#M #@?M EM #/*..
M M #4M >@M ;[email protected]
;#&@.M #.M "#;#!'5M "#M ?5">M .>M 7#;>54>M M !!#"#;M M .
*4%5;3!)K4M 7L .)!M #4?#4")"M >#&L4M #.M <?J!A.5M M "#M .M 3)>3M 45;3M !535M
5;M .5M ?4?5M /M .#EM "#%)4#M #.M 5 ,#?5M "#M @4M >5.)!)?@"M "#M !!#>5M M .M )4%5;3!*K4M #4
;#/!)K4M !54M )4$5;3!)K4M :@#M EM #C)>?#M 75;M !@4?5M #>?GM #4M 75>#>)K4M "#M @4M 5 ; &4*>35
*4!/A)"5M #4M >@M G3 *?5M "#M 7/*!!)K4M )#4M 75;:@#M H.M 3*>35M .M 'M #. 5;"5M )#4M 75;:@#
.M 'M 5 ?#4 )"5M #4M #-#;!)!*5M "#M />M $@4!)54#>M EM !537#?#4!)>M :@#M ?)#4#M #4!53#4"">
4M #/M !>5M "#M #>?M ;#!23!)K4M /M *4$5;3!*K4M >5/)!)?"M ?*#4#M .M !54>)"#;!)K4M "#
*4$5<3!)K4M 7L .)!M EM :@#M 5 <M #4M 75"#;M "#M @4M #4?)""M 05!.M #/M E@4?3)#4?5M "#
A".-;M :@*#4M ")>754#M "#M #..M #4M #.M #-#;!)!)5M "#M/>M $@4!)54#>M :@#M ?)#4#M /#&.3#4?#
;#!545!)">
>M ;#&.>M #;/#>M "#.M 7;5!#"*3*#4?5M "#M #-#;!)!*5M "#.M "#<#!'5M "#M !!#>5M M .
*4%5;3!)K4M 7L /*!M >#M 5;"4M #4M .5>M ;?J!A.5>M
M
"#M .M M #>7#!)$)!G4"5>#
#4M #.M ;[email protected]
/5>M 7 1F5>M 7;M .M ;#>5/@!*K4M "#M .>M >51*!)?@"#>M "#M *4%5;3!)K4
[‹‹t… (–—– IpUU…I’…ND~DN‹ u[v/]R,5:2‹j,w,BD&œ
[ ‹Œt… ) ––– IpU U† I’…ND~DNŒ u[v/]R
5:2&&$u-&"j
D œ
[ ‹‹x‡ ) ––– JpU U… J’…NDœ D N‹ u\yœ /]R
5?:2&&$œ x
&"‹j.œ fRDO“DDœ
[‹‹t‡*–—–Npj…V
c
pRU‹~D j‡vD€UjN^DU‡N‹œ =piUU…‹Dk…uDUjO_Dtp„DgŽDl…uDUkN^D_lYp~iDN^pkš
WOqjOpj•Wj^q‡ Ppj•Wm^q‡8822 [i gœ
[ ‹‹w ‡ +—–– IpU U … J’…NDœ E P‹ z \ zœ /]R
5?:2&&$œ ‹j
fw
'#Dœ
[ ‹‹v… (–––œ KpU U…J ’ ˆ NDœ D N u[uœ 0^R.5?;2'&%œ ‹k.hu.&"Dœ %œ
[‹‹{‰)—––œ KpWW†L’†ODœ FO z[ zœ 1^R
6@;3&&$œ k
hz
&"Fœ
[‹‹w…)—––œ JrUU‡J“ˆODœ F NŽ w[zœ 0^R
6?;2'&$œ ‹k
hw
'"Dœ
A›
Z
`nGœ œ SXœ !œ
9soŠX
d
sœ SXœ CHoŠ
|
GXoQ`Hœ
™œ
7”Xoœ <sMaXosœ 44>œ
˜ QsjŠX
e
sTX‘ ‚ GjŠ
}
GƒXjQ bGXŠœ
!
*F /8 4&15F 25 281F 7 F &/"' 5 0F 17F 107' 4'1/ 7F F 24&. 5F 107'78 F /F *F
;'78 0&F F 90F 5 #*F 241 '. /8+F 72 B"&F 2*'* F F 39 *,17F 717F F
107& 4* 7F 71*'&89 7F F '0!14.&D0F /F 8 0'D/F F 79F :1+9. 0F 1F 1.2* ('F /F
! 81F 0F +F 7 #901F 2?54"1F +F 48A9*1F F F *F F 7 F 24 :@F 39 F 9/1F
10944F *F 7929 781F F $ $1F F 39 F *F :1+9. /F 1F *F 1.2+ ('F F *F &/"15.'D/F
39 F 7 F 71*&'8F 7AF +1F $#0F 0 76'1F <F 26 :'F 018'"&'D0F +F 71,''8/8 F *F
107 9 /'F (94A'F 7 4?F 39 F *F .'0'784'D/F 2E+'F 39 F F 4 71,: 4F ,F 71*'&89F
F 71F F *F &0"14.'D0F 8' 0 F *F 217''*'F F .2*&4F ,F 2,=1F F 9/F . 7F +F 39 F
&7210 F 25F '84F <F /18'"&4F *F 4 71*9'D0F 214F 1841F . 7F '&10*F /F 78 F 71F 01F 7 F
2+&DF *F .2*&'D/F *F 2*>1F F F 5 7 C4F 8*F <F 1.1F 7 F 9 F F *17F
/8 /8 7F 39 F 140F 0F *F ;2 & 08 F F .11F 39 F *F .'0'784'D/F '721/BF F
90F . 7F 24F '84F <F /18&"'4F +F 4 71*9&D0F 0F .8 4&F F 71F F *F '/"14.&D/F
71*'&8F
F 7 #90F 1/7 9 /'F 39 F 7 F 5&:F +F 7 C*1F 24 281F 39 F #94F 4 *&D/F 1/F
*F 08 4'14F 107'78 F /F 39 F +F 48A9*1F F 4 " 4 0'F :&/9,F ,F 1.& 0>1F *F D.2981F
*F 2*=1F F 90F . 7F *F 39 F '7210 F +F .'/'784'D/F 24F 4 71+: 4F . '/8 F
4 71*9&D0F ;24 7F 1F 214F 7'* /'1F .&0&7848':1F F ,F " %F 0F 39 F +F 71*''89F 8 0#F
084F /F *F 4 #'7841F +F D5#01F 1.2 8 08 F 24F 6 71*: 5F /F +F 71F F 78F
4 +.&D/F 8*F " $F 4F +F F F .4>1F F F F ./ 4F 39 F ,F D4#/1F
1.2 8 08 F '7210AF F 90F . 7F 25F '84F <F 018'"&4F +F 144 721/' 08 F 4 71*9'D/F
#E0F 1078F /F +F ;2 & /8 F F *F 4 *.'D/F *F <908.& 081F F 9,)4F $F
241214'101F *F &0!14.'D0F 71*'&8F 0F .<1F F F /F 7817F 717F 0F 39 F *F
&/"14.'D/F 7 F 10 F 2 41F "9 6F *F 2+=1F 78+ '1F 0F *F F 241 F 78'.4F
*F 4 *.&D0F 2+08 F 214F .18&:17F "14.+ 7F *F $ 57 F :9*/ 51F -F 4 %1F +F
71*''8/8 F F 18 0 4F 90F 5 71*9'D/F /F *F 2*>1F .?;'.1F + #*. 08 F 78* &1F
$' 01F 7'1F 0 74&1F 25 7 084F 9/F 4 *.&D/F 08 F ,F F 24F : 4F 2* /. 08 F
4 101&1F 79F 5 $1F
%& & & &
0F 8 0'D0F F *17F 08 08 7F <F !90. 0817F )94A'17F 74'817F 241 F
+F 5 *.&D0F 25 7 08F "5 08 F *F <908.' /81F F
9+(4F
& & & $& "& & &
# ! &
/U +-G/A.<U -<;U /7U +AFQ-G7<U U ;T:/A<U U ./U 7+U "/IU U ./U U ./U .4-5/:,A/ U ./U
FA+;E=+A/;-4+U +--/E<U +U 8+U 4;0<A:+-5S;U =T,74-+U JU ,G/;U 2<, 4/A;<U
8+U A/-8+:+-5S;U
>A/H4EF+U /;U /7U +AFQ-G7<U U ./U 7+U :4E:+U F4/;/U 7+U -<;E4./A+-5S;U ./U EGEF5FGF4H+U ./U 7<EU
A/-GAE<EU +.:4; 4EFB+F 4H<EU ./U -<;1<A:4.+.U -<;U 7<U .5E>G/EF<U /;U /8U +AFR-G7<U U ./U 7+U #/KU
./U U ./U <-FG,C/U ./U %C<-/.5: 4/;F<U .:4;5EFA+F5H<U <:T;U ./U 8+EU
.:4;4EFC+-4<;/EU &T,74-+E
<;FB+U 8+U >A/E/;F/U A/E<7G-4S;U ?G/U ><;/U 15;U +U 7+U HR+U +.:5;4EFA+F5H+U E/U ><.COU 5;F/A><;/AU
A/-GAE<U -<;F/;-4<E<+.:5;4EFA+F5H<U /;U /7U >8+M<U ./U .<EU :/E/EU .5D/-F+:/;F/U +;F/U 7+U
(+7+U ./U 8<U <;F/;-4<E<+.:4;4EFA+F4H<U ./U 7+U G.4/;-4+U $+-5<;+8U ./U -<;1<A:4.+.U -<;U 7<U
>A/H5EF<U /;U /8U +=+AF+.<U @G 4;F<U ./U 8+U 5E=<E5-4S;U +.4-4<;+7U -G+CF+U ./U 9+U #/LU
./U
U ./U 6G84<U '/2G7+.<A+U ./U 8+U !GB4E.4--5S;U <;F/;-4<E<+.:5;4EFA+F5H+
U
"U &'( $)U #U *U
.<U !<EPU "G4EU '<.CQ3G/MU N7H+A/MU
@\\NY ccc3K<<Y 3aY6.T .6\N@N"B9!%(#]H!N!.g
@\^OZ ccc3L==Z4aZ7/Ug 07\g O@Pg "B9!%+(#_H!g P!/g g
@\^OY cc c3K< <Y3aZ6.Tg .6\ OAQg "B9!%+(#]H!g O!.g
,f?CI1g g :>g g
'MJ[>FMg :>g -V2J[R1V>J8C2g eg &b>Jg )M5D>VJMg $$*g
d 8MH[>GM;>` W1H[S1X>H8 E1>[g