Estimada 12/05/2014 · 62 días en resolverse

Acceso a información sobre calidad del aire y ruido en Alcorcón

El interesado solicitó acceso a información sobre la gestión de la calidad del aire y el ruido en el municipio de Alcorcón. El Ayuntamiento de Alcorcón denegó el acceso alegando que la información estaba en proceso de elaboración. El Consejo de Transparencia y Buen Gobierno estima la reclamación al considerar que no se ha justificado la existencia de un borrador concreto que impida la difusión.

Puntos clave de la argumentación

1 El Consejo determina que la mera alegación de que la información está en curso de elaboración no es suficiente para denegar el acceso sin acreditar la existencia de un documento concreto.
2 Se establece que el derecho de acceso prevalece cuando la administración no demuestra que la publicación de la información pueda afectar a la calidad de la decisión final.
3 La resolución subraya que la administración debe justificar la causa de inadmisión mediante hechos concretos y no mediante afirmaciones genéricas.

Texto completo

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qq_m xxx 8\C Cm8 u m;4 h~4 ;q `J`~ $K?"(0,&~ qW"T_"4~ I rr_n ! xxx 8\DDn 9un<5h~ 5 <r `Ja~ %K?"(0,&rW#Ta"25~ I qqbm xx x 8\C Cm 8um;4h~ 4<q cJ c~ $K?"(0,&~ b"qW"~ T?4= u44~ Iqq_m xxx;\WmEQ\@Cqh4Wm_4iCW;L4Cm;s~ .\VCCoq h4Xmd4hCW =M4e\hq4Ush4Xo_4hCX;L4MXG]jV4;L\X{ D<]W <]WwDWL]n <]WwDY L]n**&& IrV U~ I rqbm ! xxx 8\C Cm8 u m;4 h~4 ;r `J`~ $K?"(0,&~ rW"Tf"4~ 1|HNZ6~ ~ AF~ ~ +^[pFR^~ AF~ 3k7[pg6kF[>N7~ z~ )vF[~ -^:OFk[^~ ''/~ y >^WpFS^BFt l 6Wpb6hFW>P 6Fp~ ~ }~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t H hhXe "nnn :VDDe:ke=5_t 5 =h Y I Yt %K@$*0-'t hS$RX$5 t Hhh Z f # onnt :VE Ef ;lf>5_t 6>h [ I [t %KA$*0-(3hS$R[$6t Hih Ze # nn n :VD Df :ke=5`t 6=i \ JYt & LA$*1- ' !! Z$iS$t R@5=k7ai5t 2r G MT8t t BFt t ,WUgF P Wt BFt4b9Ug ] 8bFU?M9t qt +mFUt .W<NFbUWt ))/t p ?WUgF WCFj c8Sg ^ 8dFU? O8 Fgt st