El ciudadano solicitó al Ayuntamiento de Sant Joan Despí el acceso a un informe técnico sobre la gestión de residuos. El Ayuntamiento denegó la solicitud alegando que el documento estaba en curso de elaboración. El Consejo de Transparencia Pública Andaluza estima la reclamación, considerando que el documento ya estaba finalizado y no se justificó la denegación.

Puntos clave de la argumentación

1 El Consejo determina que la administración no acreditó que la información estuviera en proceso de elaboración, ya que el informe técnico ya había sido emitido y remitido a la entidad solicitante.

2 Se establece que la denegación basada en la elaboración de la información requiere una justificación concreta de que la publicación prematura pueda afectar al proceso de decisión, lo cual no ocurrió en este caso.

3 La resolución subraya que el derecho de acceso prevalece cuando la administración no puede demostrar la existencia de un límite legal aplicable que justifique la reserva del documento.

Texto completo

" " ! " " " " & F9A+ O & 'O *+O 4'O -1=6'O #& %& "# %!"& GC7A'62+7A8O *+O +>+JO *+O 48@O '('44+=8@O '*'38JO %& "#& F9+*2+7B+O '*6272@A='A1E8O K7A+.=8O 17)8'*8O )87B='O =+)5'6'7A+O #& & &!"$%& $$%!&"#O 4'O & $+.N7O @+O *+@9=+7*+O *+O 4'O *8)C6+7B')2M7O <D+O 8(>'O +7O +4O +F9+*1+7A+O +7O ,+)0'O O *+ ,+(=+>8O *+O O 5'O =+)4'6'7A+O @842)1BMO '5O '69'=8O *+O 5'O +HO O *+O O *+O *1)2+6(=+ *+O A='7@:'>+7)1'O '))+@8O 'O 5'O 17-8=6')1M7O ;N(51)'O IO (D+7O /8(1+=78O O +7O '*+5'7B+ &O '5O GD7B'62+7A8O *+O +?+JO *+O 48@O '('45+=8@O 4'O @2.D2+7B+O 27-8=6')1M7 !+*1'7B+O #+@85D)2M7O *+O 4)'5*L'O *+O O *+O 6'=J8O *+O O @+O 9+=62A+O 'O 4'O @852)2A'7B+O +5 '))+@8O 'O 4'O 27,8>6')1M7O @2+7*8O 9D+@B'O 'O *2@98@2)1M7O *+O 4'O 17B+=+@'*'O 4'O 78B2-2)')1M7O *+ +@A'O #+@84D)1M7O +4O O *+O 6'=J8O *+O M . DD:B HIH $8+ +B$ F B&! >M! &D ;/;M 0( L-16"M M ),M M 97C,49M ),M ?#7C<"?,7'1#M KM G,7M 9%2,?79M M J '97C,59*,E @"7C="A,7'3 ",CM ! ! ! ! ! )? ? !? ,1:.? !? ? 4!? /2. 6!? !)? 1!$:.? !? )? -.5'"''=-? /.1? *? 4.)&&5-5!? *!#- .? -5!4? !? !7,'-1)? )? ")5? !? &-5!#3' ? !? *? .6,!-5&=-? 06!? 2!%:? 1!''1? !-? )4? !/!- !-&4? ,6-'&/)!4? &4.-".1,!? .-? )? 56'=-? !? *? ,&-'451&=-? .-!1-& ? +? 4.*'&5-5!? /2!4!-5= !? 6!1 .? .-? ).? '4/6!45.? !-? !*? 15;6*.? !? )? ? 6-? 1!*,'=-? -5!? !) .-4!(.? !? 1-4/1!-'? 9? 6!-? .&!2-.? !-? !*-5!? ? ? *? 06!? 4!? ? !-51 !*? ? !? ,2:.? !? ? .-? ->,!2.? !? !8/! '!-5!? ? )? ? !? ,1:.? !? ? !*? ? 1!,'5&=? )? 2!*,&=-? ? *? !1!51<? !-!1 +? !*? 96-5,&!-5.? !? !1!:? !? ).4? **!1.4? *? .(!5.? !? 06!? /.2? !*? =1#-.? .,/!5!-5! /6 '!1-? /1!4!-514!? )4? *!#&.-!4? 06!? 4!? .-4' !14!-? ./.156-4 )? ? !? 3')? !? ? 4!? 1!'!? )? 1!4/6!45? ? *4? )!#'.-!4? 1!06!1' 4? 06!? '-*69! 6-? '-".1,!? !? )? ** !4/3!4 ' !-5? !? ? !? 1&)? !? ? .-? !)? 4&#6'!-5! .-5!-' . V V !1,+*"+V ,-#)!-+ V A@F;56D2@5AV CH6V >2V FA>;4;G2@G6V 56V >2V ;@8AD?24;T@V 6D2V B2DG6V ;@G6D6F252V 56>V 6JB65;6@G6V @U?6DAV V 6@V 6>V CH6V F6V GD2?;G232V 6JB65;6@G6V F2@4;A@25ADV 4A@GD2V >2V ;@G6D6F252V VV V F6V BDA465;TV 56V 4A@8AD?;525V 4A@V 6>V 2DGQ4H>AV V 56V >2V A@FG;GH4;T@V 6FB2SA>2V 6>V 2DGQ4H>AV V 5OV KV 6>V 2DGQ4H>AV V 2B2DG25AV 2V 56V >2V &6KV 56V V 56V A4GH3D7V 56V BDA465;?;6@GAV 25?;@;FGD2G;IAV 4A?U@V 56V >2FV 25?;@;FGD24;A@6FV BU3>;42FV 2V 4A@4656DV 6>V 2446FAV 56V >2V ;@G6D6F252V 2>V 6JB65;6@G6V 56V D686D6@4;2V ?65;2@G6V D6FA>H4;T@V 56V 2>42>5Q2V 56V 864:2V 56V ?2DLAV 56V V KV @U?6DAV 56V D6FA>H4;T@V V NT5;9AV 56V I6D;8;424;T@V 6@V F656V 6>64GDT@;42V /(!"%,%0-$ ! V '2V @AG;8;424;T@V 56V 5;4:2V D6FA>H4;T@V 8H6V D62>;L252V BADV 8H@4;A@2D;AV BU3>;4AV 56>V KH@G2?;6@GAV 56V $6D6LV 56V >AFV 232>>6DAFV 6>V 5Q2V V 56V ?2DLAV 56V V 4A@V D69;FGDAV 56V F2>;52V @U?6DAV .-V KV D64:2L252V BADV >2V ;@G6D6F252V F69U@V 4A@FG2V 6@V >2V 5;>;96@4;2V 56V >2V 8H@4;A@2D;2V 6@V >2V BDAB;2V @AG=<424;T@V 6>V 5Q2V V 56V ?2EMAV 56V V 2V >2FV V :AD2FV F6V @;692V 2V D64;3;DV >2V @AG;8;424;T@V 6@G6@5;P@5AF6V BADV G2@GAV D64:2L252V >2V ?;F?2V 56V 24H6D5AV 2>V 2DGQ4H>AV V 56V >2V &6KV V 56V V 56V A4GH3D6V !@V ;@8AD?6V 56V >2V BA>;4R2V >A42>V 6@V 4A@4D6GAV 56>V 296@G6V ,V F6V ;@5;42V CH6V B6DFA@252V 6@V >2FV A8;4;@2FV ?H@;4;B2>6FV 4A@V >2V 8;@2>;525V 56V D64;3;DV >2V @AG;8;424;T@V F6V P / GG=E KKK %;, ,E% I E'" AP" 'G >0>P 1) P G87= " N.29#P P *-P P <:F-5<P *-P !B$:F?#B-:(2$P MP J-:P <&3-B:<P P L (<:F-6<+-H C#:F@#D-:( 4#-FP OP *&"$= = ." +$".= (= )&/)= &*!& *!+= -1"= *+= "/07= +),("0+= "(= "3,"!&"*0"= ,+.-1"= #(0*= 29!"+/= 4= #+0+$./= +*/&!".*!+= ,+.= 0*0+= -1"= (= !)&*&/0. &<*= %= 1),(&!+= "*= ,(5+= +*= (= /+(& &01!= !"= &*#+.) &<*= ."(&6!= ,+.= (= &*0"."/!= +;= == = "*0&"*!"= -1"= "(= ,."/"*0"= ." 1./+= ." "= !"= #1*!)"*0+= = "*&"*!+= "*= 1"*0= -1"= (= !)&*&/0. &<*= %= 1),(&!+= +*= /1= +(&$ &<*= !"= &*#+.) &<*= = (= &*0"."/!= !"(= ,.+ "!&)&"*0+= 0./(!7*!+("= (= !+ 1)"*0 &<*= +.." 0)"*0"= *+*&)&5!= ,".+= /&"*!+= ." %5!= ,+.= (= )')= "/0= ,.0"= "*0&"*!"= -1"= /"= 0.0= !"= 1*= ." 1./+= -1"= ." "= !"= #1*!)"*0+= !"= +*#+.)&!!= +*= "(= .0: 1(+= = ,.0!+= "= !"= (= "4= = !"= = !"= + 01."= !"&"*!+= /".= &*!)&0&!= = 0.7)&0"= /1= /+(& &01!= += +/0*0"= "(= "3,"!&"*0"= /&$1"= = !&/,+/& &<*= !"= (= &*0"."/!= "*= (/= +#& &*/= !"(= 41*0)&"*0+= ,.= -1"= 1!= "*= 1(-1&".= )+)"*0+= = ,+.= 8(= = == = "= &*!)&0= (= ." () &<*= ,."/"*0!= ,+.= +;= == = %G #10&1:/'$!$G #10G +1G $'>2@%>?1G %0G %,G !:?E#@,1G #G $%G +!G G CG %0G %+G !:?E#@+1G $%+G %!+G %#:%?1G G $%G G $%G 1#?@":%G 31;G %+G 8@%G >%G !4:@%"!G %+G >?!?@?1G $%, 10>%*1G $%G ;!0>3!:%0#'!G DG @%0G 1"'%;01G G G %,G :%>($%0?%G $%G %>?!G @?1:'$!$ $/'0'>?;!?'A!G 0$%2%0$ '%0?%G %>G #1/7%?%0?%G 2!:!G :%>1,A%:G +!>G :%#+!/!#)10%>G 9@%G %0G !2,'#!#'F0G $%,G !<?E#@+1G G $%G +!G G >%G 2:%>%0?%0G &;%0?%G !G +!>G <%>1,@#)10%>G %B2=%>!>G 1 2;%>@0?!>G ;%#!E$!>G %0G /!?%:)!G $%G !##%>1G !G ,!G )0&1:/!#)F0 0G A':?@$G $% +G !5!:?!$1G G $%G +!G $'>61>)#)F0G !$)#'10!+G #@!:?!G $%G -!G G G ,!> #1/@0'$!$%>G !@?F01/!>G 7@%$%0G !?:'"@'=G ,!G #1/7%?%0#'!G 7!;!G ,!G :%>1,@#)F0G $%G .!>G :%#,!/!#)10%>G !,G G /%$)!0?%G +!G #%+%":!#'F0G $%,G #1:;%>210$)%0?%G #10A%0)1G #10G +!G _ :WW K T [[[ /I7 7T /YU1+P_ +1W L ; L_ = !'$ WED K )+ _ : WWKT [[[ /I7 7U/YU1+P_ +1W L<M_ > !'$_ M WF_ D +2Y+, (^9?G-_ _ 58_ _ #JHV8BJ_ 58_ *Q.HVN-Q8H3?._ ]_ "Z8H_ %J0@8QHJ_ &_ \ 3JHV8CJ68X R-HVO-S8H3 A-8V_ ! !0(1(895 )D1F "1"6-F !"-F 89!2F 1F !"8662.-2F !"F !) &F 35";)8(D1F "<(89"F 21;"1(2 ;)%"19"F 8:8 6)92F 21F -8F 20:1)!!"8F :9D1208F !"F 89:6(8F 195 (F F (2+F <96"0!:6F 89)..F 1 'F "F /--"8F -"68F 8BF 202F 21F -8F ):!!"8F :9D1208F !"F ":9F =F ".(--F F F "1F 8:F 59C :-2F F 6"%:-F "-F !"6" &2F !"F 92!8F -8F 3"68218F F "!"6F F - )1$260 (D1F 3E-( F "19"1!(!F 8"%E1F "-F 59B :-2F F !"F -F 0(80F 1260F 202F 26F -2F 9192F .F -"=F !"$(1"F "-F 2,"92F !"F :1F 82 -( (9:!F !"F "82F F -F (1$260 )D1F "1 6". (D1F 21F (1#260 (D1F 4:"F =F "<(89"F 326F :192F "89@F "1F 328"8(D1F !"F :1F 26%1)802 )1 .:(!2F "1F 8:F @0)92F !"F 3.) (D1F ("1F 3264:"F A-F 0)802F -F &F "-26!2F ("1F 3264:" -F &F 29"1(!2F "1F"+"6 ( )2F !"F .8F #:1 (21"8F =F 203"9"1 (8F 4:"F 9("1"F "1 20"1!!8 "%E1F 8"F "<36"8F "1F "-F 36"@0:-2F !"F -F F -F 961836"1 (F "-F "82F F - )1$260 (D1F 3E-( F =F -8F 12608F !"F :"1F %2)"612F !""1F 8"7F -28F ","8F #:1!0"19-"8 !"F 92!F )D1F 32- B9) F D.2F :1!2F -F (D1F !"F -28F 6"83218-"8F 3E-( 28F 8"F 820"9"F "8 5:9(1(2F :1!2F -28F (:!!128F 3:"!"1F 212 "6F D02F 8"F 9201F -8F !" (8(21"8F 4:" -"8F #" 91F D02F 8"F 01"+1F .28F #21!28F 3E- ( 28F 2F +2F 4:AF 6)9"5)28F 9E1F 1:"8968 )189(9: (21"8F 32!6"028F &.6F !"-F (1( *2F !"F :1F 362 "82F "1F "-F 4:"F -28F 32!"6"8F 3E-( 28 20("1>1F F 6"8321!"6F F :1F 82 ("!!F 4:"F "8F 6B9) F "<(%"19"F =F 4:"F !"01! 369( (3 )D1F !"F -28F 32!"5"8F 3E-( 28 "F :"5!2F 21F ".F )9!2F 69C :-2F F !"F -F F "F 21 .:(6F 4:"F -F )1$260 (D1 82-( )9!F !""F 218)!"668"F 3:"892F 4:"F 266BF "1F 32!"7F !"F :1 8:+"92F 2-)%!2F 326F .F F "-F =:190)"192F !"F "6">F !"F -28F -."628F 4:)"1 !)8321"F !"F "..F "1F ".F "+"6 ( )2F !"F -8F #:1 (21"8F 4:"F 9("1"F ."%-0"19"F 6" 212 )!8 1961!2F "1F ".F #21!2F !"-F 8:192F =F 8"%E1F 8"F !"837"1!"F !"F .28F 19" "!"19"8F - !0(1)896 (D1F 21 "61)!F &F 3:"892F F !)8328( (D1F !"F -F &26F 6" -019"F "1F -8 !"3"1!"1 (8F0:1( (3."8F "-F "<3"!)"19"F !0(1(8969(;2F 825"F ".F 4:"F ;"68F 8:F 82-) (9:! !"F )1$260 (D1F 89F 3:"89F F !(8328) (D1F 8"F 218)!"6F 21#260"F F -F 21 6"90"19"F F .2F !(83:"892F "1F 8:F 69C :-2F F F !!F -F 19:6-"?F !"F - !2 :0"19 )D1F *19"%619"F !".F "<3"!)"19" #66.5 :::-+5!'- !62+5.2!+%!5 6< -*! !5 62,5.2!+% /-46(72,5.2!,% %,"-3*%-,; !-+-+9!+%-5-+9!+%-5 # 6* (< #66 . 5 ::: -!!5 852< 6 0 $ 0< & < 6+).< $67.5:::-!!5852< 6.#1< % < %' ' ' ' ' ' ' $' "' ' ' # ! ' &' *GQk GUQ/k I/QU6k 6Fk 3Y/FVGk /k B/k ?FU69Q?5/5k 56Ck 6^I65?6FU6k 6SU6k GFS6@Gk I/QU6k 56k C/k 0/S6k 56k OZ6k 6Fk SYSk Q6C/3>GF6Sk 3GFk GVQ/Sk /5E?F>SVQ/3?GF6Sk Ij0D?3/Sk Q>96Fk CGSk IQ>F3>I?GSk 96F6Q/B6Sk 56Bk /QUh3Y CGk 6 56k B/k &6_k 56k 56k G3UZ0Q6k 56k +f9?E6Fk $YQg5?3Gk 56Ck ,63UGQk *j0C?3Gk 56k 0Z6F/k 76k 3GF8>/Fb/k C69hV?E/k _k C6/CU/5k ?FSU>VZ3>GF/Bk CCGk ?EIB?3/k OY6k 6Fk 6SU6k 3/SGk IQ6SZIGF6k OZ6k 6Ck 6^I65?6FV6k OZ6k </k S?5Gk IY6SUGk /k 5?SIGS?3?iFk 56k C/k Q63B/E/FV6k 6SUek 3GEIC6UGk _k 3GFU?6F6k IGQk U/FUGk C/k 5G3ZE6FU/3?iFk hFU69Q/k OZ6k 5616k 8GQE/Qk I/QU6k 56k fC k k U6FGQk 56k BGk 6^IY6SUGk 6SU6k GFS6@Gk3GFS?56Q/k OY6k 6Ck _YFU/E>6FUGk 56k %6Q6bk 56k CGSk /0/CC6QGSk </k /3UZ/5Gk 56k 3GF7GQE>5/5k 3GFk C/k &-#"k IGQk BGk OZ6k IQG3656k 6Fk 568?F>V?\/k 56S6SV?E/Qk B/k Q63B/E/3?iFk IB/FU6/5/ k Fk /U6F3?iFk /k CGSk /FU63656FV6Sk _k 7YF5/E6FUGSk @ZQh5>3GSk 56S3Q>VGSk IQG3656k B/k Q63B/E/3?iFk IQ6S6FV/5/k 7Q6FU6k /Ck _YFU/E>6FVGk 56k %6Q6bk 56k CGSk /0/CC6QGSk 6k /3Z6Q5Gk 3GFk 6Ck /QUg3ZBGk FjE6QGk 56k B/k &6`k 56k 56k 5?3>6E0Q6k 56k UQ/FSJ/Q6F3?/k /336SGk /k C/k >F7GQE/3?iFk Kj0B>3/k ak 0Z6Fk :G0>6QFGk C/k Q63B/E/3>iFk IQ6\>SU/k 6Fk 6Bk /QUh3YCGk 56k C/k E>SE/k U?6F6k B/k 3GFS?56Q/3?iFk 56k SYSV>UZV?\/k 56k CGSk Q63ZQSGSk /5E>F?SUQ/U>\GSk 56k 3GF7GQE?5/5k 3GFk BGk 5?SIZ6SUGk 6Fk 6Bk /QUh3YBGk 56k C/k '6_k 56k 56k G3UZ0Q6k 56k *QG365?E>6FVGk 5E?F?SUQ/U>\Gk GEjFk 56k C/Sk 5E?F>SUQ/3>GF6Sk *j0B?3/S GFVQ/k B/k IQ6S6FU6k Q6SGCY3?iFk OY6k IGF6k 7>Fk /k C/k \h/k /5E?F?SUQ/U>\/k S6k IG5Qek >FV6QIGF6Qk Q63ZQSGk 3GFU6F3?GSG /5E?F?SVQ/V?\Gk 6Fk 6Ck IB/bGk 56k 5GSk E6S6Sk 5?Q63V/E6FV6k /FU6k C/k ,/C/k 56k BGk GFU6F3?GSG/5E?F?SUQ/V?\Gk 56k C/k Y5?6F3?/k (/3>GF/Bk 56k 3GF7GQE>5/5k 3GFk CGk IQ6\>SUGk 6Fk 6Bk /L/QV/5Gk PZ?FUGk 56k B/k >SMGS>3?iFk /5?3?GF/Ck 3Z/RU/k 56k C/k &6`k 56k 56k AZB?Gk +6;ZC/5GQ/k 56k B/k %ZQ?S5?33>iFk GFV6F3?GSG /5E>F?SVQ/V>\/ 'k *+,#(.k &k -"k !5Gk %GSfk 'Y?Sk +G5Qh9Z6bk dC\/Q6bk ck =XNT] 2H66T 2[T4/R /4WN=N ?5) /k B aaR^ ggg 5O>>^ 5d^80Yk 0 8a S C Sk #H;!'-*$k aL!KR!0k BaaT_ ggg6P??_6e_91Yk 29a UBVk #E;!'-*%bL!k U"1k k DaaT^ gg g6O> >^6d^80Zk08ak TBVk #E;!'-*%bL!k S!0k .jAFM3k k <@k k )QN`@IQk <@k /[4N`W3[@N:F4k ik (f@Nk +Q7G@[NQk &&,k h :QN`@JQ=@c \3L`X3]@N:H 3@`k