El interesado solicitó acceso a información sobre la gestión de subvenciones y la relación de beneficiarios de la convocatoria de ayudas para la digitalización de la empresa. El Consejo de Transparencia y Buen Gobierno estima la reclamación, obligando a la administración a facilitar la información solicitada.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
El derecho de acceso a la información pública prevalece sobre la alegación de la administración de que la información se encuentra en proceso de elaboración o publicación general.
2
La administración no justificó adecuadamente la denegación basándose en la protección de datos personales, ya que la solicitud se refería a datos de beneficiarios de subvenciones públicas.
3
El Consejo determina que la información solicitada es accesible al no concurrir ninguna de las causas de inadmisión previstas en la Ley 19/2013.
4
Se concluye que la administración debe proporcionar la relación de beneficiarios y los importes concedidos, garantizando la transparencia en el uso de fondos públicos.
Texto completo
" "
! "
" " "
#&[ PDL1[ [
' +[ 01[ :+[ 26I?+[
$'
!&'
#$ "&"# ' QM@L+?61@LB[ 01[ !B4HBWB [
"&' # $' BD7+[ 01[ ;+K[ I1KB<M.7B@1K[ +[ <BK[ 0BK[ KMDM1KLBK[ DIU.L6.BK[ 01<[
DHB.1KB[ K1;1.L 7OB[ 01[ [email protected][ 01[ LH7-MLBK[
$ ' ' ' "# %&' ()")$'[
%=,TC[ 01[ 191/N/8XA[ [ 0V+K[
'
(14Z@[ K1[ 01KDI1@01[ 01[ ;+[ 0B.M?1@L+.7Y@[ GM1[ B-I+[ 1@[ 1>[ 1PD1071@L1[ <+[ I1.;+?+@L1
KB<7.6LY[ +<[ +?D+IB[ 01[ ;+[ 1R[ [ 01[ [ 01[ 07.71?-I1[ 01[ LI+@[email protected]+[ +..1KB[ +[ <+
6@3BI?+.7Y@[ FZ-; 7.+[ S[ -M1@[ 5B-71I@B[
1@[ +01;+@L1[ !*[ +<[ QM@L+?61@LB[ 01[
!B4IBWB[ 1<[ [ 01[ 21-I1HB[ 01[ [ <+[ K64M71@L1[ 6@3BJ?+.6Y@
) ) ) ) !) ) ) ") "#%) ) $ ) ) &) )
"$"# ) ) # $#") #) "() ) %") $" ) $) ) )
) ) ") "$") ) ") ")"$$"#") #") ) ) $) )
) ) $) '#)
O
/ EE;C IJI %9, ,C% G C'" ?O" 'E < 0 <O 1)
M.27#O O *-O O
:8D-5:O *-O !@$8D=#@-8(2$O LO H-8O :&3-@8:O O
K (:8D-6:+-F A#8D>#B-8(4 #-DO
O
NO
!
! !
! !
@N0\ <,\ ,OM0A.6,\ /0\ J0MCO0MN,\ ,\ MO\ MB=6.7NO/\ =,\ J0.<,?,@N0\ CJ0M0ANY\ OA,\ K0.=,?,.6YA
,@N0\ 0<\ BAM09B\ /0\ )K,AMC,K0A.6,\ R\ O0@\ B-60KAB\ 0A\ ,/0=,@N0\ )\ 0=\ \ /0\ ?,RB
/0\ \ 1O0\ K036MNK,/,\ .BA\ AZ?0KB\ /0\ 0QC0/70AN0\
%0/6,AN0\ B26.7B\ /0\ \ /0\ ?,RB\ /0\ \ 0=\ *\ K0?7N 6Y\ =,\ K0.<,?,.6YA\ ,\ =,\ (0.J0N,KV,
0A0K,<\ /0=\ ROAN,?60ANB\ /0\ "B3KBXB\ ,<\ B-:0NB\ /0\ HO0\ CO/60K,@\ CK0M0AN,K\ =,M
,=03,.6BA0M\ HO0\ M0\ .BAM7/0K,M0A\ BCBKNOA,M
A\ =,\ 20.5,\ 0A\ HO0\ M0\ /6.N,\ =,\ CK0M0AN0\ J0MB<O.6YA\ AB\ M0\ 4,A\ K0.7-6/B\ ,=03,.7BA0M\ ,<
K0HO0K 6?70ANB\ 020.NO,/B
0\ .BA2BK?6/,/\ .BA\ =B\ /6MCO0MNB\ 0@\ 0<\ ,KNW.O<B\ .\ /0\ =,\ #) \ R\ 0A\ 0=\ ,KNW.O=B\
/0=\ '0,=\ 0.K0NB\ \ /0\ \ /0\ B.NO-K0\ DBJ\ 0=\ IO0\ M0\ ,EKO0-,\ 0=\ MN,NONB\ /0<
B@M0;B\ /0\ +K,@ME,K0A.7,\ S\ O0A\ B-60KAB\
\
\ 0=\ &K0M6/0AN0\ /0\ 0MN,\ ,ONBK6/,/
,/?6A7MNK,N7P,\ 8A/0C0A/60AN0\ 0M\ .B?C0N0AN0\ C,K,\ K0MB=P0K\ <,M\ K0.=,?,.7BA0M\ HO0\ 0A
,C<6.,.6YA\ /0=\ ,JNV.O=B\ \ /0\ =,\ $)!
M0\ CK0M0AN0A\ 1K0AN0\ ,\ =,M\ K0MB=O.7BA0M\ 0QCK0M,M
B CJ0MOAN,M\J0.,W/,M\ 0A\ ?,N0K7,\ /0\ ,..0MB\ ,\ =,\ 7A2BK?,.6Y@
A\ P6LNO/\ /0 =\ ,F,KN,/B\ \ /0\ =,\ /6MGBM7.7YA\ ,/7.6BA,=\ .O,KN,\ /0\ =,\ ")!\
\ <,M
.B?OA6/,/0M\ ,ONYAB?,M\ CO0/0A\ ,NK6-O6K\ <,\ .B?C0N0A.6,\ C,J,\ <,\ K0MB<O.7YA\ /0\ =,M
K0.<,?,.7BA0M\ ,<\ )\ ?0/7,AN0\ =,\ .0=0-K,.6YA\ /0<\ .BKJ0MCBA/70AN0\ .BAP0A7B\ .BA\ =,
/?6@6MNJ,.7YA\ 0A0K,=\ /0=\ MN,/B\ A\ /0M,KKB<=B\ /0\ /7.5,\ CJ0P7M6YA\ 0Q6MN0\ .BAP0A6B
P730AN0\ MOM.K7NB\ .BA\ =,M\ .B?OA7/,/0M\ ,ONYAB?,M\ /0\ MNOK6,M\ ,AN,-K 6,\ ",\ '6B9,
QNK0?,/OK,\ ,MN7==, ",\ %,A.5,\ 0\ >=<0M\ ,=0,KM\ ,MW\ .B?B\.B@\ =,M\ .7O/,/0M\ ,ONY@B?,M
/0\ 0ON,\ R\ %0<6==,
\ N0@BK\ /0\ =B\ /7MCO0MNB\ 0@\ MO\ CK0T?-O<B\ =,\ #) \ N60A0\ CBK\ B-:0NB\ " "
" " " " " !" " " " " " " " "
" " " " " " " " " " "
" " " " " !" " " " " "
" " 0\ 0MN0\ ?B/B\ MO\ ,KNV.O<B\ \ K0.BAB.0\ 0=\ /0K0.5B\ /0\ NB/,M\ =,M
C0KMBA,M\ ,\ ,..0/0K\ ,\ =,\ 6A2BK?,.7YA\ C[-<6.,\ 0A\ =BM\ NUK?6ABM\ CK0P6MNBM\ 0@\ 0<\ ,LNV.O<B
‡
Ryyhv %
‚ ?eL Lv ?~vB:p:By iRm) TG'.2+y_'i'8:#
‡
R yzjv %
‚ ?fM Mv
?~vB;q‡ ;By k Sk‡ )TG'.62+##!‡ j'# {_'‡ [:
Ryzlw& ?fM Mw@~wC;q‡ ;Cz i S m‡ *TH(.62,##"‡ l($ {`'‡ [H;D~;:
Ryy j v %
‚ Be_vN YeILyp:_v j :pL_BU: Lv Ey‡ 4e]LLvyq<avj;qL_BU;
n
fqy:\|p:bvj<pLaBU<UbPer];BUeb…
LBe_De_€L_Uev
Bf_€M_Uew00++ Ry^ \‡
7†
Q
Vc=‡ ‡ JO‡ ‡
1gdxO
Z
g‡ JO‡ 9s>dx
=sOdFV>‡
„‡
/Od‡ 3gAWOsdg‡ --5‡
ƒ FgdxOYgKO} t =dxj=uO`F X=Ox‡
"H $%H /!H 329:+:;#+F2H >H $%9!6730/!$39H 436H $+#)!H 2371!H /%(!/ H 2H %9:%H 9%2:,$3H %0
!6:D#;03H H $%H /!H H $%'+2%H /!H ,2'371!#,F2H 4G"0+#!H #313H /39H #32:%2+$39H 3H
$3#;1%2:39H #;!/5;+%7!H 5;%H 9%!H 9;H &371!:3H 3H 93437:%H 5;%H 3"7%2H %2H 43$%7H $%H !/(;23H
$%H /39H 9;-%:39H +2#0;+$39H %2H %0H A1",:3H $%H !4/+#!#,F2H $%H %9:%H :C:;/3H >H 5;%H *!>!2H 9+$3H
%/!"37!$39H 3H !$5;+7,$39H %2H %0H %-%7#,#+3H $%H 9;9H &;2#+32%9 H
2H %/H 47%9%2:%H %=4%$+%2:%H 9%H 93/,#+:!H ,2&371!#+F2H 93"7%H #34+!H $%H /!H 7%93/;#+F2H $%H 039H
9;4;%9:39H 47A#:+#39H 40!2:%!$39H %2H ;239H 473#%939H 9%0%#:+<39H $32$%H )%H 4!7:+#,4!$3H %2H %0H
>;2:!1+%2:3H $%H 3(73E3H >H 23H 1%H 039H $!2 H
!H +2&371!#,F2H 930+#,:!$!H %9H +2&371!#,F2H 4G"/,#!H %2H /!H 1%$+$!H %2H 5;%H 3"7!H %2H 43$%7H $%H
;2H 9;-%:3H 3"/+(!$3H 437H /!H H 5;,%2H $+9432%H $%H %0/!H %2H %0H %-%7#+#+3H $%H /!9H ';2#+32%9H
5;%H :,%2%2H /%(!01%2:%H 7%#323#+$!9 H
2H %/H #!93H $%H %9:!H 7%#/!1!#,F2H #313H 9%H )!H +2$,#!$3H %2H /39H !2:%#%$%2:%9H %0
>;2:!1,%2:3H #32#%72,$3H 23H )!H $!$3H 7%94;%9:!H !H /!H 93/+#+:!2:%H >H :!143#3H )!
#32:%9:!$3H !/H 7%5;%7,1,%2:3H $%H !/%(!#+32%9H &371;/!$3H 437H %9:%H 329%-3 H 9:%H 473#%$%7
$,&,#;/:!H #329+$%7!"/%1%2:%H %0H #;14/+1+%2:3H $%H 0!H ';2#+F2H $%H (!7!2:C!H %2#31%2$!$!H !
%9:!H !;:37,$!$H !$1,2,9:7!:+<!H ,2$%4%2$+%2:%H !0H 23H 473437#+32!7/%H 2+H /!9H 6!?32%9H 437H /!9
5;%H 23H 9%H !:%2$,FH /!H 93/+#,:;$H $%H !##%93H 2+H 0!H <!037!#+F2H $%H 0!9H #;%9:,32%9H 4/!2:%!$!9
436H /!H 7%#0!1!2:%H #32H %/H &+2H $%H 5;%H 4;%$!H $+9432%6H $%H /39H %0%1%2:39H $%H -;+#,3
2%#%9!7,39H 4!7!H 4632;2#,!79%H 93"7%H /!H 473#%$%2#+!H 3H 23H $%H #32#%$%7H %0H !##%93H !H /!
,2&371!#+F2H 93/,#+:!$! H 313H #329%#;%2#+!H $%H %/03H %9:%H329%-3H+(237!H 9+H %2H !:%2#+F2
!H 9;H #32:%2,$3H #32#;67%H !/(;2!H #,6#;29:!2#+!H 5;%H +14+$!H 9;H 4;%9:!H !H $+9439,#+F2
%' ' ' '
+2H %1"!7(3H %/H +2#;14/,1+%2:3H 437H 4!6:%H $%H /!H !$1+2,9:7!#,F2H$%H /!H 3"/+(!#,F2H /%(!/H $%
$,#:!7H;2!H 7%93/;#+F2H %=46%9!H 93"7%H 0!H 93/+#+:;$H $%H !##%93H !9DH #313H /!H &!/:!H $%H 7%94;%9:!
!/H 7%5;%7+1,%2:3H $%H !/%(!#+32%9H $%H %9:%H 329%.3H 23H 4;%$%2H $%-!7H 9,2H %&+#!#,!H %/
%-%6#+#,3H $%H ;2H $%7%#)3H $%H 7!2(3H #329:,:;#+32!0H #313H %9H %/H $%7%#)3H $%H !##%93H !H /!
,2&371!#+F2H 4G"0,#!
H %9:39H %'%#:39H %9H 48%#,93H :%2%7H %2H #;%2:!H 5;%H 9%H :7!:!H $%H ;2H $%7%#)3H 5;%H (3@!H $%H ;2
!140+3H 7%#323#+1+%2:3H %2H 2;%9:73H 37$%2!1,%2:3H >H 5;%H #329,(;+%2:%1%2:%H #;!/5;,%6
7%9:7+##+F2H $%H 9;H %'+#!#+!H $%"%H 4!6:,7H $%H ;2!H ,2:%747%:!#+F2H %9:7+#:!H $%H /39H /C1,:%9H >
-;9:+'+#!7H $%H 1!2%7!H %=47%9!H >H 473437#,32!$!H 9;H !4/,#!#,F2 H 9CH /3H <,%2%H %=,(+%2$3H %0
7,";2!/H ;47%13H $%H 1!2%7!H #329:!2:%H #313H )!H 7%#37$!$3H %2H 9;H 9%2:%2#+!H $%H H $%H
-;2+3H $%H H H H %2H 039H 9+(;+%2:%9H :B71,239
$) !') ) ) ) ) ") ) ) ) ) ) ) )
) ) ) ) ') () ) ) ) ) ) ) )
) ) %) ) ) ) ) ) ) &) ) ) ) ) )
#) ) ) ') ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
' ' ' $' "' ' '
# ! '
&'
!
<>;A.02-;@Y DY .9Y /29Y =B.Y .9Y A;-;Y ,*@;Y 7;@Y 7P82A.@Y <>.C2@A;@Y @.Y *<72,*>N9Y *A.9-2.9-;Y
*Y B9Y A.@AY -.Y -*U;Y I-.7Y 29A.>O@Y =B.Y @.Y @*7C*0B*>-*Y ,;9Y .7Y 7T2A.Y EY -.Y 29A.>O@Y <W+72,;Y
.9Y 7*Y -2CB70*,2V9Y =B.Y .9Y .7Y ,*@;Y ,;9,>.A;Y 9;Y <>.C*7.F,*Y .7Y 29A.>O@Y <W+72,;Y .9Y 7*Y
-2CB70*,2V9Y -.Y 7*Y 29/;>8*,2V9Y EY -.Y /;>8*Y <>;<;>,2;9*-*Y EY 7282A*-*Y <;>Y @BY ;+6.A;Y EY
/29*72-*-Y
[email protected] '>2+B9*7Y 1*Y A.92-;Y ;,*@2V9Y -.Y @.U*7*>Y &'&Y 9XY Y -.Y Y -.Y ;,AB+>.Y -.Y
Y >.,Y JY EY &'&Y Y -.Y 8*?H;Y -.Y Y >.,Y >.@<.,A;Y
*Y 7;@Y 7Q82A.@Y ;<;92+7.@Y />.9A.Y *7Y *,,.@;Y *Y 7*Y 29/;>8*,2V9Y <W+72,*Y =B.Y L(Y Y )Y $*Y
/;>8B7*,2V9Y *8<72*Y .9Y .7Y >.,;9;,282.9A;Y EY .9Y 7*Y >.0B7*,2V9Y 7.0*7Y -.7Y -.>.,1;Y -.Y
*,,.@;Y *Y 7*Y 29/;>8*,2V9Y ;+720*Y *Y 29A.><>.A*>Y -.Y /;>8*Y .@A>2,A*Y ,B*9-;Y 9;Y >.@A>2,A2C*Y
A*9A;Y 7*@Y 7282A*,2;9.@Y *Y [email protected] -.>.,1;Y =B.Y @.Y ,;9A.8<7*9Y .9Y .7Y *>ASB7;Y Y -.Y 7*Y $.EY
Y ,;8;Y 7*@Y ,*B@*@Y -.Y29*-82@2V9Y -.Y @;72,2AB-.@Y -.Y 2:>8*,2V9Y =B.Y *<*>.,.9Y
.9B8.>*-*@Y .9Y .7Y *>AP,B7;Y Y @29Y =B.Y =B.<*Y *,.<A*>Y 7282A*,2;9.@Y =B.Y @B<;90*9Y B9Y
8.9;@,*+;Y 296B@A53,*-;Y EY -.@<>;<;>,2;9*-;Y -.7Y -.>.,1;Y -.Y *,,.@;Y *Y 7*Y
29/;>8*,2V9MY
.Y 8*9.>*Y =B.Y @;7;Y @;9Y *,.<A*+7.@Y 7*@Y 7282A*,2;9.@Y =B.Y >[email protected] 6B@A2/2,*-*@Y EY
<>;<;>,2;9*-*@Y *@PY 7;Y -2@<;9.Y .7Y *>AP,B7;Y Y -.Y 7*Y $.EY Y L(Y Y )Y Y $*Y
*<72,*,2V9Y -.Y 7;@Y 7R82A.@Y @.>NY 6B@A54,*-*Y EY <>;<;>,2;9*-*Y *Y @BY ;+6.A;Y EY /29*72-*-Y -.Y
<>;A.,,2V9Y EY *A.9-.>NY *Y 7*@Y ,2>,B9@A*9,2*@Y -.7Y ,*@;Y ,;9,>.A;Y .@<.,2*78.9A.Y *Y 7*Y
,;9,B>>.9,2*Y -.Y B9Y 29A.>O@Y <W+72,;Y ;Y <>2C*-;Y @B<.>2;>Y =B.Y 6B@A54=B.Y .7Y *,,.@;MY %;>Y
A*9A;Y 7*Y <;@2+272-*-Y -.Y 7282A*>Y .7Y -.>.,1;Y -.Y *,,.@;Y *Y 7*Y 29/;>8*,2V9Y 9;Y ,;[email protected]
B9*Y <;A.@A*-Y -2@,>.,2;9*7Y -.Y 7*Y -8292@A>*,2V9Y EY @;7;Y >.@B7A*Y <;@2+7.Y ,B*9-;Y
,;9,B>>*Y B9;Y -.Y 7;@Y @B<B.@A;@Y 7.0*78.9A.Y .@A*+7.,2-;Y =B.Y *<*>.G,*Y -.+2-*8.9A.Y
*,>.-2A*-;Y <;>Y =B2.9Y 7;Y 29C;,*Y EY >[email protected] <>;<;>,2;9*-;Y EY 7282A*-;Y <;>Y @BY ;+6.A;Y EY
/29*72-*-Y "#Y XKY
3 )!#&3 3 #3 ,$*()#3 #3 %*3 3 #* !)1"3 (#) 3 )!3 3 #!1!3 3
!#& 1!3 $2 3 -3 %*3 3 -*!) !)#3 3 #�#3 !#3 3 *()#3 3 $1!3
3 *!#3 3 #(3 . )(3 $'+()#(3 !3 #(3 ').*#(3 3
-3 3
3 3 3 !3 3
#!*&&!3 3 *!3 *(3 3 ! (1!3 3 &)/*#3
()3 #!(#3 3 $&#'3
3 () &3 3 & 1!3 $&(!)3
=]]KV ``` 0H9 9V0^V3,R,3Z K=L>6#&! ZEK,e
= ]]MW
```e 0I::W 1^W4-Re -4[ M =Ne >6#)&!e [EDO-e e
e
= ]]MV ```e 0H9 9X 0^W3,Re
, 3Z M=Ne >6#)&!e ZEDM,e e
*c
<
?F.e e 7;e e
%JGY;
B
Je 7;e +S/GY
P
.S;G5?/e
be
$_;Ge 'J2@;SGJe ""(e
a 5JGY;
C
J8;\ T.GY
Q
.U;G5 A.;Ye
de
1R ?"2 )P1R R -3>R 2?" "!"1?">R DR $@2!0"1?3>R *A;L! ) 3>R !"> ;(?3>R 4;3 "!"R
-R ;" .0 (P1R 4;">"1?!R #;"1?"R .R D@1?0)"1?3R !"R 3%;3N3R
.R D@1?0)"2?3R !"R 3%;3O3R R 8A"R "2R "-R 4.H3R 0JC)03R !"R B")2?"R
!L>R 'J)-">R # (-)?"R R .R ;" .01?"R .R >)%@("1?"R ) 1#3;0 )P2R
34)R M2?"%;R !"R ->R ;">3.@ (31">R R .3>R !3>R >@4A">?3>R 4-2?"!3>R 43;R ".R ; )@2.R
-)$) !3;R !"R -R 4;@"R 4;J ?) R !".R 4;3 ">3R >"-" ?(B3R 4;R A;(;R .R 4-HR !"R
>A(1>4" ?3;R !"R ?;)@?3>R
-R DA1?0("2?3R !"R 3%;3N3R R 9@"R "2R ".R 0)>03R 4-H3R 0JC(03R !"R
B")2?"R !L>R 'J).">R ;"0)?R R ">?"R 32>"+3R !"R ;1>4;"1 (R DR @"1R 3)";13R 34)R !"R
.R (1#3;0 (P1R "1B(!R R -R ;" -01?"R
"R @";!3R 31R ".R ;?L @-3R 2Q0";3R !"R -R "ER !"R !"R !) ("0;"R !"R
;2>5;"1 (R ">3R R -R 1#3;0 )P1R Q-( R FR A"1R 3(";23
R -R " -0 )P1R
4;"B(>?R "1R "-R ;?M A.3R R !"R .R 0(>0R ?)"1"R -R 32>)!"; )P1R !"R >A>?(?@?)BR !"R .3>R
;" @;>3>R !0(1)>?;?(B3>R !"R 31#3;0)!!R 31R -3R !)>4@">?3R "1R "/R ;?M A-3R !"R .R "GR
!"R !"R 3 ?@;"R !"R <3 "!)0)"2?3R !0)1(>?;?)B3R 30Q1R !"R .>R
!0)1(>?; (31">R Q.) >
R
32?;R -R 4;">"1?"R ;">3.A )P1R 8A"R 431"R #(1R R .R BLR !0(1)>?;?(BR >"R 43!;JR )1?";431";R
;" @;>3R 31?"1 )3>3!0(1)>?;?(B3R "1R ".R 4-H3R !"R !3>R 0">">R !);" ?0"1?"R 1?"R .R
.R !"R -3R 31?"1 )3>3!0)1)>?;?)B3R !"R .R A!)"1 )R (32-R !"R 31#3;0)!!R 31R .3R
4;"B(>?3R "1R "-R 6;?!3R :@)1?3R !"R -R (>73>( )P1R !) )31.R @=?R !"R .R "ER !"R
!"R ,A-)3R "&@.!3;R !"R -R @<)>!) (P1R 31?"1 )3>3!0(1)>?;?(B
R R R R
!3R 3>KR @)>R 3!; M %A"HR I.B;"HR
k
B aaR^ ggg 5O>>^ 5d^80Yk 0 8a S C Sk #H;"'-*$k aL"KR"0
BaaT_!ggg6P??_6e_91Yk 29a UBVk #E;"'-*%bL"k U"1k k
DaaT^ ! gg g6O> >^6d^80Zk08ak TBVk #E;"'-*%bL"k S"0k
.jAFM3k k <@k k
)QN`@IQk <@k /[4N`W3[@N:F4k ik (f@Nk +Q7G@[NQk &&,k
h :QN`@JQ=@c \3L`X3]@N: H3@`k