El solicitante pidió información sobre la gestión de fondos europeos al Ayuntamiento de Alcorcón. Tras una respuesta insuficiente, el interesado reclamó ante el Consejo de Transparencia y Buen Gobierno. El Consejo estima la reclamación, obligando al Ayuntamiento a entregar la información solicitada por no concurrir límites legales.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
El derecho de acceso a la información pública prevalece sobre la mera dificultad técnica de recopilar los datos solicitados.
2
La administración no puede denegar el acceso basándose en que la información requiere una labor de recopilación exhaustiva si los datos existen.
3
El Ayuntamiento de Alcorcón no justificó la aplicación de ningún límite legal del art. 14 de la Ley 19/2013 para denegar la información.
4
Se determina que la respuesta del Ayuntamiento fue insuficiente al no proporcionar los datos concretos sobre la ejecución de los fondos.
Texto completo
" "
! "
" " "
$&Y OBK. Y
.+3)Y !)Y -.Y 9)Y /5G=)Y
&.+<)=)>J.Y
4E.++4U>Y
PL?K)=5.?KAY -.Y ')?KAT)Y )?K)*F6)Y
A8)Y -.Y N):AG),5V?Y -.Y BGA-L,K6N6-)-Y
%# ' S%Y
'.1W?Y I.Y -.IBG.?-.Y -.Y :)Y -A,M=.?K),6V@Y DM.Y A*G)Y .?Y .;Y .OB.-6.?K.Y .;Y G.,:)=)@K.
IA;6,6KVY );Y PL?K)=6.?KAY -.Y ')?KAT)Y );Y )=B)HAY -.Y :)Y !.QY
-.Y Y -.Y -6,5.=*G.
-.Y KG)?IC)F.?,6)Y ),,.IAY )Y :)Y 5?0AG=),6V?Y CX*;5,)Y RY *M.?Y 2A*5.G?A
.?Y )-.:)?K.
"( Y .;Y Y -.Y .?.GAY -.Y Y ;)Y I61L5.?K.Y5?0AG=),7V?Y
# # # # # # # #
# # # # # # # "# # # "# # # #
# !# # # "# # # # # # # # #
# # # "# # # # # # # # # # #
# #
I
+??6= CDC !4( (=!A=#9#? 6+6 ,%
G*-2I I &)I I
53>)05I &)I : 3>7:)3$- I FI B)3I 5".):35I I
E $53>)15')@ ; 3>8<)3$ /)>I
I
HI
!
! !
! !
Y ;Y Y /0Y 10-H0HBY /0Y Y CI0K0@LWY MA,Y H0.;,?,.6WAY ,AL0Y 0<Y BAK08BY /0Y (I,AKC,[email protected],Y P
M0AY B-50H@BY 0AY ,/0<,@L0Y ( Y ML 5;6R,A/BY MAY 1BH?M<,H5BY /0Y FM09,Y <,Y .M,=Y 1M0
H025KLH,/,Y .BAY AX?0HBY /0Y 0OC0/60AL0Y
+@,Y N0RY ,CBHL,/,Y ;,Y .BC 5,Y /0Y <,Y KB;5.5LM/Y 6A6.5,;Y PY ,K TY KM-K,A,/,Y 0;Y Y /0Y ?,IRBY /0Y
0<Y ( Y H0?6L5WY <,Y I0.;,?,.5WAY ,Y ;,Y '0.H0L,HU,Y 0A0I,;Y /0;Y PMAL,?60ALBY /0Y ',ALBV,Y 0<
Y /0Y ?,HRBY /0Y Y ,<Y B-80LBY /0Y FM0Y CM/50J,AY CH0K0AL,HY >,KY ,<02,.5B@0KY FM0Y K0
.BAK5/0H,K0AY BCBHLMA,KY PY K0Y ,CBIL,K0Y M@,Y .BC5,Y /0=Y 0OC0/50AL0Y LH,?5L,/B
<Y Y /0Y ?,HRBY /0Y Y K0Y 3,Y H0.6-5/BY B15.5BY /0<Y <.,=/0Y /0Y ',ALBV,Y CBHY 0<Y FM0Y K0Y 0OC<6.,
FM0Y 0<Y Y /0Y 10-H0HBY /0Y Y K0Y H0?5L5WY 0;Y /B.M?0ALBY KB;5.6L,/BY ,<Y 6AL0H0K,/BY .MP,
ABL616.,.6WAY 0<0.LHWA6.,Y 1M0Y I0.3,R,/,Y '0Y ,/9MAL,Y .BC 5,Y /0Y /5.4,Y .B?MA6.,.5WAY PY /0Y <,
H0KB<M.5WAY ,/?6A5KLH,L 5N,Y FM0Y ,CIB-WY <,Y .5L,/,Y 3B8,Y /0Y N,=BH,.6W@Y /0Y CHB/M.L5N5/,/
PY K0Y ,;02,Y FM0Y ;,Y ,.LM,.6WAY [email protected],<Y 3,Y K5/BY .BA1BH?0Y ,Y <0P
<Y H0.<,?,AL0Y?,A5150KL,Y 0AY 0;Y LHS?5L0Y /0Y ,M/60A.6,Y .BA10H6/BY CBIY 0KL0Y BAK08BY FM0Y 0;
,PM@L,?60ALBY L60A0Y ;,Y B-<52,.5W@Y /0Y CM-< 5.,HY 0;Y 0OC0/50AL0Y .B?C<0LBY .BAY LB/,KY =,K
0N,<M,.5BA0KY FM0Y K0Y 4,AY 30.3BY ,Y LB/BY 0<Y C0IKBA,<
0Y .BA1BH?5/,/Y .BAY <BY /5KCM0KLBY 0@Y 0;Y ,HLT.M;BY .Y /0Y <,Y #)! Y PY 0AY 0<Y ,HLT.M=BY
/0<Y &0,<Y 0.H0LBY Y /0Y Y /0Y B.LM-H0Y DBIY 0<Y GM0Y K0Y ,EHM0-,Y 0<Y KL,LMLBY /0;
B@K0:BY /0Y *H,@KE,H0A.5,Y QY M0AY B-50HABY
Y
Y 0<Y %H0K6/0AL0Y /0Y 0KL,Y ,MLBH5/,/
,/?5A6KLH,L6N,Y 6A/0C0A/50AL0Y 0KY .B?C0L0AL0Y C,H,Y H0KB=N0HY ;,KY H0.<,?,.6BA0KY FM0Y 0A
,C;5.,.5WAY /0<Y ,ILU.M<BY Y /0Y <,Y #*"
K0Y CH0K0AL0AY 1H0AL0Y ,Y <,KY H0KB<M.6BA0KY 0OCH0K,K
B CI0KMAL,KYI0.,T/,KY 0AY ?,L0H6,Y /0Y ,..0KBY ,Y <,Y 6A1BH?,.5W@
AY N5ILM/Y /0 <Y ,E,HL,/BY Y /0Y <,Y /5KDBK6.6WAY ,/6.7BA,<Y .M,HL,Y /0Y <,Y $*" Y
Y ;,K
.B?MA5/,/0KY ,MLWAB?,KY CM0/0@Y ,LH5-M5HY ;,Y .B?C0L0A.5,Y C,I,Y ;,Y H0KB;M.6WAY /0Y =,K
H0.;,?,.6BA0KY ,;Y * Y ?0/6,AL0Y <,Y .0<0-H,.5WAY /0;Y .BHI0KCBA/60AL0Y .BAN0A6BY .BAY <,
/?5@5KLI,.6WAY 0A0H,<Y /0<Y KL,/BY AY /0K,HHB;<BY /0Y /6.3,Y CI0N6K5WAY 0O5KL0Y .BAN0A5B
N620AL0Y KMK.H6LBY .BAY <,KY .B?MA6/,/0KY ,MLWAB?,KY /0Y KLMH5,KY ,@L,-H 5,Y $,Y &5B8,
…
Q xxgt %
€€€ ?dKKt ?}tB9n… 9Bx hRh… )SG'-51*x^'Zg'79#
…
Q xyit %
€€€ ?dL Lt
?}tB9n… :Bx j R j… )SG'-51*##!… i'# z^'… Z9
Qxygu&€€€ ?eL Lu
@}uC:n…
:Cy h R k… )SG(-51+##"… k($ z_'… ZG;D}:;
Qxx i t %
€€€ Bd^vM XdHKxn9^t i <nK^BT9 Kt Ex… 3d\KKtxn9`ti9nK^BT9
l
ds<[{n9ati9nK`BT9TaOdo\9BTdaƒ
KBe^Dd^K^TdvBd^L^Tdt//** Q{] […
6„
P
Ub=… … IN… …
0fcwN
Y
f… IN… 8p>cw
m
=pNcFU>…
‚…
.~Nc… 2fAVNpcf… ,,4…
FfcwNXfJN| q =cwi=rN_FW =Nw…
=:5"0!;5I 9:),,I 1 &I "I /,+"9I ,"59I 9DI 202I 21I ,9I );!!"9I ;:G1209I
!"I ";:I >I "+(,,I
21I 5B :"5I 35"<(2I I 212 "5I 926"I "+I $21!2I !",I 9;1:2I 3,1:"!2I 6"9;+:I 1" "95(2
!":"1"59"I "1I "-I 1B, (9(9I !"I ;1I ;"9:)G1I $260,I "+I 3,@2I "9:." )!2I 35I #250;,5I ,
5" +0 )G1I 3;"9:2I 4;"I "1I 92I !"I 35" (5I 4;"I "=(9:"I "=:"03261")!!I !""6E
)1!0):)59"I ,I 5" +0 )G1I 9)1I "1:55I "1I "+I #21!2I !"I +2I "1I ",,I 3+1:"!2
I "9:29I "#" :29I "I 9"F,5I 4;"I ",I 5:D ;,2I I !"I +I I ! (9321"I 4;"I
9)0(902I "+I 6:D ;,2I I
!"I ,I "?I I !"I I !"I 2 :;5"I !"I 52 "!(0("1:2
!0(1(9:6:(<2I 20H1I !"I ,9I !0(1)9:5 (21"9I H+( 9I 37"<CI 4;"I ,29I 3+@29I 9"I
203;:6B1I I 35:(5I !",I !DI 9)%;("1:"I I 4;"+I "1I 4;"I :"1%I +;%7I ,I 12:($) )G1I 2I
3;+( )G1I !"-I :2I !"I 4;"I 9"I :6:"I 2I !"9!"I "+I 9(%;("1:"I I 4;"+I "1I 4;"I 9"I 352!;@ I ,I
"9:)0 (G1I 2I!"9"9:(0 )G1I 327I 9(+"1 )2I !0(1(9:5:(<2I F!("1!2I 4;"I 9(I "1I ",I 0"9I !"I
<"1 )0)"1:2I 12I ';("5I ! DI "4;(<,"1:"I I 4;",I "1I 4;"I 20)"1AI "+I G03;:2I 9"I
"1:"1!"6BI4;"I ",I 3,A2I "=3(6I ",I H,:)02I !EI !",I 0"9I
"%H1I 219:I "1I "+I "=3"!("1:"I "1I "9:"I 92I "+I >;1:0("1:2I !"I 1:2FI 5"92+<(GI !"I
$250I "=37"9I "+I I !"I #"7"52I!"I I !"1:52I !",I 3,A2I ,"%+I !"I I 0"9I !"9!"I ",I I !"I
"1"52I !"I I 0("1:59I 4;"I "+I 92,( ):1:"I 35"9"1:GI 9;I 5" ,0 (G1I 1:"9I !",I :89 ;592I
!"I !) '2I 3,A2I ",I I !"I #"6"52I !"I I
"I 02!2I 4;"I ;14;"I 35"1:"0"1:"I "+I >;1:0("1:2I 'I :;!2I 21#250"I I ,">I ,I
5" +0 )G1I !""I 9"5I )1!0):)!I 325I 5A21"9I !"I 3+A2I 9(1I "1:55I I <+255I ,9I
;"9:(21"9I 4;"I ",I 6" +01:"I3,1:"I "1I 9;I 5" ;592I "5 I !"I 3;,( )!!I :(<I >I !"I
,29I !:29I 926"I +I <+26 (G1I !"I ,29I 2:529I "03+"!29I 3H+) 29I ,9I ;,"9I 12I "9:1I
)1 +;(!9I"1I9;I 92+) (:;!I )1( (,I
1I :"1 (G1I I +29I 1:" "!"1:"9I >I #;1!0"1:29I *;5D!( 29I !"9 5):29I 352 "!"I
,I 5" +0 (G1I 35"9"1:!I #5"1:"I +I >;1:0("1:2I !"I 1:2FI
P
0FF<D JKJP &:- -D&HD(#@P #(F =0=P 3*!=F7P 6#
N/18$P P +.P P
;9E.4;P +.P "A%9E>$A.9)1%P MP I.9P ;'2.A9;P P
L );9E.5;,.G B$9E?$C.9) 3$.EP
OP
!
,S (*E,@+:S *:9S ,3S (@DO*E4:S S 9R8,@:S S +,S 4(S ,GS S +,S S +,S +0*1,8)@, S +,S
&@(9C;(@,9*1(S **,C:S (S 4(S 9-:@8(*0Q9S #R)41*(S HS E,9S :)1,@9:5S 4(S $,*4(8(*0Q9S
<@,F1CD(S ,9S ,4S (@DP*E3:S S +,S 3(S 81C8(S D0,9,S 4(S *:9C0+,@(*0Q9S +,S CECD1DED0F(S +,S 3:CS
@,*E@C:CS (+8190CD@(D1F:CS +,S *:9-:@80+(+S *:9S 4:S +0C<E,CD:S ,9S ,6S (@DP*E4:S S +,S 3(S !,IS
+,S S +,S :*DE)@,S +,S #A:*,+080,9D:S +8091CDB(D1F:S :8R9S +,S 3(CS
+8091CDB(*1:9,CS #R)30*(C
S
:9DA(S 4(S <@,C,9D,S @,C:3E*0Q9S >E,S <:9,S -19S (S 3(S FO(S (+8190CD@(D1F(S C,S <:+BMS 19D,@<:9,@S
@,*E@C:S *:9D,9*0:C:(+8190CD@(D1F:S ,9S ,3S <4(K:S +,S +:CS 8,C,CS +1B,*D(8,9D,S (9D,S 3(S
%(3(S +,S 4:S :9D,9*0:C:(+8090CD@(D0F:S +,S 3(S E+0,9*0(S "(*1:9(4S +,S *:9-:@80+(+S *:9S 3:S
<@,F1CD:S ,9S ,4S (;(@D(+:S ?E 09D:S +,S 4(S 1C=:C1*0Q9S (+0*0:9(3S *E(BD(S +,S 7(S ,JS
+,S
S +,S 2E40:S $,.E3(+:@(S +,S 4(S EA0C+0**1Q9S :9D,9*0:C:(+8190CD@(D1F(
S
!S #$%"&S S 'S
+:S :CNS E0CS $:+@P/E,KS L3F(@,KS
> [[LX aaa 1J::X1^X4-Sg - 4[ M ? Mg @7#)& g [GFL-g
>[\ N Y baag 1J; ;Y 2_Y5-Sg .5[ O ? Og @7#)&!+[GFO.g g
> [[NX aaa 1J: :X2 _ X4- Tg- 4[ M?Mg @7#)& [GFP-g
*e=AH/g g 8<g g
%KIZ<DKg 8<g ,U0IZQ/U<I6A0g dg $`<Ig 'K3B<UIKg ""(g
c 6KIZ<EK9<] V /GZR/W<I6 C/<Zg
fg