El interesado solicitó acceso a información sobre el uso de fondos europeos en el marco del Plan de Recuperación, Transformación y Resiliencia. Tras una respuesta insuficiente de la administración, el Consejo de Transparencia y Buen Gobierno estima la reclamación, obligando a la administración a proporcionar la información detallada solicitada.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
La administración no puede denegar el acceso basándose en la existencia de una publicación general si esta no contiene la información detallada y específica solicitada.
2
El derecho de acceso a la información pública prevalece cuando la administración no ha demostrado la existencia de un límite legal que justifique la denegación.
3
Se considera insuficiente la remisión a portales de transparencia si la información allí disponible no satisface la solicitud concreta del interesado.
4
El Consejo recuerda que la administración debe realizar un esfuerzo activo para localizar y facilitar la información solicitada.
Texto completo
$& E>B-M M
( )M ,-M 7)M .4?;)M
%(
"' (
$%#' " $!( C<B)M ,-M =;C<3,),-AM ,-M )AB47 7)!)M #)<+1) M =<A-5-?I)M
,-M -A)?@=78=M '=AB-<4*8-M
!#' ( $!%( 'C*D-<+4=<-AM +=<+-,4,)AM >)?)M B@)B);3-<B=AM A48DJ+=7)AM
%!( ( ( "$!&' ( %#'H%M
'-0L<M A-M ,-A>@-<,-M ,-M 7)M ,=+C;-<B)+4K<M =*?)<B-M -<M -7M -E>-,4-<B-M -7M M ,-M ;)?G=M ,-
M -8M ?-+7);)<B-M A=74+3BKM )9M );>)?=M ,-M 8)M "-FM M ,-M M ,-M ,4+4-;*?-M ,-
B?)<A>)?-<+4)M )++-A=M )M 7)M 4</=?;)+3K<M >L*74+)M FM *C-<M 0=*4-?<=M -<M ),-7)<B-M !(
)M 8)M =<A-6-?J)M ,-M -A)??=88=M '=AB-<4*8-M ,-M )AB487)!)M #)<+2)M :)M A40C3-<B-M 4<.=?;)+3K<
%& & & &
7(B 5,(0'1B &12412,(6$4,1B '(B .$B 2$4&(.$B '(.B 21.?*101 '(B .$B .1&$.,'$'B '(
,01-15$B 6>4/,01B /70,&,2$.B '(B "$46$0('1B =7$'$.$-$4$B (.B '?$B B &10B
4(*,5641B '(B (064$'$B B 5(B 51.,&,6$B 5($0B ,08(56,*$'$5B $.B /(015B '15B 57%8(0&,10(5B
&10&(','$5B $.B &10&(-$.B '(.B :706$/,(061B '(B #$46$0('1B BB B 214B 70B 8$.14B $2419,/$'1B
'(B B (7415B :B 64$%$-15B 5,.8?&1.$5B 4($.,<$'15B 214B .%$4B 14(56$.B !B (0B ',&+$B ),0&$B
5,0B ,0)14/$4/(B :B 5,0B /,B $7614,<$&,@0B 01B 5(B +$B &106(56$'1B +$56$B .$B )(&+$B
.B '?$B B &10B 4(*,5641B '(B (064$'$B B 5(B 2,'(B 61'$B .$B '1&7/(06$&,@0B
4()(4(06(B $B 57%8(0&,10(5B :B 64$%$-15B 4($.,<$'15B (0B ',&+$B ),0&$B .B B 5(B
&106(56$B &10B 0A/(41B '(B 5$.,'$B B &10B .$5B %$5(5B 2A%.,&$5B '(B .$5B 57%8(0&,10(5B
;B 64$5B &108(45$&,@0B 6(.()@0,&$B 5(B /(B ,0)14/$B 37(B 5,0B $&4(',6$4B .$B 2412,('$'B 01B /(B
& & & $& "& & &
# ! &
!
! !
! !
39&%&0B %"5B />7B +0'15/"$+@0B .B B $10B 5&)+7851B %&B &085"%"B B 7&B
:9&.:&B "B 71.+$+8"5B ."B /+7/"B %1$9/&08"$+@0B "3158"0%1B -978+'+$"08&B %&B 3513+&%"%B %&B
%+$*"B (0$"B *"78"B ."B '&$*"B 01B 7&B *"B $108&78"%1B 5"7B :"5+"7B $10:&6"$+10&7B
35&7&0$+".&7B $10B BB B /&B +0'15/"B 49&B :9&.:"B "B 71.+$+8"5B 185"B :&=B ."B %1$9/&08"$+@0B
"71$+"%"B "B 79#:&0$+10&7B $10$&%+%"7B <B 85"#"-17B 5&".,="%17B &0B %+$*"B '+0$"B "3158"0%1B
%1$9/&081B %&.B &)+7851B %&B ."B 513+&%"%B
.B B 7&B "3158"B $13+"B &;8&07"B %&.B &)+7851B %&B ."B 513+&%"%B %&B 1.+02B %&B
5")@0B "$5&%+8"0%1B /+B 3513+&%"%B :1.:+&0%1B "B 71.+$+8"5B $13+"B %&B ."B %1$9/&08"$+@0B
"71$+"%"B "B .17B &;3&%+&08&7B %&B %+$*"7B 79#:&0$+10&7B $10$&%+%"7B 39&7B 3"5"B $10$&%&5"7B
&7B 5&49+7+81B +/35&7$+0%+#.&B 7&5B 3513+&8"5+1B %&.B B %&B ."B 3513+&%"%B 7&)A0B
015/"8+:"B 315B .1B 49&B *"<B 7173&$*"7B '90%"%"7B %&B 49&B &.B $10$&-".B %&B !"58"0&%1B BB B
31%5?"B *"#&5B $1/&8+%1B &085&B 18517B %&.+817B %&B '5"9%&B <B '".7&%"%B %1$9/&08". B &$*"B
%&B *1<B 01B 7&B *"B 5&$+#+%1B $108&78"$+@0B
4<&H 0"H $54<&;<"$,F4H "H 5<8"H ;51,$,<=%H "4<&8,58H %&H ,4(583"$-F4H ;,3,1"8H %&H H %&H '&85
%&H H 8&$-#-%"H &0H H %&H '	&85H %&H H &2H ;50,$-<"4<&H 68&;&4<FH =4"H 8&$0"3"$,F4H"4<&
&0H 54;&.5H %&H 8"4;6"8&4$,"H @H =&4H 5#,&845H &4H "%&0"4<&H !H &0H H %&H 3"8A5H %&
H 8&),;<8"%"H $54H 4G3&85H %&H &?6&%,&4<&H
54H "4<&8-58,%"%H &0H !H <9"3,<FH =4"H 8&$0"3"$-F4H ;5#9&H 0"H 3,;3"H $=&;<,F4H $54
4G3&95H %&H &?6&%-&4<&H H 8&;=&0<"H 659H 0"H H H H %&H H %&H 5$<=#8&
1H H %&H 3"8B5H %&H H &0H !H 8&3-<-FH 0"H 8&$1"3"$-F4H "H 0"H &$8&<"8E"H &4&8"0H %&
54;&/&8E"H %&H &;"885105H 5;<&4,#0&H "1H 5#.&<5H %&H 7=&H ;&H 6=%,&8"4H 68&;&4<"9H 1";
"1&)"$,54&;H 7=&H ;&H $54;-%&8";&4H 565:=4";
%' ' ' '
1H H %&H "#8-1H %&H H ;&H 8&$-#&H 5'-$,5H %&H $54<&;<"$,F4H %&H 0"H &$8&<"8E"H &4&8"1H 658H &0
7=&H ;&H 654&H %&H 3"4,'-&;<5H 7=&H 0"H 68&;&4<&H 9&$1"3"$,F4H &;<CH 68&;&4<"%"H "4<&;H %&H 7=&
<8"4;$=89"H &1H 61"A5H %&H H 3&;H 6"8"H 9&;51>&8H "$&8$"H %&H 0"H ;51,$,<=%H $54(583&H "1H "8<E$=05
H %&H 1"H !
5H 5#;<"4<&H ;&H -4%,$"H "H &;<&H 54;&/5H 7=&H ;&H *"H "$58%"%5H $54$&%&8H 0"H ,4(583"$-F4
;50,$-<"%"H "%.=4<"4%5H $56-"H %&H 0"H 8&;50=$-F4H %&H &;< ,3"$-F4H %&H 1"H 3-;3"H '&$+"H H %&
"#8-1H %&H H @H %&H 1"H %5$=3&4<"$-F4H 9&3,<-%"H "1H ;50,$,<"4<&H $5369&4;,>"H %&H 1";
;50,$-<=%&;H %&H ;=#>&4$,F4H 68&;&4<"%";H 658H =4H <&8$&85H &4H H @H H 1";H 9&;6&$<->";
8&;50=$-54&;H "685#"<58,";H 05;H 8&7=&8,3,&4<5;H ;5#8&H .=;<-(,$"$-F4H %&H 0"H ,4>&8;,F4H @H 0";
8&;50=$-54&;H %&H 6D8%-%"H %&1H %&8&$+5H "1H $5#85H $54H "454,3,A"$-F4H %&H 05;H %"<5;H %&
$"9C$<&9H 6&8;54"0
' ' ' $' "' ' '
# ! '
&'
,W *<:-<C90+(+W *<:W 5<W +0F=H,FG<W ,:W ,6W (CGR*I6<W *W +,W 5(W !&W LW ,:W ,5W (CGR*I7<W
+,5W %,(5W ,*C,G<W W +,W W +,W <*GH)C,W ><DW ,5W AH,W F,W (?CH,)(W ,5W FG(GHG<W +,6
<:F,3<W +,W &C(:F@(C,:*1(W MW H,:W <)0,C:<W
W
W ,5W $C,F0+,:G,W +,W ,FG(W (IG<C0+(+
(+90:1FGC(G1J(W 1:+,=,:+0,:G,W ,FW *<9=,G,:G,W =(C(W C,F<5J,CW 6(FW C,*5(9(*1<:,FW BH,W ,:W
(=60*(*0U:W +,5W (DGS*H5<WW +,W 5(W !&
F,W =C,F,:G,:W -C,:G,W (W 5(FW C,F<5H*1<:,FW ,K=C,F(FW
< =D,FH:G(FW D,*(R+(FW ,:W 9(G,C1(W +,W (**,F<W (W 5(W 0:-<C9(*0U:
:W J0DGH+W +,5W (?(CG(+<W W +,W 5(W +0F><F1*1U:W (+1*0<:(5W *I(CG(W +,W 6(W "' W
W 6(F
*<9I:0+(+,FW (HGU:<9(FW =I,+,:W (GC0)I0EW 6(W *<9=,G,:*0(W =(D(W 6(W C,F<6I*1U:W +,W 7(FW
C,*6(9(*1<:,FW (6W &W 9,+1(:G,W 5(W *,5,)C(*0U:W +,6W *<CD,F=<:+1,:G,W *<:J,:1<W *<;W 5(W
+90:0FGD(*1U:W ,:,C(5W +,5W FG(+<W :W +,F(CD<65<W +,W +1*/(W =D,J1F0U:W ,K0FG,W *<:J,:0<
J1.,:G,W FHF*C1G<W *<:W 5(FW *<9H:1+(+,FW (IGU:<9(FW +,W FGHC0(FW (:G()C 0(W "(W %0<4(W
KGC,9(+HC(W (FG155("(W #(:*/(W ,W 556,FW (5,(CFW (FRW *<9<W *<:W 5(FW *1H+(+,FW (HGU:<9(FW
+,W ,HG(W LW #,6055(W
<:W *(CP*G,CW =C,J0<W (W *<:<*,CW F<)D,W ,5W -<:+<W +,5W (FH:G<W =5(:G,(+<W D,FI6G(W :,*,F(C0<
+,G,:,CF,W ,:W ,8W (:P5 0F0FW +,W H:(W *H,FG2U:W -<D9(5W ,6W =5(O<W ,FG()5,*1+<W =(C(W -<C9H6(CW 5(
C,*6(9(*1U:W =H,FG<W BH,W ,:W *(F<W +,W (=C,*0(CW BH,W ,K0FG,W ,KG,9=<C(:,1+(+W +,),DS(
1:(+91G0CF,W 5(W C,*6(9(*1U:W F1:W ,:GC(CW ,:W ,6W -<:+<W +,W ,56(
W ,FG<FW ,-,*G<FW *(),W F,T(5(CW BH,W ,5W (CGR*H5<W W +,W 6(W "' W +0 F=<:,W BH,W
F190F9<W ,6W (DGR*H5<W W
W
+,W 5(W ",NW
+,W W +,W <*GI)C,W +,W $C<*,+090,:G<
+90:0FGD(G0J<W <9V:W +,W 5(FW +90:1FGC(*0<:,FW $V)60*(FW =E,JQW BH,W 5<FW =6(O<FW F,W
*<9=HG(DP:W (W =(CG0CW +,5W +R(W F1.H0,:G,W (W (BH,6W ,:W BH,W G,:.(W 6I.(EW 5(W :<G1-0*(*1U:W <W
=H)60*(*1U:W +,8W (*G<W+,W BI,W F,W GD(G,W <W +,F+,W ,6W F0.H0,:G,W (W (BH,6W ,:W BH,W F,W =C<+HO*(W 5(W
,FG19(*0U:W <W +,F,FG 09(*1U:W =<CW F06,:*1<W (+90:0FGC(G0J<W T(+0,:+<W BH,W F0W ,:W ,5W 9,FW +,W
L uubq #||| ;_F Fq; y q>7 k‚7 >u cMc‚ 'NB%+3/)uZ%Wb%57!‚
L vvbr $ ||| ;_GGr <yr?8k‚ 8 ?v cMd‚ (NB%+3/)!! ‚ d%"vZ&‚ W8‚
L uueq #|| | ;_F Fq ;yq>7k‚ 7?u f M f‚ 'NB%+3/)!! ‚ e%!uZ%‚ WB7@y77‚
Luubq#|||>_ZqHT_CFuk7Zqb7lFZ>P7Fq>w‚ 1_YFFsuk7[qg7kFZ @O7h_ku7Xwk7[sb7kF[>P7O[J`mY7>P_[€
G?`Z ?`Z{GZP`r ?`Z{G\ P`r--)) LvY X‚
Lvubq $}||‚ ;_F Fq;yq>7n‚ 7>v cLi‚ 'NB%+3/)g%!v[&‚ W7‚
4KQ]9‚ ‚ DI‚ ‚
.a^tIUa‚ DI‚ 6o:^tj9oI^AQ:‚ ‚ ,zI^‚ 0a=RIo^a‚ **2‚
~ AaZtIVaEIx p9Zte9kIZA S9It‚
!
K/=-5<5/=H>X =>X 4I,6/E+X . T+X /CI6K+:/=H/X +X +CJ/:X /=X CJ/X -><5/=Q+X /;X -V<?IH>X G/X
/=H/=./FSX CJ/X /:X ?:+Q>X /L?5F+X /:X W:H5<>X .U+X ./:X </G X
(/2W=X ;>GX .+H>GX CJ/X ->=GH+=X /=X /;X /L?/.5/=H/X /=X /:X -+G>X ./X /GH+X E/-:+<+-6V=X :+X
G>:6-6HJ.X CJ/X :/X .+X >E52/=X 0J/X ?E/G/=H+.+X /:X X ./X <+EQ>X ./X X ?>EX :>X :+X
+.<6=5GHE+-6V=X +JH>=V<6-+X .6G?>=T+X ./X ?:+Q>X 4+GH+X /:X .U+X X ./X +,E5;X ./X X ?+E+X
E/G>:K/FX G>,E/X /:;+X (6=X /<,+E2>X /;X E/-:+<+=H/X 1>E<J;VX E/-:+<+-6V=X +=H/X /:X)X /:X X
./X <+FR>X ./X X /GX ./-6EX +=H/GX ./:X HF+=G-JFG>X ./;X ?;+R>X ./X I=X </GX CI/X /GH+,;/-/X :+X
!)X /=X GJX +EHU-J:>X X ?+F+X CJ/X G/X E/GJ/:K+X MX =>H516CI/X J=+X G>:6-5HJ.X ./X ./E/-4>X ./X
+--/G>X +X :+X 6=1>E<+-6V=X ?W,;6-+X =X ->=G/-J/=-6+X =>X G/X 4+=X?E>.J-5.>X :>GX /0/-H>GX ./:X
G5:/=-6>X +.<6=5GHE+H5K>X MX ?>FX H+=H>X =>X -+,/X +.<5H5FX :+X E/-;+<+-5V=X CJ/X /GX
/LH/<?>FS=/+X
%>X >,GH+=H/X ./,/X E/->E.+FG/X CJ/X ;+X +.<5=6GHE+-5V=X 4+X ?J/GH>X +X .6G?>G5-6V=X ./;X
E/-;+<+=H/X :+X .>-J</=H+-6V=X CI/X 4+,T+X G>:5-6H+.>X ?>EX ;>X -I+;X GJGX ?F/H/=G5>=/GX 4+=X
CI/.+.>X ./, 6.+</=H/X G+H5G0/-4+GX
=X +H/=-5V=X +X :>GX +=H/-/./=H/GX MX 0J=.+</=H>GX JFU.6->GX ./G-E6H>GX ?E>-/./X
:+X E/-:+<+-5V=X ?E/G/=H+.+X 0E/=H/X +X :+X >=G/8/ET+X ./X /G+EE>:;>X (>GH/=6,:/X ./X +GH5::+!+X
$+=-4+X
/X +-J/E.>X ->=X /:X +EHU-J;>X X =W</E>X X ./X ;+X !/NX X ./X X ./X .6-5/<,E/X ./X
)E+=G@+E/=-5+X --/G>X +X ;+X =0>E<+-6V=X &W,;5-+X OX J/=X >,5/E=>X ;+X '/-;+<+-6V=X
?E/K5GH+X /=X /;X +EHT-I:>X X ./X :+X <5G<+X H6/=/X ;+X ->=G6./E+-6V=X ./X GJGH5HJH6K+X ./X :>GX
E/-JEG>GX +.<5=6GHE+H5K>GX ./X ->=0>E<6.+.X ->=X ;>X .6G?J/GH>X /=X /;X +EHT-I;>X X ./X :+X "/NX
X ./X X ./X >-HJ,E/X ./X &E>-/.6<6/=H>X .<6=5GHF+H6K>X ><W=X ./X :+GX
.<6=5GHF+-5>=/GX &W,:6-+G*X
>=HE+X ;+X ?E/G/=H/X E/G>:I-6V=X CI/X ?>=/X 05=X +X :+X KU+X +.<5=6GHE+H5K+X G/X ?>.FSX 6=H/E?>=/EX
E/-JEG>X ->=H/=-6>G>+.<5=6GHE+H5K>X /=X /:X ?;+R>X ./X .>GX </G/GX .7F/-H+</=H/X +=H/X :+X
(+:+X ./X :>X >=H/=-6>G>+.<6=6GHE+H6K>X ./X :+X I.6/=-6+X %+-5>=+;X ./X ->=0>E<6.+.X ->=X :>X
?E/K5GH>X /=X /;X +A+EH+.>X DJ6=H>X ./X ;+X 5GB>G5-6V=X +.6-6>=+:X -I+FH+X ./X ;+X #/PX X ./X
X ./X 9I;6>X '/3J:+.>E+X ./X ;+X JE6G.6--6V=X >=H/=-6>G>+.<5=6GHE+H5K+
X
? \\MY bbb 2K;;Y2_Y5.Th . 5\ N @ Nh A8$*'!h \HGM.h
?\] O Z cbbh 2K< <Z 3`Z6.Th /6\ P @ Ph A8$*'",\HGP/h h
? \\OY bbb 2K; ;Y3 ` Y5. Uh. 5\ N@Nh A8$*'!\HGQ.h
+f>BI0h h 9=h h
&LJ[=ELh 9=h -V1J[R0V=J7B1h eh %a=Jh (L4C=VJLh ##)h
d 7LJ[=FL:=^ W 0H[S0X=J7D 0=[h
gh
$% % % %
& & & &
& #& & $!& " !&
% % % #% !% % %
" %
&
%&