El ciudadano solicitó al Ayuntamiento de Alcorcón información sobre el coste de la gestión de residuos y el presupuesto de limpieza. El Ayuntamiento denegó la solicitud alegando que la información ya era pública. El Consejo de Transparencia Andaluza estima la reclamación al considerar que la administración no indicó dónde se encontraba la información.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
La administración no puede limitarse a afirmar que la información es pública sin indicar el lugar exacto o el enlace donde el ciudadano puede acceder a ella.
2
El derecho de acceso a la información pública implica la obligación de la administración de facilitar la localización de los datos solicitados.
3
Se considera insuficiente la respuesta que remite a la publicación general sin concretar la ubicación de los datos específicos requeridos.
Texto completo
" "
! "
" " "
' D9A,K K
' (K +,K 4(K -1=6(K
$'
!&'
#$!&"# ' EB7A(62,7A8K +,K (698@K !(548=*(K
!&' # $' 1*,7*1(K +,K (*A1C1+(+K EK @,.B=1+(+K 9(=(K =,(51H(*1I7K +,K
(*A2C1+(+,@K =,5(*187(+(@K *87K =BA(@K (K *()(448K
$ ' ' ' "# %&' %%&"'#$K
'
K %,.J7K @,K +,@9=,7+,K +,K 4(K +8*B6,7A(*1I7K <B,K 8)>(K ,7K ,5K ,D9,+1,7A,K ,7K -,*0(K K +,
-,)?,?8K +,K K ,4K ?,*4(6(7A,K @841*1AIK (5K EB7A(61,7A8K +,K B(+(5(3(=(K (5K (69(=8K +,
4(K ,FK K +,K K +,K +1*1,6)=,K+,K A=(7@:(=,7*1(K (**,@8K (K 5(K 17-8=6(*2I7K ;J)42*(K G
)B,7K /8)1,=78
,7K (+,4(7A,K 'K 4(K @1.B1,7A,K 27-8?6(*1I7
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
O
/ EE;C IJI %9, ,C% G C'" ?O" 'E < 0 <O1)
M.27#O O *-O O
:8D-5:O *-O !@$8D=#@-8(2$O LO H-8O :&3-@8:O O
K (:8D-6:+-F A#8D>#B-8(4 #-DO
O
NO
!
! !
! !
'8"21%250$D "21D , D 6$83:$89 D # # D 326D 3 59$D #$D , D #0(1(895 "(B1D "21"$51)# D $,D D #$
%$!5$52D #$D D 4:$D 5$0(9@ D $,D $;3$#($19$D $-D D #$D 0 5=2D #$D D D , D (5$""(B1
$1$5 ,D #$D &6'":,9:5 D 1 #$5A D <D $8 552,,2D :5 ,D #$D , D 218$*$5A D #$D &5 (":,9:5
$8" D <D $#(2D 9:5 .D #$D - D #0(1'895 "(B1D #$D - D 20:1(# #D :9B120 D #$D / 8D -,,$8
,$ 58D $,D 82,'"(9 19$D 37$8$19BD #$D ":$5#2D "21D ,2D #(83:$892D $1D $,D 59A":,2D
P
#$D ,
D :1 D 5$", 0 "'B1D 19$D $-D 218$*2D #$D 6 183 5$1"' D <D :$1D 2!'$612D $1
#$, 19$D D D , D 4:$D 8$D # D $195 # D $.D D #$D 0 5>2D #$D D "21D 1C0$52D #$
$;3$#'$19$D
-D D #$D 0 5>2D #$D D $,D D 5$0(9(BD , D 5$", 0 "(B1D D , D $"5$9 5A D $1$5 ,D #$-
<:19 0($192D #$D 0328D ,D 2!+$92D #$D 4:$D 326D $-D B5& 12D "203$9$19$D 3:#($5 1
35$8$19 58$D , 8D ,$& "'21$8D 4:$D 8$D "218(#$6 8$1D 23259:1 8
-D D #$D !6(,D #$D D 8$D 6$"(!$D "219$89 "(B1D ,D 5$4:$5'0($192D #$D ,$& "(21$8
$%$"9: #2D 4:$D (1"-:<$D :1D '1%270$D #$-D <:19 0'$192D #$D 0328D #$D D #$D 0 5>2D #$
D 4:$D 8$D 3721:1"' D $1D -28D 8'&:'$19$8D 9?60(128
-E E &'E ('$4'41E &'E E %1/E E /CE E E E E 24'5'/6#E #-E
:7/6#.+'/61E &'E #.215E +/56#/%+#E )'/'4#-E .'&+#/6'E -#E %7#-E 5'E 51-+%+6#E
+04.#%+A/E 2B$-+%#E 4'-#6+8#E #E -#E -')#-+&#&E &'E 7/#E #%6+8+&#&E &'E '9%745+1/'5E #E
%#$#--1E 7$+%#&#E '/E '-E 6?4.+/1E .7/+%+2#-E &'E #.215 E
"'/+'/&1E '/E %7'/6#E -#E 2'6+%+A/E 214E 2#46'E &'-E +/6'4'5#&1E '/E ('%*#E E &'E .#4;1E &'E
E %1/E !E /DE ! E '-E :7/6#.+'/61E &'E #.215E 4'.+6'E -#E %+6#&#E
51-+%+67&E #E -#E 1/5','4@#E &'E )4+%7-674#E '5%#E :E -+.'/6#%+A/E 214E '/6'/&'4E 37'E
5')B/E -1E &+527'561E '/E '-E #46@%7-1E *=E &'E -#E ':E E &'E E &'E /18+'.$4'E &'E
4?)+.'/E ,74@&+%1E &'E +/56#-#%+A/E #%%'51E :E ','4%+%+1E &'E #%6+8+&#&'5E '/E -#5E 5-#5E
#-'#4'5E '/E '-E .#4%1E &'E -#5E #%6+8+&#&'5E4'('4+E '/E '-E #46@%7-1E E &'E -#E ':E E
&'E E &'E ,7-+1E &'-E !7'-1E B56+%1E &'E -#5E 5-#5E #-'#4'5E -#E %1.2'6'/%+#E 2#4#E 4'51-8'4E
'56#E %7'56+A/E -#E 156'/6#E -#E 1/5','4@#E &'E )4+%7-674# E
!+.7-6>/'#.'/6'E #E '56#E 4'.+5+A/E '-E :7/6#.+'/61E &'E #.215E %1/6'56AE #E -#E
2'451/#E +/6'4'5#&#E %1/E 7/E '5%4+61E /16+(+%#&1E '-E .+5.1E &@#E E &'E .#4<1E &'E E %1/E
!E /CE ! E 5+'/&1E +.215+$-'E #&,7/6#4E .>5E +/(14.#%+A/E 214E /1E %1/56#4E
'/E -15E #4%*+815E &'E 74$#/+5.1E :E #%6+8+&#&'5E &1%7.'/6#%+A/E 4'-#6+8#E #E '56#E #%6+8+&#& E
P
/FF<DJKJP %:,,D%HD'"@P " 'F </=P 0) P F76< "
N.18#P P *-P P
;9E-4;P *-P !A$9E>#A-9(1$P MP I-9P ;&2-A9;P P
L (;9E-5;+-G B #9E?#C-9( 3#-EP
OP
*@ #" %@ @ !"@ ).6+@ !"@ @ 5@ @ *?@ @ 0"@ !@ ."0,2"01@ (@
52*1)&"*1+@ ,+.@ ,.1"@ !"@ (@ +*0"'".<@ !"@ $.& 2(12.@ 5@ "0 @ +*@ &*#+.)"@
."(1&3+@ @ (@ 0+(& &12!@ !"@ &*#+.) &=*@ ,>(& @ 5@ !"*2* &@ ,+.@ ,."02*10@ &*#. &+*"0@
"*@ 2*@ 2!.@ !"@ ((+0@ 5@ "*@ 2*@ 1&3&!!@ !"@ "4 2.0&+*"0@ 5@ .210@ @ ((+@ 8!"(@
2(@ 0"@ !'2*1@ +,&@ (@ &1!+@ &*#+.)"@ +* (25"@ "*1."@ +1.0@ 2"01&+*"0@ "*@ 2*1+@
(@ 52*1)&"*1+@ !"@ ),+0@ ."0," 1@ -2"@ (0@ 1&3&!!"0@ !"@ ."#"."* &@ 0"@
+*0&!".*@ $..&0@ !&." 1)"*1"@ ."( &+*!0@ +*@ "(@ !"01&*+@ +@ *12.("7@ !"@ (0@
#&* 0@ ,+.@ (+@ -2"@ "01:*@ "4"*10@ !"@ +1"*".@ (& "* &@ !"@ 1&3&!!"0 @
0;@ ,2"0@ (@ &**" "0.&!!@ !"@ +1"*".@ (& "* &@ !"@ 1&3&!!"0@ "*@ "01"@ 0"*1&!+@ "4&)"@
(@ 52*1)&"*1+@ !"@ ),+0@ !"@ !&0,+*".@ !+ 2)"*1 &=*@ ."(1&3@ @ "01@ 1&3&!!@ 5@
1"*&"*!+@ "*@ 2"*1@ (+0@ &1!+0@ *1" "!"*1"0@ ,." "@ (.@ (@ 3+(2*1!@ !"(@
52*1)&"*1+@ !"@ ,+*".@ @ !&0,+0& &=*@ !"@ 1". ".+0@ 1+!@ (@ &*#+.) &=*@ ,+0&("@ "*@
."( &=*@ @ (@,"1& &=*@ !"@ (@ ,".0+*@ &*1"."0! @
*@ #" %@ @ !"@ ).7+@ !"@ @ +*@ @ *?@ 9"*3;+@ @ !"@ @ 5@ @ *?@
@ "*3;+@ @ !"@ @ 0"@ ,."0"*1@ *1"@ "(@ 52*1)&"*1+@ !"@ ),+0@
."-2".&)&"*1+@ !"@ ("$ &+*"0@ 5@ !+ 2)"*1 &=*@ ,+.@ ,.1"@ !"(@ +*0"'+@ !"@
.*0,."* &@ 5@ 2"*@ +&"/+@ ,+.@ %".@ 1"*&!+@ "*1.!@ "*@ "(@ )&0)+@ ." () &=*@
&*1".,2"01@ ,+.@ @@ @ "*@ #" %@ D !"@ ).6+@ !"@ @ (@ ),.+@ !"@ (+@ !&0,2"01+@ "*@ "(@
.1; 2(+@ @ !"@ (@ "5@ @ !"@ @ !"@ !& &")."@ !"@ 1.*0,."* &@ "0+@ @ (@
&*#+.) &=*@ ,>(& @ 5@ 2"*@ $+&"/+@ @
+*0&!".*!+@ 1+!+@ (+@ "4,2"01+@ 0"@ ,.+ "!"@ @ !'2*1.@ (@ ,."0"*1"@ "0 .&1+@ +,&@ !"@
1+!@ (@ !+ 2)"*1 &=*@ ."(1&3@ (@ "4,"!&"*1"@ !"@ (@ 1&3&!!@ !"@ ."#"."* &@ -2"@
+*01@ "*@ (+0@ . %&3+0@ !"@ 2.*&0)+@ 5@ 1&3&!!"0@ !"(@ 52*1)&"*1+@ !"@ ),+0@
,.@ 02@ +*+ &)&"*1+@ &@ +*0&$2&"*1"0@ "#" 1+0@
$D "/-%/6,&# #D "/-D )/D #&:1<$:;/D $-D $*D 6;A"<*/D "D #$D * D D ?D $.D $+D 6;B"<)/D
#$*D $ *D $"6$;/D D #$D D #$D /";<!6$D 2/7D $*D 4<$D :$D 36<$! D $*D :; ;<;/D #$+
/.:$(/D #$D 6 .:2 8$-"& D @D <$-D /!&$6./D
D $*D 9$:'#$.;$D #$D $:; D <;/8&# #
#,&.&:;7 ;&= D -#$1$-#'$.;$D $:D "/,1$;$.;$D 1 6 D 6$:/+=$6D * :D 6$"* , "&/.$:D 5<$D $-D
1+&" "&C-D #$*D 7;B"<*/D D #$D + D D :$D 16$:$.;$-D %6$-;$D D + :D 6$:/*<"'/.$:D $>16$: :D
/ 17$:<-; :D 6$" B# :D $-D , ;$6' D #$D ""$:/D D + D '-%/6, "'C-
N
/EE;C IJIN %9, ,C%G C'" ?N " 'E </<N 2)E65< "
M.07#N N *-N N
:8D-3:N *-N !@$8D=#@-8(0$N LN H-8N :&1-@8:N N
K (:8D-4:+-F A#8D>#B-8( 2#-DN
0D
!
/F <(5:;!F !",F 25:!1F F !"F -F !)9219) (D/F !) (1/,F ;5:F !"F ,F
F ,9
1.;0)!!"9F ;:D/1.9F 3;"!"0F :5);)6F -F 1.3":"/ )F 37F -F 5"91-; (D/F !"F ,9
5" -. (1/"9F -F F ."!(/:"F ,F ","5 )D/F !"-F 157"931/!("/:"F 1/<"/(1F 1/F ,
!.)0)9:7 (D/F "/"5,F !",F 9:!1F /F !"9551-,1F !"F !( &F 37"<(9)D/F "=)9:"F 1/<"/ )1
<(%"/:"F 9;9 5(:1F 1/F ,9F 1.;/(!!"9F ;:D/1.9F !"F 9:;5)9F /:5 )F F )1*
=:5".!;5F 9:(--F / 'F "F -,,"9F ,"59F 9BF 1.1F 1/F ,9F (;!!"9F ;:D01.9
!"F ";:F >F "-(,,
F F "/F 9;F 7:C ;,1F
F 5"%;,F ",F !"5" &1F !"F :1!9F ,9F 3"591/9F F "!"5F F ,
(0#15. )D/F 3E,) F "0:"/!)!F 9"%E/F ",F 7:B ;,1F F !"F ,F .)9.F /15.F 1.1F
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
15F ,1F :0:1F -F ,">F !"#)/"F ",F 1+":1F !"F ;/F 91,) ):;!F !"F "91F F ,F )/#15. (D/F "0
5"- )D/F 1/F )0$15. )D/F 4;"F >F "=)9:"F 315F ;/:1F "9:@F "/F 319"9)D/F !"F ;/F15%/(9.1
(/ -;)!1F "/F 9;F @.):1F !"F 3-) )D0F ("/F 3154;"F A-F .(9.1F ,F 'F ",15!1F )"/
3174;"F ,F 'F 1:"/(!1F "/F "*"7 ) )1F !"F -9F #;/ )1/"9F >F 1.3":"/ )9F 4;"F :)"/"
"/ 1."0!!9
"%E/F 9"F "=35"9F "/F ",F 35"@.;,1F !"F ,F F ,F :8/935"/ )F ",F "91F F ,
(0#15. )D/F 3E,) F >F ,9F /15.9F !"F ;"/F %1("5/1F !""/F 9"8F ,19F "+"9F $;0!."/:,"9
!"F :1!F (D/F 31,B:( F D-1F ;0!1F ,F )D/F !"F ,19F 5"93109-"9F 3E,) 19F 9"F 91.":"
F "9 5;:(/)1F ;/!1F ,19F );!!/19F 3;"!"/F 1/1 "5F D.1F 9"F :1.0F ,9F !" (9)1/"9
4;"F -"9F $" :/F D.1F 9"F ./"+/F ,19F #1/!19F 3E,) 19F 1F *1F 4;AF 7):"5)19F :E0
/;"9:59F (/9:(:; (10"9F 31!5".19F &,5F !",F )/( )1F !"F ;/F 371 "91F "/F ",F 4;"F ,19F 31!"7"9
3E-) 19F 1.)"/?0F F 5"9310!"5F F ;/F 91 )"!!F 4;"F "9F 5B:( F "=)%"/:"F >F 4;"
!"./!F 37:) )3 )D0F !"F -19F 31!"8"9F 3E- ) 19
"F ;"7!1F 1/F ",F (:!1F 5:C ;,1F F !"F ,F F "F 1/ ,;)5F 4;"F ,F (/$17. )D/
91,) (:!F !""F 1/9(!"759"F ! ! 3;"9:1F 4;"F 155CF "/F 31!"8F !"
;/F 9;*":1F 1,(%!1F 315F ,F F -F 1/9"*"5CF !"F %7( ;,:;5F "9 F >F "!)1F :;5,
4;)"/F !(931/"F !"F "--F "0F ",F "+"8 ) (1F !"F -9F $;/ )1/"9F 4;"F :("0"F ,"%-."0:"
5" 1/1 )!9
t
@ ffVd mm m 1S: :d 1jd3-]t -3f W AWt C6"*& t VfOt L6-4j--
t
@ffXdmmm3SOd;IS7:f^-OdX.]:O3E-:d4gt (SN::df_-PdY-]:O4D-ZS_f.Mg]-PdX-]:P3E-CP>U`N-3ESPq
<3SO 4SOl<OESd 3SOl<O ESd$$ @fN Mt
B ffVd mmn 1S: :d1 j d3- ]t- 3h W A [t C6"*& t hOL[-
+r?FQ/t t 8=t t
%TRe=JTt 8=t ,a0Re\/a=R5F0t pt #k=Rt 'T2G=aRTt !!)t
o 5TRe=KT9=i b /ReV/c=R5H /=et
st
;HC$;'=X (;X (5X )=;'=X '(5X $GJ;H=X G(+V;X &=<GH$X (<X (5X (L>('/(<H(X '(X 6$X C(&7$:$&0U<X (5
MJ;H$:/(;H=X '(X $:>=GX -$X C(:/H/'=X 6$X G=6/&0HJ'X '(X /;)=C:$&0U;X $X 6$X =;G(2(DS$X '(
+C/&J5HJC$X (G&$X MX ('0=X $HJC$6X >=CX (GH0:$E5$X &=:>(H(;H(X >$C$X C(G=7K(CX G=%C(X (6
$&&(G=X 0;)=C:$<'=X $5X G=50&0H$;H(X (<X &J:>5/:/(;H=X '(X 7=X '/G>J(GH=X (;X (5X $FT&J5=X
'(X 5$X #X AJ(X '0G>=;(X AJ(X
=:=X G(X '(G>C(;'(X '(X 6=GX $;H(&('(;H(GX 5$X $':0<0GHC$&/U;X &=<&(C<0'$
&=;&C(H$:(;H(X 5$X /C(&&0U<X (;(E$6X '(X +C0&J6HJC$X $;$'(CS$X MX (G$EC=56=X !JE$5X '(X 5$
=<G(3(CT$X '(X +E0&J6HJD$X (G&$X MX ('0=X $HJC$6X -$X >J(GH=X $X '0G>=G 0&0U;X '(6
G=50&0H$<H(X 6$X /;)=C:$&0U;X C(AJ(C/'$X (<X (6X >5$P=X >C(K0GH=X >$E$X (67=X >=CX 5=X AJ(X $5X .$%(E
$&HJ$'=X '(X &=;*=C:0'$'X &=;X 6$X #X $:%$GX $':/;/GHC$&0=;(GX >C=&('(X (<
'(*0;/H0K$X '(G(GH/:$DX 5$X C(&9$:$&/U;X >5$<H($'$
;X $H(;&0U;X $X 5=GX $;H(&('(<H(GX MX )J;'$:(;H=GX 2JCS'/&=GX '(G&E/H=GX >C=&('(X
6$X E(&5$:$&0U;X >C(G(;H$'$X )C(;H(X $5X MJ;H$:/(;H=X '(X $:>=GX
(X $&J(C'=X &=;X (5X $CHT&J6=X
<W:(C=X
'(X 6$X (NX
'(X X '(X '0&/(:%C(X '(X
HC$;G?$E(<&0$X $&&(G=X $X 6$X 0;)=C:$&0U<X ?W%50&$X OX %J(;X ,=%0(C;=
6$X C(&6$:$&0U;X
>C(K/GH$X (;X (5X $CHS&J6=X X H0(;(X 5$X &=;G0'(C$&0U<X '(X GJGH0HJH/K$X '(X 5=GX E(&JEG=GX
$':0;/GHC$H/K=GX '(X &=;)=C:0'$'X &=<X 5=X '/G>J(GH=X (;X (5X $CIT&J7=X X '(X 5$X (NX
'(X X '(X =&HJ%C(X '(X D=&('0:/(;H=X ':0;0GHE$H/K=X =:W;X '(X 7$GX
':0;/GHE$&/=;(GX W%60&$G
=<HD$X 6$X >C(G(;H(X C(G=5J&0U;X AJ(X >=<(X )0;X $X 5$X KT$X $':0<0GHC$H0K$X G(X >='CRX
/<H(C>=;(CX C(&JDG=X &=;H(;&0=G=$':0;0GHC$H0K=X (;X (8X >8$P=X '(X '=GX :(G(GX
'/C(&H$:(;H(X $;H(X 5$X "$5$X '(X 6=X =<H(;&/=G=$':/;/GHE$H0K=X '(X 6$X J'0(;&/$X $&0=;$6X
'(X &=<)=C:0'$'X &=;X 5=X >C(K/GH=X (;X (5X $@$EH$'=X BJ/;H=X '(X 6$X /G?=G0&/U;X $'0&0=<$6X
&J$CH$X '(X 5$X (NX
'(X X '(X 4J60=X !(,J5$'=D$X '(X 5$X JC0G'1&&0U;X =<H(;&0=G=Q
$':0;/GHC$H0K$
s
GiiXf$nnn8VCCf8lf;4`4;hXGX&I?%),'!!hR%Y%!4#
G iiZf $nnn 9VCCf8lf<4as 4 <i [ H [s &J?%)0-'!! s iS%QZ%!4s
Gij \ f $ nnn 9VD Df 8lf=4as 5=i ] H Ys &J@%)0-'2iS%QX%!4s
GiiXf $nnn 8VC Cf8lf;4bs 4;i \G[s &K?%)0,'##"!hS%s X%!4#s
1qFLT6s s AEs s
+WUgEOWs AEs 3c7Ug^6cEU>L7s ps *mEUs .W:MEcUWs ((/s
o >WUg EPWBEkd 6Sg_6eEU>N 6 Egs
rs
$% % % %
& & & &
& #& & $!& " !&
% % % #% !% % %
" %
&
%&