El ciudadano solicitó al Ayuntamiento de Sant Joan de Les Comes información sobre la gestión de residuos y el servicio de recogida. Tras la denegación de la administración, el Consejo de Transparencia y Acceso a la Información de Cataluña estima la reclamación, obligando al ayuntamiento a entregar la información solicitada.

Puntos clave de la argumentación

1 El derecho de acceso a la información pública prevalece sobre la alegación de la administración de que la información se encuentra en proceso de elaboración.

2 La administración no ha justificado adecuadamente que la divulgación de la información pudiera comprometer la calidad de la misma o la toma de decisiones.

3 Se determina que la información solicitada es de naturaleza pública y no existen límites legales aplicables que justifiquen su denegación.

Texto completo

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email protected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ttao#}~}9^CCo9yo<6j„ 6 <v bIb„ &KA%*2.'tY%„ Tg%46!„ „ Iuucp $ }}} 9^D Dp :yp=7k„ 7=u dId„ &KA%*2.'!! „ d%"uY%„ U7 „ Ittco # } }}„ 9^CCq9yo=6l„ 6>t e Jb„ &LA%*2.'" " b%"tY%„ UA6>z66 Ittao#}~}<^ZoCQ^ACtl6Zob6 lCY<K6Co<t„ 0^WCCotj6Yof6lCY>K6a^nt6Vvl6Zob6lCZ<K6MZG_jX6<K^Z‚ D=_Y=_[|DYK_p=_Y|DYK_p,,'(IuWV„ Iutco $}}} 9^C Do9yo<6k„ 6<x dId„ &KA%*2.'!! „ uY%„ Tg%!6„ 3ƒHN\8„ „ BE„ „ -`]rER`„ BF„ 5m8\rh8mE]?N8„ „ +{F]„ /`;OEm\`„ ))1„ €@`]sES`BEwn8Yri8mE]@P8Er„ 5:$H -$8H %$"9 1H "F02H 8$H 0 1$, 1H .28H %21#28H 3G!.*"28H 2H ! ,2H 5:CH "6*9$7+28H "9G 1H 1:$896 8H *189+9:"*21$8H 32#6$028H ( !. 6H #$.H *1+"*2H #$H :1H 362"$82H $1H $-H 5:$H .28H 32#$6$8H 3G!-+"28H "20+$1@ 1H H 6$8321#$6H H :1 H 82"+$# #H 5:$H $8H "6D9*" H $<+&$19$H =H 5:$H #$0 1# H 3 79+"+3 "*F1H #$H -28H 32#$6$8H 3G!-+"28H -H "219$1+#2H #$H - H 82.+"+9:#H ;$68 H 82!6$H . H 2!9$1"*F1H #$H :1H "$79+%*" #2H #$H $89 6H - "266*$19$H #$H . 8H 2!. + & "+21$8H "21H - H "*$1# H :921F0*" H =H #$H -28H *1&6$828H 6$ -*@ #28 89$H 9*32H #$H 82-*"*9:#$8H 12H $197 1H #$1962H #$.H "21"$392H #$H *1%270 "+F1H 3G!.+" H 5:$H . H $89 !-$"$H $1H $.H "*9 #2H 69E":.2H 89$H 218$,2H = H ) H 9$1+#2H . H 23269:1+# #H #$H 3621:1"+ 68$H $1H 6$- "*F1H "21H 8:3:$8928 8*0+- 7$8H H 5:C-.28H $1H 5:$H . H 3$9+"+F1H $89BH #$89+1 # H H 5:$H . H #0+1*896 "+F1H G!.*" "21"$61*# H ..$;$H H " !2H :1 H "9: "*F1H 0 9$6+ -H %:9:6 H %260:/ # H $1H 9C60*128H #$H :1 2!.*& "*F1H 328*9*; H #$H ) "$6H $1H $89$H " 82H - H $0+8*F1H #$H :1H "$69+%*" #2H 8DH $1H 8:8 6$82.:"*21$8H H H #$H H #$H &2892H #$H H =H H H #$H H #$ 2"9:!6$H #$H H #$9$60+1 ! H 5:$H 3$9+"+21$8H #$H 9 -H 1 9:6 /$A H #*89 1H #$H 96 9 68$H #$ 82.+"*9:#$8H #$H ""$82H H - H *1%260 "+F1H $1H -28H 9C60+128H #$%+1+#28H 326H .28H 69D":-28H H H #$H . H 3623* H $H $89$H 02#2H 920 1#2H $1H "218+#$6 "+F1H $.H 2!,$92H #$H . H 82-+"*9:#H 36$8$19 # "218*89$19$H $1H - H $0+8+F1H #$H :1H "$69*%*" #2H 326H 3 69$H #$H . H #0+1+896 "+F1 :921F0+" H " !$H "21"-:+6H 5:$H - H 6$"- 0 "*F1H 3. 19$ # H #$!$H 8$7H #$8$89*0 # 1H 9$1"*F1H H .28H 19$"$#$19$8H =H %:1# 0$1928H ,:7E#+"28H #$8"6+928H 362"$#$H . H 6$". 0 "+F1H 36$8$19 # H %6$19$H H . H 218$,$6E H #$H "2120D H =H "+$1# H #$H 19 !6* H $H ":$7#2H "21H $.H 69D":.2H H 1G0$62H H #$H . H $>H H #$H H #$H #+"*$0!6$H #$H 97 184 6$1"+ H ""$82H H . H +1%260 "+F1H 4G!.*" H ?H !:$1H '2!+$712 H - H 6$". 0 "+F1H 36$;+89 H $1H $.H 69D":.2H H #$H . H 0*80 H 9+$1$H - H "218+#$6 "+F1H #$H 8:89+9:9+; H #$H -28H 6$":6828H #0+1 + 896 9*;28H #$H "21%270+# #H "21H .2H #+83:$892H $1H $/H 69D":.2H H #$H . H Bkh V c ppp 6SNc=GS;=h]1NcV1^=N6C1=c6kt (SM=6hCoC;1; /=cSJl6CSO=c]=cSKm6CSO=ct ""t %%* , #"t tBhMKt BkiWc ppp7SNd> HT;>i]1PdW2^>N7C2>d8kt (TM>7iCoC;2;/>eTJl8CSO?d_>dSKm7CTO>dt ""t %%*+#"t BhMKt BhhXc ppp 4T> =c4lc82`t 26kYBYt C; -&t hNt LZ2t .sADQ3t t <@t t $URf@IUt <@t 0a3Qf[3a@R9D3t rt !n@Rt 'U5E@aQUt )t p q:UPg@HU<@jb3Pf\3a@P:F3@ft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ccc)K22Y )`Y +&Tl &+] P:Ql ;/#]Fl O&l l #l "3fl l 03l l 03l 0 <, <4E)U3 l /3l ^V'GZO&V3G,<'l ',,2ZLl 'l C'l =H7LUE&,<jFl Q k )D<,'l gl )a2Fl 8M)<2VFKl $i9>I(l l 15l l NJ[5ANl 16l %W(I[R(W5J->(l hl b6Jl N*?5WINl !l de.NJ\5BN15_X(F[S(W5J.@(5[l