El solicitante pidió al Ayuntamiento de Alcorcón información sobre el coste de la gestión de residuos y la tasa de basuras. El Ayuntamiento denegó el acceso alegando que la información estaba en curso de elaboración. El Consejo de Transparencia Andaluza estima la reclamación y ordena el acceso a la información.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
La administración no ha acreditado que la información solicitada se encuentre en un proceso de elaboración que justifique la denegación.
2
El derecho de acceso a la información pública prevalece cuando no se demuestra la existencia de un borrador o proceso de publicación general activo.
3
La denegación basada en la elaboración de la información requiere una justificación concreta que no ha sido aportada por el Ayuntamiento.
Texto completo
!
!
! !!
' D9A, L
' (L +,L 3(L -1>5(L
#'
&'
"# &!"' !(6*85B62+(+L +,L %,>C1*18@L !(6*0B,3(L 86=B,6@,L
(@A134( (L!(7*0(L
&' "#' ,3,.(*1J7L +,L *859,A,6*2(@L 5B61*29(3,@L ,7L 5(A,>1(L
B>)(6I@A1*(L (L 4(L !(6*85B71+(+L 74(*,L (L 98>A(3L +,L A>(7@9(>,6*2(L EL (L @,+,L ,3,*A>J62*(L
#' ' ' !"$&' %&!'"$L #$ L
%' ' "$&' L +I(@L 0H)13,@L
%,.K6L @,L +,@9>,7+,L +,L 3(L +8*B5,6A(*1J6L <B,L 8)>(L ,6L ,4L ,D9,+1,6A,L ,6L -,*0(L L +,
,6,?8L +,L L ,3L >,*4(5(6A,L @831*1AJL (3L (59(>8L +,L 3(L ,FL L +,L L +,L +2*1,5)>,
+,L A>(6@:(>,6*2(L (**,@8L (L 3(L 16-8>5(*1J6L ;K)41*(L GL )B,6L /8)1,>68
,7L (+,4(6A,
'L (L 4(L !(6*85B62+(+L +,L %,>C1*28@L !(6*0B,3(L 86=B,6@,L 3(L @1.B2,6A,
27-8>5(*1J6
!( ( ( ( ( ( $( ( ( !( ( &!( ( ( $(
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
!( ( '( !( ( !( ( "( ( (
!( ( ( ( ( ( # ( !% ( !(
( ( ( ( ( !( ( ( ( '( (
J
,AA7> EFE !5( (>!C>%;J %A8,8J -&
I+.3 J J ')J J
64?)16J '*J< 3?9 <)4#. J HJ D*3J 6"/)<36JJ
E
G$64@)26')B= 4?: <)4$0 )?J
".,/$4$-") 3? ,5-)")/ +$3? $-? , 4$1) ? #$? $7/$#)$-4$3? 51! -<34)" 3? /.1? -.? &'51 1? $-?
35? /.14 +? #$? 41 -3/ 1$-") ? 3<? ".,.? 4 ,!);-? )'-.1 ? 05;? 85-4 ,)$-4.3?
, -".,5- #.3? ( -? /1.! #.? $-? 3$3)=-? /+$- 1) ? #$+$' 1? $3 3? ".,/$4$-") 3? $-? + ?
-".,5-)# #?
?
./) ? /.1? $34$? ,$#).? #$? + 3? 1$3.+5").-$3? #$? "$/4 ")=-? #$? #$+$' ")=-? #$?
".,/$4$-") 3? $-? , 4$1) ? #$? )-%.1, ")=-? 51! -<34)" ? /1$"$/4)6 ? 8? $-? , 4$1) ? #$?
)-3/$"")=-? 51! -<34)" ? $+ ")=-? #$? 85-4 ,)$-4.3? #$? +.3? 05$? ".-34 ? $-? + ?
-".,5-)# #? 05$? -.? ( -? /1.! #.? $-? /+$- 1).? + ? #$+$' ")=-? #$? ".,/$4$-") 3?
$-? , 4$1) ? #$? )-%.1, ")=-? 51! -<34)" ? /1$"$/4)6 ? 8? $-? , 4$1) ? #$? )-3/$"")=-?
51! -<34)" ? $+ ")=-? #$? 105)4$"4.3? %5-").- 1).3? #$? +.3? 05$? #)3/.-$? + ?
-".,5-)# #? -+ "$? +? /.14 +? #$? 1 -3/ 1$-") ? #$? + ? -".,5-)# #? -+ "$? ?
+ ? 3$#$? $+$"41=-)" ? #$? + ? -".,5-)# #?
-5 ? )? 64 -&? ? 1 4/6 45? ? 46? / 5&%=-? *? 4.)&%5-5 ? /2 4 -5=? ? 6 1.? .-? ).
&4/6 45.? -? )? 25;6).?
? +? ? 6-? 1 ),%=-? -5 ? )? .-4 '.?
1-4/1 -&? 9? 6 -? .% 1-.? -? *-5 ? ? ? )? 06 ? 4 ? ? -51? )? ?
,2:.? ? ? .-? ->, 1.? ? 8/ & -5 ?
*? ? ? ,1:.? ? ? )? ? 1 ,&5&=? )? 3 ),%=-? ? )? 1 51<? - 1)? ? )
-.,6-%? ? 17%&.4? -$6 )? .-06 -4 ? *? .( 5.? ? 06 ? /.1? *? =2#-.
.,/ 5 -5 ? /6& 2-? /1 4 -514 ? )4? * #%.- 4? 06 ? 4 ? .-4& 14 -? ./.156-4
*? ? ? 1%)? ? ? 4 ? 1 % -? )4? ) #%.- 4? !.1,6*4? /.1? )? -5&
.- 1-&? 06 ? %-)69 -? 6-? &-".1, ? )? 1 4% -5 ? ? )? -.,6-&? ? ?
,2:.? ? ? .-? *? 4% -5 ? .-5 -&.
? ? ? $3/$"4.? ? 35? 3.+)")45#? #$? "./) ? #$? +.3? "5$1#.3? /+$- 1).3? #$? + ? #$+$' ")=-? #$?
".,/$4$-") 3? $-? , 4$1) ? 51! -<34)" ? #)"(.3? "5$1#.3? #$!$-? 3.+)")4 2$? ? " # ?
$-4)# #? +." +? 8 ? 05$? $-? + ? "45 +)# #? $+? /5$34.? #$? 3$"1$4 1) ? #$? $34 ?
, -".,5-)# #? 3$? $-"5$-41 ? 6 " -4$?
$3/$"4.? +? /$13.- +? 05$? 1$ +)9 ? + 3? %5-").-$3? #$? 105)4$"4.? 3$? +$? )-%.1, ? 05$?
#)"( ? /+ 9 ? 3$? $-"5$-41 ? )-,$13 ? $-? $+? /1."$3.? #$? $34 !)+)9 ")=-? /5!+)" #.? $-? $+?
?
? #$? ? #$? #)")$,!1$? #$?
? 34 ? -".,5-)# #? 1$ +)9 ? +.3? )-%.1,$3? *51<#)".3? 8? 4;"-)".3? $-? $+?
:,!)4.? 51! -<34)".? /1$"$/4)6.3? 3$'>-? + ? -.1, 4)6 ? 51! -<34)" ? 05$? +$? 1$35+4$? #$?
Q
1HH=E LML &;- -E&JE($BQ $(H>1>Q 2+!Q H8Q ?$
"P039%Q Q ,.Q Q
<:F.6<Q ,/Q #C%9F@%C.:)3%QOQ K/:Q <'4.C9<Q Q
L
N*<:G.7<,.ID%:FA%C.:*5%.FQ
-. ". #. % #. %#. #. & $#. %"+#$#. #.
"$%"#. '. $"$#. . #%. $". ". . '%$$. #. %#$"#.
"#. "$. . #%. $.
. . . . #. $"-. . . %.
$$ #%!%##$"#.
*S '98+9@7/)%)S '98S 49S )/E<G*EF9S *8S *5S %@FO'G49S (S )*S 4%S "S KS *8S *5S %@FO'G49S
)*4S !*%4S *'@*F9S S )*S S )*S 9'FG&@*S :9AS *4S >G*S E*S %;@G*&%S *6S EF%FGF9S )*5
98E*19S )*S #@%8E:%B*8'/%S LS G*8S 9&0*@89S
S *4S @*E0)*8F*S )*S *EF%S GF9@/)%)
)7/80E FA%F/I%S 8)*<*8)/*8F*S *ES '97<*F*8F*S <%B%S B*E94I*AS 4%ES @*'5%7%'/98*ES ?H*S *8
%<50'%'/Q8S )*4S %AFP'G49S S )*S 5%S "S E*S <@*E*8F*8S +A*8F*S %S 4%ES @*E94G'098*ES *J<B*E%E
9 <A*EG8F%ES A*'%P)%ES *8S 7%F*A/%S )*S %''*E9S %S 5%S 08+9@7%'/Q8
8S I/@FG)S )*5S %=%D%)9S S )*S 4%S )/E=9E/'0Q8S %)0'/98%5S 'H%AF%S )*S 4%S #
S 6%E
'97G8/)%)*ES %GFQ897%ES <H*)*8S %F@/&G0BS 5%S '97<*F*8'/%S <%@%S 4%S @*E94G'/Q8S )*S 4%E
@*'5%7%'/98*ES %5S #S 7*)/%8F*S 4%S '*5*&@%'/Q8S )*4S '9A@*E<98)/*8F*S '98I*809S '98S 5%
)7/80E F@%'/Q8S *8*@%4S )*4S EF%)9S 8S )*E%@@9459S )*S )/'-%S <B*I/E/Q8S *J/EF*S '98I*8/9
I0,*8F*S EGE'@/F9S '98S 4%ES '97G8/)%)*ES %GFQ897%ES )*S EFGC/%ES %8F%&@ /%S %S !/92%
JF@*7%)H@%S %EF/54%%S %8'.%S *S 554*ES %4*%@ES %EPS'979S '98S 4%ES 0H)%)*ES HFQ897%E
)*S *GF%S KS *5044%
%S $S *8S EGS %@FP'H49S
S @*,G5%S *4S )*@*'.9S )*S F9)%ES 4%ES <*@E98%ES %S %''*)*@S %S 4%
08+9@7%'/Q8S <R&4/'%S *8F*8)/)%S E*,R8S *4S %AFP'H49S S )*S 4%S 70E7%S 89@7%S '979S (#
$#. . %$#. %!%". !%. #. #%. "$. . # "$. !%. ".
". . %. . #. #%$#. %#. . . *$. . -. . #$. $,%. '. !%
'. #. "#. . !%"#. . . ". . #%#. %#)
9@S 49S F%8F9S 5%S 4*KS )*+08*S *4S 9&3*F9S )*S G8%S E94/'0FH)S )*S %''*E9S %S 4%S 08+9@7%'/Q8S *8
@*5%'/Q8S '98S /8+9@7%'/Q8S ?H*S K%S *J/EF*S <9AS 'G%8F9S *EFMS *8S <9E*E/Q8S )*S G8S 9@,%80E79
08'5H/)9S *8S EGS M7&/F9S )*S %<5/'%'0Q8S &0*8S <9@?G*S N5S 70E79S 4%S .%S *6%&9@%)9S &/*8
Dnn\i
xyx 4Y> >i
4ti6/d~
/ 6n ]D]~ F<#+'!nT~ O]-/~
Dnn\i x yx~ 4Y?>j4tj6/e~ 0 7n ^E^~ G<#+'!^nT~ P<17u//~
Dno_jxxx8YUj?LZ<?oe0Ui_0e?U7F0 ?k8o~ )ZR??jpf1Tj_1e?V7F1`Zh o0Qqe2Uj_/e?U8F/HUBZfS2;FYU|
>6YT6YTw>TFYi6YTw >TFYi%%!!DnRQ~
Dnn\i xyx 4Y> >i4ti6/d~ /6s]D]~ F<#+'!~ nT~ Oa/~
,}CIW3~ ~ =@~ ~
&[Xl@M[~ =A~ .g3Wlb3g@X9I3~ {~ $vAX~ ([5J@gW[~ ""*~
x
z :[Xm@N[=@rh3Vlc3g@X:K3 @l~
4365;"I .I &I 3:"2)!3I "2I ","7 * *3I !"I .9I #;2 *32"9I >I 314":"2 *9I 5;"I :)"2"I
"2 31"2!!9I
"%H2I 9"I "=47"9I "2I ".I 47"A1;/3I !"I .I I .I :82947"2 *I ".I "93I I .I
)2$371 *G2I 4H.* I >I .9I 23719I !"I ;"2I %3*"723I !""2I 9"7I /39I "-"9I $;2!1"2:."9I
!"I :3!I )G2I 43.C:) I G.3I ;2!3I .I )G2I !"I /39I 6"94329/"9I 4H/* 39I 9"I 931":"I
I "9 7;:*2*3I ;2!3I .39I *;!!239I 4;"!"2I 323 "7I G13I 9"I :312I .9I !" )9*32"9I
5;"I /"9I #" :2I G13I 9"I 12"-2I .39I #32!39I 4H.) 39I 3I -3I 5;BI 7):"6*39I :H2I
2;"9:79I )29:*:; )32"9I 43!7"139I '.7I !".I )2* )3I !"I ;2I 473 "93I "2I "/I 5;"I .39I 43!"8"9I
4H/* 39I 31*"2?2I I 7"9432!"7I I ;2I 93 *"!!I 5;"I "9I 7D:) I "=*%"2:"I >I 5;"I
!"12!I 47:* *4 )G2I !"I /39I 43!"8"9I 4H/* 39I
"I ;"6!3I 32I "/I ):!3I 7:E ;/3I I !"I .I I "I 32 /;*7I 5;"I .I )2$371 )G2I
93.* ):!I !""I 329*!"779"I 4;"9:3I 5;"I 377EI "2I 43!"8I !"I
;2I 9;-":3I 3/*%!3I 437I .I I .I 2 31;2*!!I !"I "7<* *39I 2 (;"/I
325;"29"I 5;*"2I !)9432"I !"I "/.I "2I ".I "-"7 * )3I !"I .9I $;2 *32"9I 5;"I :)"2"I
."%/1"2:"I 7" 323 )!9I
2I "/I 93I !"I "9:I 7" /1 *G2I >I 313I 9"I !"947"2!"I !"I .39I 2:" "!"2:"9I >I /3
"=47"9!3I 2:"8*371"2:"I /I *2#381 )G2I 93/* *:!I :)"2"I .I 32!) *G2I !"I )2$371 )G2
4H/* I 437I /3I 5;"I !""7CI 9"8I 4"71): *!3I ".I "93I I .I :3:/*!!I !"I 5;"..I /
7" /12:"I *2I "16%3I .I !1)2*9:7 *G2I 32 "72)!I &I 32 "! *!3I "/I "93I 93/3I
;2I 46:"I !"I "9I )2#371 *G2I 2I 32 7":3I 9"I 'I 473437 )32!3I .I 6" /12:"I "/
"2. "I I .I 9"!"I "/" :7G2* I !"I /I 2 31;2*!!I I :7<B9I !".I ;.I 4;"!"I "!"79"
.I 437:.I !"I :72947"2 *I !"I "9:I "2:)!!I :1)B2I 7"5;"7*!3I 437I ".I93.) ):2:"
%& & & &
9*1*913I 9"I 'I !!3I 7"94;"9:I :1*B2I I .I 93.) *:;!I !"I *2$371 *G2I 7".:*<I I /
4/@I !"I 75;*:" :3I !"I .I 2 31;2)!!
3I 39:2:"I "2I .3I 7".:*<3I .I 439*/"I "-"8 I !"I 314":"2 *9I ;82C9:) 9
1;2* )4."9I 436I 47:"I !"I .I 2 31;2*!!I !"I "7<* )39I 2 &;".I 325;"29"I "9:"
329",3I "9:)1I 5;"I 23I 9"I &I !!3I 9:*9$ *G2I I 0I 93.) *:;!I !"/I 7" .12:"I :3!I <"@
5;"I .I "2:*!!I 32 "72*!I *2!* I 5;"I !) &I )2$371 *G2I !""I 9"6I 93/+ *:!I I !I ;2
!"I .9I "2:*!!"9I /3 /"9I 5;"I #3612I 47:"I !"I /I 2 31;2)!!I 47I 5;"
473437 *32"2I.39I ;"7!39I 4."26*39I 7"94" :*<39
*2I "16%3I "I 9"F/7I 5;"I !"I ","7 ):79"I "9:9I 314":"2 *9I /39I ;"7!39
377"9432!)"2:"9I !""7C2I $*%;77I "2I 43!"7I !"I /I "2:*!!I 32 "72*!I 5;*"2I "2I 9;
32!* *G2I !"I 9;-":3I 3/)%!3I 437I /I I >I 438I !*9432"7I !"I ;2I *2#381 *G2
329*!"7!I 313I 4H/* I 5;"I &I 9*!3I ".38!I 3I !5;)7)!I "2I "/I "-"7 ) *3I !"I 9;9
#;2 *32"9I :*"2"I "/I !""7I !"I 473437 *3270
& & &$& "& & &
# !&
M ?(56:M '(M 26M (B7@(>?6M '$'6M 9@(M 3$M '6&@4(5?$&-K5M >62-&-?$'$M 56M 7:676:&-65$'$M ?-(5(M
2$M &65'-&/K5M '(M .5)6:4$&.K5M 7L% 2-&$M CM 9@(M 3$M $5&64@5.'$'M '(M !(;A.&/6>M $5&,@(2$M
659@(5>(M 56M ,$M 0@>?-)-&$'6M 2$M $72.&$&-K5M '(M $2*@56M '(M 26>M 3J4.?(>M 7:(A->?6>M (5M 26>M
$;?I&@36>M
CM
'(M 2$M "M 5.M 2$M &65&@;:(5&-$M '(M @5$M &$@>$M '(M -5$'4.>-K5M '(2M
$;?I&@36M
(>?(M 65>(16M '(%(M 7;6&('(:M $M (>?.4$:M 7$:&/$34(5?(M 2$M :(&2$4$&-K5M
7:(>(5?$'$ M
5M $?(5&-K5M $M 36>M $5?(&('(5?(>M CM )@5'$4(5?6>M 0@<I'-&6>M '(>&:.?6>M 7:6&('(M
2$M <(&2$4$&-K5M 7:(>(5?$'$M ):(5?(M $M 2$M
$5&64@5-'$'M '(M !(<A.&.6>M $5&,@(2$M 659@(5>( M
$M 2$M $5&64@5.'$'M '(M !(:A-&-6>M $5&,@(2$M 659@(5>(M $M 9@(M (5M
(2M 72$G6M 4HB-46M '(M A(/5?(M 'I$>M ,H%-2(>M )$&-2-?(M $2M :(&3$4$5?(M 2$M >/*@-(5?(M /5)6:4$&/K5M
6&@4(5?$&-K5M '65'(M &65>?(M (5M >@M &$>6M 2$M $?:-%@&/K5M '(M &647(?(5&-$>M
@;%$5I>?-&$>M 4@5-&.7$2(>M 76:M 7$:?(M '(M 3$M $5&64@5/'$'M '(M !(:A-&-6>M $5&,@(2$M
659@(5>( M
$M 2$M $5&64@5/'$'M '(M !(:A.&.6>M $5&,@(2$M 659@(5>(M 9@(M (5M (2M
4->46M 72$G6M 4HB.46M '(M A(-5?(M 'I$>M ,H%-2(>M ;(4-?$M $M (>?(M 65>(16M '(M #:$5>7$:(5&.$M CM
@(5M 6%.(:56M&67-$M '(M 3$M -5)6:4$&-K5M (5A/$'$M $2M :(&2$4$5?( M
(M $&@(:'6M &65M (2M $:?I&@26M M 5L4(:6M M '(M 3$M (DM M '(M M '(M '-&.(4%:(M '(M
?;$5>8$:(5&-$M $&&(>6M $M 2$M -5)6:4$&-K5M 8L%3-&$M EM %@(5M +6%-(:56
2$M =(&3$4$&-K5M
7:(A->?$M (5M (2M $:?I&@26M M '(M 2$M 4.>4$M ?-(5(M 3$M &65>-'(:$&-K5M '(M >@>?-?@?-A$M '(M 36>M
:(&@:>6>M $'4-5->?:$?/A6>M '(M &65)6;4-'$'M &65M 26M '->7@(>?6M (5M (2M $:?I&@26M M '(M 2$M
(FM M '(M M '(M 6&?@%:(M '(M :6&('-4-(5?6M '4-5->?:$?-A6M 64L5M '(M 3$>M
'4-5->?;$&.65(>M L%2-&$>
65?:$M 3$M 7:(>(5?(M :(>62@&-K5M 9@(M 765(M )-5M $M 2$M AI$M $'4 -5/>?:$?/A$M >(M 76':HM
/5?(:765(:M :(&@:>6M &65?(5&/6>6$'4-5->?:$?-A6M (5M (3M 73$G6M '(M '6>M 4(>(>M
'.:(&?$4(5?(M $5?(M 3$M !$2$M '(M 26M 65?(5&.6>6$'4 -5->?:$?/A6M '(M 3$M @'/(5&/$M $&-65$3M
B __P[
fgfk 4N= =[
4b[60Xk
06_ Q B Qk #D:"&-*$k _J"k R"0k
k
B __S[ fffk 4N= >[4b[60Xk 1 6_ TBTk #D:"&-*$k _J"k S"0k
B `_S[ !fffk 4N=>[4c\71Xk 1 7` TBTk #D:"&-*$k `J"k U"2k k
B__S[ fff4N==[4d[60Xk 06_UCTk #D:"&-*$k_K"kS"0k
B__P[ ff f4N= >[4d[60Xk 07_ RBTk #D;"'-*$_K"k P"0k k
.jAEL3k k <?k k
)OM]?HOk <@k /Y3L]V3Y?M8E3k ik (e@Mk +O5F?YLOk %%,k
f
h9OM^?IO<?aZ3M]W3Y?M9G3?]k
> +*!+0)$> +*> '+> ,0 6%23+> *> '> -13+> /5%*3+> > (> %2.+2$$=*> $%+*'>
403> > '> 7> > > > > &4'$+> "5(+1> > '> 40$2%$=*> +*3 *%+2+9
)$*%2303%6
>
> > > >
+> +2;> 4$2> +1<#4 8> :'60 8>
&&"% (( (! %'%$)
& "#) & ) " )
$% % % %
% % % #% !% % %
" %