El interesado solicitó al Ayuntamiento de Alcoroccos información sobre el coste de la gestión de residuos y el presupuesto de la empresa contratista. El Ayuntamiento denegó el acceso alegando que la información estaba en proceso de elaboración. El Consejo de Transparencia de Castilla-La Mancha estima la reclamación y ordena entregar la información.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
La administración no puede denegar el acceso a la información basándose en que se encuentra en proceso de elaboración si no acredita que la publicación la haría incompatible con la finalidad de la información.
2
El presupuesto de un contrato administrativo es información pública que no puede ser restringida basándose en la confidencialidad de la toma de decisiones cuando ya existe un contrato formalizado.
3
La denegación basada en la elaboración de la información requiere una justificación concreta de los perjuicios que causaría su divulgación, lo cual no ocurrió en este caso.
Texto completo
!
!
! !!
% F=D. O
% *O -.O 5*O /3@9*O
"%
$%
!"$ !% GE:D*94.:D<O -.O $E.@D<56*:<O 3E-*-O %.*7O *CD365**O
!*:,2*O
$% !"% <,E9.:D*,4M:O .:O @.5*,3M:O *O ,<D3J*,4<:.CO *O 5*O '.C<@.@K*O
.:.A*5O -.O 6*O &.0EA3-*-O &<,3*6O -.5O E.A=<O -.O $<53,L*O <,*6O
"% % % !#$% &&(")#%O
&.0N;O C.O -.C=A.:-.O -.O 6*O -<,E9.:D*,3M;O ?E.O <+B*O .:O .5O .F=.-3.:D.O .:O /.,2*O O -.
.:.A<O -.O O .8O @.,6*9*:D.O C<53,4DMO *6O GE:D*93.:D<O -.O $E.@D<76*:<O *5O *9=*B<O -.O 5*
.HO O -.O O -.O -4,[email protected] -.O D@*:C>*@.;,3* O *,,.C<O *O 6*O 3:/<@9*,4M:O >N+53,*O I
+E.:O 1<+3.B:<
.:O *-.5*;D.O )O 6*O C40E3.:D.O 3:/<@9*,3M:
"$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ "
$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ !#$ $$
$ $ $ $ $ $ "$ $ $ $ $ $ $
$ $ $ $ $ #$ $ $ $ $ $ $
J
,AA7> EFE !5( (>!C>%;J %A8,8J -&
I+.3 J J ')J J
64?)16J '*J< 3?9 <)4#. J HJ D*3J 6"/)<36JJ
E
G$64@)26')B= 4?: <)4$0 )?J
;#3:C#G ,3',<,';#1G '(1G :7#%#0#'47G 6;(G 9;9&7,%(G 6;(G '(%(G #%43#7G (1G #>;3:#2,(3:4
'(G ;(8411#34G #G 1#G !(947(7C#G (3(7#1G '(G 1#G (*;7,'#'G 4&,#1G '(G 1#9G '.(7(3&,#9G '(G
&4:,?#&,E3G '(:(&:#'#9G 7(95(&:4G #G 149G :7#%#0#'47(9G '(1G ;(754G '(G 41,&D#G 4G '(G
;(7:411#34G '(7,<#'#G '(G 1#G 47'(3G '(G 9(7<,&,4G '(G 1#G 395(&&,E3G 74<,3&,#1G '(G !7#%#04G
'(G ,;'#'G (#1G
;#3:C#G *14%#1G '(G 1#G 5#7:(G '(1G :7#%#0#'47G '(%C#G #547:#7G #G 1#G (*;7,'#'G 4&,#1G 6;(
#+47#G '(%(7AG #%43#7G (1G #>;3:#2,(3:4G
;#3:C#G *14%#1G >G 3F2(74G '(G :7#%#0#'47(9G 0;%,1#'49G $&:#'49
(&7(:4G 4G (941;&,E3G '(G #1'C#G 47'(3#3'4G ()(&:;#7G (1G %,4G '(G 7B*,2(3G '(
#547:#&,43(9G #G ),3G '(G 34G ()(&:;#7G 1#9G &477(9543',(3:(9G&4:,?#&,43(9G
(95439#%1(9G ',&:#7G >G (0(&;:#7G ',&+#G #&:;#&,E3G #'2,3,9:7#:,<#G %#04G &;>#
7(95439#%,1,'#'G 9(G :7#2,:(3G 149G 574&(',2,(3:49G
;#3:C#G *14%#1G '(7,<#'#G '(1G 7(*4G '(1G G '(7,<#'#G '(G 1#G 47'(3G '(G 9(7<,&,4G '(
1#G 395(&&,E3G 74<,3&,#1G '(G "7#%#04G '(G ,;'#'G (#1G
3)472(G '(G 3:(7<(3&,E3G 2;3,&,5#1G 9,G 14G +;%,(7(
3)472(G '(G 1#G !B&3,&4G ;3,&,5#1G &425(:(3:(G 9,G 14G +;%,(7(
(G ,3)472(G '(G 547G 6;BG 34G 9(G ,3)472EG #G 149G :7#%#0#'47(9G '(1G %,4G '(G &4:,@#&,E3
574';&,'49G (3G 9;9G 3E2,3#9G
(G ,3)472(G '(1G ,25#&:4G '(7,<#'4G >#G 6;(G #1G 34G 574&('(7G #G 1#G 4547:;3#G &4:,@#&,E3
'(G 1#9G *7#:/-&#&,43(9G (=:7#47',3#7,#9G 1#9G %#9(9G '(G &4:,@#&,E3G (3G 149G 5(7,4'49G '(G
%#0#G >G 0;%,1#&,E3G '(G 149G:7#%#0#'47(9G +#3G 54','4G <(79(G #)(&:#'49G
$, #&+, , , , , , ), ', , #$!+
%!, ', !&!##, &#, , '&%$, , &!$, , , , !,
, $, , *, , , "!, #, , $#%+, , #, #&%#, $(!#,
, #$&, , #, !#$
%& & & &
(G #&;(7'4G &43G 4G #3:(7,47G 1(G '4>G :7#91#'4G 1#G 9,*;,(3:(G '4&;2(3:#&,E3G
(&7(:4G '(G 1'C#G 3F2(74G G #574%#3'4G >G 47'(3#3'4G (1G 5#*4G '(G 1#9
&;#3:C#9G 7(9;1:#3:(9G '(G 1#G #51,&#&,E3G '(G 1#G 7(*;1#7,@#&,E3G '(G &4:,@#&,43(9G 47'(3#'#9G
(3G (1G 7(6;(7,2,(3:4G 1G (&7(:4G &43:,(3(G 1#9G &;#3:C#9G 2(39;#1(9G #G #%43#7G
G &42;3,&#'#9G >G #574%#'#9G 547G 1#G !(947(7D#G (3(7#1G '(G 1#G (*;7,'#'G 4&,#1G '(
#&;(7'4G &43G 149G :,549G '(G &4:,?#&,E3G <,*(3:(9G
& & & $& "& & &
# !&
:(9/;6F 9*4/;/)6F %3F #<'/5:7*(;69F )*F $9%'%26F *5F *3F 8<*F :*F 3*F )%F ;9%:3%)6F )*F 3%:
4*)/)%:F %)67;%)%:F ?F 8<*F (65;/*5*F ;6)%F 3%F /5+694%(/D5F 8<*F 2<:;/+/(%F :<F
(<473/4/*5;6 F
<:;0,/(%5;*F )*F 7%-6
B3(<36F /5)/=/)<%/@%)6F *3*F 3%:F '%:*:F )*F (6;/@%(/D5F 9*-<3%9/@%)%:F %3F /5;*9*:%)6
5F (<%5;6F %F %F /5+694%(/D5F :63/(/;%)%F *5F 9*3%(/D5F (65F 3%F /)*5;1(%(/D5F )*F 36:F
7%9;/(/7%5;*:F *5F 3%F *3%'69%(/D5F )*F 36:F *>7*)/*5;*:F 3*F (64<5/(6F 8<*F :<F /)*5;/)%)F :*F
7<*)*F *>;9%*9F )*F 36:F 7967/6:F )6(<4*5;6:F 8<*F +694%5F 7%9;*F )*F 36:F *>7*)/*5;*:F
(<%5)6F 9*8</*9%5F +/94% F
:/4/:46F )*F %(<*9)6F (65F 3%:F 5694%:F =/-*5;*:F *5F 4%;*9/%F )*F #*-<9/)%)F #6(/%3F ?F
;*5/*5)6F *5F (<*5;%F 8<*F :*F .%5F %'65%)6F )/+*9*5(/%:F )*F (6;/@%(/D5F 36:F &(;%)6:F
76)9B5F :63/(/;%9F %3F (/;%)6F 69-%5/:46F 3%:F 4*)/)%:F 6769;<5%:F 8<*F &(;*5F %F 796(*:6:F
?%F 9*(656(/)6:F (65F %5;*9/69/)%)F %F 3%F 9*-<3%9/@%(/D5F )*F 3%:F 4/:4%:F
(; 30$38/"H 30H ,H )0$38/ )F0H 8" ))!H 438H ";<)/8H 6="H 03H ;"H & CH 4=";<3H H ;=
!(;43;) )F0H -H )0$38/ )F1H 8"6="8(!H "0H .3;H 49<!3;H H H H H ?H H !"H ;=H ;3.( )<=!H !"
";3H ".H ;3.( )<0<"H 4:";"0<FH !"H =":!3H 30H -3H !(;4=";<3H "0H ".H 8<C =.3H H !"H .
H =2H 8" ./ )F2H 2<"H "-H 30;"*3H !"H 80;58"2 (H ?H ="0H 3(":03H "0
!".0<"H H H .H 7="H ;"H !H "0<9!H "-H H !"H /8@3H !"H H 30H 2G/"93H !"
">4"!("0<"H
-H H !"H /8A3H !"H H ".H H 8"/)<)FH -H 9" -/ )F0H H .H " 8"<8DH "0"8.H !"-
?=0</)"0<3H !"H ="8<3.-03H -H 3+"<3H !"H 6="H 439H ".H F8%23H 3/4"<"0<"H 5=!("90
48";"2<8;"H .;H -"% (30";H 6="H ;"H 30;(!"9;"0H 3438<=0;
-H H !"H /?3H !"H H ;"H 8" )"H 32<";< )F0H .H 9"6="8)/ )"0<3H !"H -"% )30";
"#" <=!3H 6="H (0 .=?"H =0H ";3.= )F0H !"H . .!DH !"H H !"H 8(-H !"H H 6="
!";4=B;H !"H .=!)8H H .H !) <!H 32H #" 'H H !"H "0"83H !"H H E!"H-3H ;(%=("2<"
%& & & &
F F F "*(/'/)6F *:(9/;6F *5<5(/%F 769F +%3;%F )*F (6;/@%(/D5F 5E4*96F )*F 9*-/:;96F A
"F )*F F )*F %'9/3F )*F F 6(F 5E4*96F F 769F %(<*9)6F )*F 3%F <5;%F )*F
6'/*956F 6(%3F )*F F :*F .%5F /5/(/%)6F )/3/-*5(/%:F !9*=/%:5+694%;/=%:F
7%9%F *3F *:(3%9*(/4/*5;6F )*F 36:F .*(.6:F )*5<5(/%)6:F 6( F 5E4*96F F
*5(65;9B5)6:*F C:;%:F *5F 796(*:6F
& & &$& "& & &
# !&
! !!
-W *></>E;4,(,W *><W 8>W ,4H?J-HI>W -=W -9W (EIS*J8>W +W ,-W 8(W &W NW -<W -9W (EIS*J8>W
,-8W $-(8W -*E-I>W W ,-W W ,-W >*IK)E-W @>EW -8W CJ-W H-W (AEJ-)(W -8W HI(IJI>W ,-9
>=H-6>W ,-W 'E(<HB(F-<*4(W OW K-=W >)5-E<>W
W -8W #E-H5,-<I-W ,-W -HI(W JI>E4,(,
,;4<5HIG(I4L(W <,-?-=,4-<I-W -HW *>;?-I-=I-W ?(F(W F-H>8L-GW 8(HW E-*9(;(*4><-HW DK-W -<
(?95*(*4U<W ,-8W (EIT*J8>W W ,-W 9(W &W H-W ?E-H-=I-<W /E-<I-W (W 9(HW E-H>8J*4>=-HW -M?E-H(H
> ?G-HJ<I(HW E-*(T,(HW -<W ;(I-E5(W ,-W (**-H>W (W 9(W 5</>E;(*4U=
<W L4EIJ,W ,-8W (@(EI(,>W W ,-W 8(W ,4H @ >H4*5U=W (,5*4><(9W *K(GI(W ,-W 8(W !'
W 8(H
*>;J<4,(,-HW (JIU<>;(HW ?K-,-=W (IE4)J5FW 9(W *>;?-I-<*4(W ?(E(W 8(W E-H>8J*4U<W ,-W 8(H
E-*9(;(*4><-HW (9W &W ;-,4(<I-W 8(W *-9-)E(*4U<W ,-8W *>GE-H?>=,4-<I-W *><L-< 4>W *>=W 9(
,;4<5HIG(*5U<W -<-E(8W ,-8W HI(,>W <W ,-H(EE>89>W ,-W ,4*1(W ?F-L4H4U<W -M5HI-W *><L-<5>
L50-=I-W HJH*E4I>W *><W 8(HW *>;J=4,(,-HW (JIU<>;(HW ,-W HIJE4(HW (<I()E 4(W (W $4>7(
MIE-;(,JE(W (HI499( (W "(<*2(W -W 998-HW (8-(EHW (HTW *>;>W *><W 8(HW 5K,(,-HW KIU=>;(H
,-W -JI(W NW "-9588(
!(W !&W -<W HJW (EIS*J9>W
W E-0J8(W -8W ,-E-*2>W ,-W I>,(HW 9(HW ?-EH><(HW (W (**-,-EW (W 8(
5<.>G;(*4U<W ?V)94*(W -=I-<,5,(W H-0V<W -8W (EIT*J8>W W ,-W 8(W ;5H;(W =>E;(W *>;>W
%-0V=W H-W -M?E-H(W -<W -8W ?E-Q;)J8>W ,-W 8(W !'W 8(W IE(<H?(G-<*5(W -9W (**-H>W (W 9(
5=/>E;(*4U<W ?V)84*(W NW 8(HW <>E;(HW ,-W )J-=W 0>)4-E<>W ,-)-<W H-FW 8>HW -7-HW .J=,(;-<I(8-H
,-W I>,(W (**5U<W ?>8TI5*(W %U8>W *J(<,>W 8(W (**5U<W ,-W 9>HW G-H?><H():-HW ?V)94*>HW H-W H>;-I-
(W -H*FJI4<4>W *J(<,>W 8>HW *4K,(,(<>HW ?J-,-<W *><>*-EW *U;>W H-W I>;(<W 8(HW ,-*4H4><-H
DK-W 9-HW (.-*I(<W *U;>W H-W ;(=-7(<W 8>HW .>=,>HW ?V)84*>HW >W )(7>W DKRW *G4I-E4>HW (*IV(<
<K-HIE(HW 5<HI4IJ*5><-HW ?>,E-;>HW 3()8(EW ,-8W 5<4*5>W ,-W J<W ?E>*-H>W -<W -9W DJ-W 8>HW ?>,-F-H
?V)95*>HW *>;4-=P(<W (W E-H?><,-EW (W J<(W H>*4-,(,W DJ-W -HW *ESI5*(W -M40-<I-W NW DK-
,-;(<,(W ?(GI4*4?(*5U=W ,-W 9>HW ?>,-F-HW ?V)94*>H
~
Eoo\j
xyx 6Y? ?j
6tj82d~
2 8o ]E]~ #F="&.*$oS"~ N]"02
~
E oo\j xyx 6Y? @j6tj82d~ 28s^E^~ #F="&.*$~ ^"pS"~ O=28u22
Eoq_k!xxx9YTk@KZ=@pe3Uj_3f@U8G3@j9p~ ,ZQ@@kqd4Vk_3g@U8F3
`Zep2Poe3Tl_3f@T8F3HTCZgQ38FYT|
?8YS8YSw?SFYj8YSw?SFYj(($$EoRP~
Eoo\j xyx 6Y? ?j6tj<2d~ 28p]E]~ #F="&.*$~ oS"~ Na"2
/}DGW5~ ~ >A~ ~
)[XmAL[~ >B~ 1h5Wmb5hAX:I5~ {~ 'vBW~ +[7JAhW[~ %%-~
x
z;[XnAM[>Ari5Umc5hAU;I5Am~
$E ":$4#1E "10E $,E ")8 #1E 58A":,1E E #$E , E E " !$E "10"-:(5E 3:$E , E (0%16/ "(C0E
71,(")9 # E #$!$E "107(#$5 57$E 2:$781E 3:$E 1!5 5A E $0E 21#$6E #$E
:0E 7:*$81E 1!,)& #1E 215E , E E $,E =:09 /($091E #$E :$591,, 01E 3:)$0E #)7210$E #$E
$,- E $0E $,E $+$5"(")1E #$E - 7E %:0"(10$7E 3:$E 9)$0$E -$& ,/$08$E 5$"101")# 7E
-E 4$", / 09$E "107)#$5 E 3:$E , E (0%15/ "(C0E 71-)"(9 # E 01E ,$E ' E 7(#1E 241215")10 # E $0
7:E 818 - (# #E 216E 2 59$E #$E , E #/(0(795 "(C0E "10"$50)# E (0E $/! 5&1E E +:)"(1E #$E $78$
107$+1E 2:$#$E $08$0#$57$E 3:$E 7$E ' E # #1E 7 9)7% ""(C0E E 7:E #$5$"'1E #$E ""$71
0E 25)/$5E ,:& 5E $78$E 107$+1E 2 59$E #$E , E ! 7$E #$E 3:$E $0E 7:7E 5$. "(10$7E "10E 184 7
#/(0)785 "(10$7E 710E #$E 2-(" ")C0E ,17E 25)0")2(17E &$0$5 ,$7E #$,E 58A":,1E E $
#$E ,
$=E E #$E E #$E 1"9:!5$E #$E @&(/$0E :5A#("1E #$-E $"915E D!,("1E #$E !:$0 E %$
"10%) 0> E ,$&B8)/ E =E ,$ -8 #E (079(9:")10 -E --1E )/2,(" E 3:$E 25$7:210$E , E ;$5 ")# #E #$
, 7E #$"- 5 "(10$7E 5$ -(> # 7E 5$72$"91E E 3:$E , E (0%15/ ")C0E 251215"(10 # E $7E ,
$<)79$08$E $0E 5$, "(C0E "10E , E / 9$4) E 71,(")8 #
15E 184 E 2 49$E =E "10"5$8 /$08$E 5$72$"81E #$E , E (0%15/ "(C0E 5$3:$5(# E $0E -17
2 59 #17E 1"9 ;1E =E 01;$01E #$E , E 71,("(9:#E $-E 2412)1E 6$"- / 09$E 2 59$E #$E , E ! 7$E #$
3:$E ,17E )0%15/$7E 71-)"(9 #17E 2:#($4 0E 01E $<)79)4E 7)$0#1E @79 E , E 5 >C0E 214E , E 3:$E 01E 7$
,$E ' !5B 0E 251215"(10 #1
(0 ,/$08$E $0E $,E 2 59 #1E #@")/1E #$E - E 71-(")9:#E #$E ""$71E 7$E (079 E ,E =:09 /($091
E 241215"(10 5E $<2,(" ")10$7E ,E 5$"- / 09$E 5$72$"81E E ,17E " /!)17E #$E "18(> ")C0E $0E , 7
0C/(0 7E #$E -17E 94 ! * #15$7E !$E )0#(" 4E E $78$E 4$72$"81E 3:$E $,E 1!*$91E #$E 9 ,
71,(")9:#E 01E $78?E "1/24$0#)#1E #$0851E #$,E ?/!(81E #$E 2-(" ")C0E / 8$5( ,E #$E - E
#$,)/)8 #1E $0E -17E 9@5/(017E #$E 7:7E 59B":-17E E =E E ,E 01E ;$57 4E , E (0%14/ "(C0
5$3:$5(# E 71!5$E -17E "109$0(#17E 1E #1":/$0917E 3:$E 1!4$0E $0E 21#$4E #$E :0E 7:*$81
)0"-:(#1E $0E $,E ?/!(81E #$E 2-(" ")C0E #$E - E $=
15E ,1E $<2:$791E $78$E 107$*1E "107(#$5 E 3:$E $-E =:08 /($081E #$E :$591,, 01E '
"9: #1E #$E "10%16/)# #E "10E ,1E #)72:$781E $0E - E E ,E ' !$5E 2:$781E E #)7217)"(C0
#$,E 4$"- / 09$E - E (0%16/ ")C0E 71-(")9 # E $0E 9($/21E =E %15/ E 215E ,1E 3:$E 251"$#$
#$7$79(/ 5E - E 5$", / "(C0E 25$7$08 #
S
2JJ?G N ON '=. .G'LG)%DS % )J @2@S 3," J:S 9A%
#R14;&S S -/S S
><H/7>S -0S $E&;HB&E/<*4&SQS M0<S >(5/E;>S !S
N
P+><I/8>-/KF&<HC&E/<+6&/HS
;X ,F0;.5U;X ,X 8=EX ,<F0.0/0;F0EX IX 1G;/,:0;F=EX 6GCR/4.=EX /0E.D4F=EX >D=.0/0X
8,X C0.9,:,.4U;X >D0E0;F,/,X
0X ,.G0D/=X .=;X 08X ,DFR.G9=X X ;V:0D=X X /0X 9,X $0JX X /0X X /0X /5.40:-D0X /0X
FD,;E?,D0;.4,X ,..0E=X ,X 8,X 4;1=D:,.5U;X ?V-95.,X KX -G0;X 2=-40D<=
X 9,X D0.9,:,.4U<X
>D0H5EF,X 0;X 08X ,CFS.G8=X X F40;0X 8,X .=;E4/0D,.4U;X /0X EGEF4FGF5H,X /0X 8=EX D0.GDE=EX
,/:4;5EFD,F4H=EX /0X .=;1=C:5/,/X .=<X 8=X /5E>G0EF=X 0;X 08X ,DFS.G8=X X /0X 8,X %0JX
X /0X X /0X =.FG-D0X /0X (D=.0/ 4:40;F=X /:4;4EFD,F5H=X =:V;X /0X 8,EX
/:4;5EFD,.5=;0EX (W-84.,E
X
=<FD,X 9,X >D0E0;F0X D0E=9G.4U<X AG0X >=;0X 15;X ,X 8,X HT,X ,/: 4 ;4EFD,F4H,X E0X >=/DPX
5<F0D>=<0DX D0.GDE=X .=;F0;.4=E=,/:4;5EFD,F4H=X 0;X 09X >8,L=X /0X /=EX :0E0EX
/5D0.F,:0;F0X ,;F0X 9,X *,8,X /0X 8=X =;F0;.5=E= ,/:4<4EFD,F4H=X /0X 9,X G/40;.4,X ',.4=;,9X
/0X .=;1=D:4/,/X .=;X 8=X >D0H5EF=X 0;X 08X ,@,CF,/=X BG5;F=X /0X 9,X 5E?=E4.4U;X ,/4.5=;,8X
.G,DF,X /0X 8,X &0JX X /0X X /0X 7G84= X )02G9,/=C,X /0X 8,X "GD4E/5..4U;X =;F0<.5=E=N
,/:4;5EFD,F5H,
&X ()*!'+X $X + X
/=X #=EQX &G4EX )=/CS3G0MX O8H,D0MX
i
@[[LW cdc2J;;W2`W7/Ti /7^M@Mi !A9 $+'"i [G i N /
i
@[\LW ccc 2J< <W 3aX80Ti 0 8_ M@Mi !A9 $+("-[G i N 0
@[[OW c cc 2J; <W3aW7/Ti / 8^ P@Pi !A9 $+' " [G i Q /
,h?BH1i i :=i i
&KIY=EKi :>i .U1HYR1U=I5B1i gi %b>Hi )K4C=UHKi ##*i
ef6KIZ=FK:=]V1GYS1U=I6D1=Yi