El interesado solicitó acceso a información sobre la gestión de la calidad del aire al Ayuntamiento de Madrid. Tras una respuesta insuficiente, el ciudadano reclamó ante el Consejo Transparencia y Buen Gobierno. El Consejo estima la reclamación, obligando al Ayuntamiento a proporcionar la información solicitada por no concurrir límites legales que justifiquen la denegación.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
El derecho de acceso a la información pública prevalece sobre la mera alegación de que la información sea compleja o requiera un esfuerzo desproporcionado si no se acredita la inexistencia de la misma.
2
La administración no puede denegar el acceso basándose en la dificultad de compilación de datos si estos se encuentran en archivos públicos o bases de datos accesibles.
3
Se determina que la solicitud no es abusiva ni repetitiva, ya que busca datos concretos sobre la calidad del aire que son de interés público.
4
El Consejo concluye que el Ayuntamiento de Madrid no ha justificado adecuadamente la aplicación de ningún límite legal del art. 14 de la Ley 19/2013.
Texto completo
8dd d d
-/%'d &ZOX;d d d
' G6d :;d H6d =BSL6d
#'
&'
"# &!" ' 2 (41 WN9C 69BaMd O6T6d ;Id $;W6TU NIINd :;d I6d #NL6T96d
26ENd 16INTd HLNMX;d #_9;T;Wd
&' "# ' 0;XT B7Y9CNM;Wd [d NXTNWd ;LNHYL;MXNWd O;S9B7C:NWd ONSd ;Hd
OT;WB:;MX;d :;d 3 (41d ONUd I6Wd >;WXCNM;Wd T;6HB^6:6Wd O6T6d ;Hd [YMX6LC;MXNd :;d 5BJI6d :;Id
0;[d
#' ' ' !"$&' &12),!2.0) d
%' :;d ;F;9Y9DbMd d :`6Wd @_7BI ;Wd
1;>cMd W;d :;WOS;M:;d :;d I6d :N9 YL;MX69BaMd RY;d N7T6d ;Md ;Id ;ZO;:C;MX;d ;Md <;9A6d d :;
EYIBNd :;d d ;Id U;9I6L6MX;d WNIB9BXad 6Id 6LO6SNd :;d I6d *;\d d :;d d :;d :B9C;L7T;
:;d XS6MWP6S;M9B6d 699;WNd 6d H6d CM=NTL69CaMd Qc7IB96d ]d 7Y;Md ?N7C;SMN
;Md 6:;I6MX;
+ )"(d 6d 2 (41d WN9C69CaMd O6U6d ;Hd $;W6TTNHKNd :;d I6d #NL6S96d 36ENd 16INTd ILNMX;d H6d
WB>YC;MX;d BM<NVL69CaM
#$ $ !$ "$ $ ! $ $ $ $ $
$ $ $ $ $ $ $ ! $ $ $ $ $ !$ $ $ #$
$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ "! $ $
-
!))&(- +++ %(*('- )&!&- "-
, #$- - - -
"+--#= &'-= '9= 9= != #5:= %0.0= 5+= 5'= #$0/#30/= 103= 1#36'= &'= '56#= '/6+ &#&= 8+#,'5= 9=
&+'6#5=
FW3b ?-b -XU3F/8-b 23b P3UKX3UW-b -b UXb UI?:/8WX2b 3?b UI?8/8W-FW3b KQ3U3FW`b 23b -/X3Q2Ib /IFb ?Ib
28UKX3UWIb 3Fb 3@b -PW_/X?Ib b
23b @-b #(! b XF -b P3/ ?-E-/8`Fb -FW3b 3?b IF U3<Ib 23b
(Q-FUK-P3F/9-b [b X3Fb I.83QFIb 3Fb -23?-FW3b + b 3@b b 23b 53.Q3QIb 23b b /IF
FaE3PIb 23b 3ZK3293FW3b
@b b 23b 53.Q3PIb 23b b 3?b * b Q3E:W8`b ?-b Q3/?-E-/8`Fb -b ?-b '3/P3W-Q^-b 3F3P-?b 23
( ,'UI /9-/:`Fb K-P-b 3Ab 3U-QQIA?Ib 23b ?-b IE-Q/-b )-=I '-?IP @EIFW3b -?b I.=3WIb 23
NX3b KIQb 3?b `P6-FIb /IEK3W3FW3b KX283Q-Fb KP3U3FW-RU3b ?-Ub -?36-/8IF3Ub NX3b U3
/IFU923Q-U3Fb IKITXF-U
@b b 23b -.Q8?b 23b b U3b Q3/9.3b /IFW3UW-/9`Fb -?b P3NX3P8E83FWIb 23b -B36-/:IF3U
P3-@8]-2Ib NX3b :F/@X[3b XFb 8F5IQE3b 23?b 3R3FW3b 23?b PXKIb 23b //8`Fb #I/-@b ( ,'b
UI/8-/:`Fb K-P-b 3?b 3U-PQIA?Ib 23b A-b IE-Q/-b (-<I '-CIP@EIFW3b 23b 3U-b E:UE-b 53/7-
0JFb 4?b V;6X;4GW4b 0JFW4F;2J
= = = 6'/)0= #= $+'/= +/(03.#3= 27' = %0/57-6#&#= -#= %0/6#$ +-+&# &= #5;= %0.0= 063#=
&0%7.'/6#%+</= 27'= 0$4#/= '/= '56#= #50%+#%+ </ = = = = = = = = 3'63+ $7%+</=
#-)7/#= '/= %0/ %'160= &'= )#5605= &'= 8+#,'= 9= &+'6#5= '/= '-= 1'3+0&0= %0.13'/ &+&0= '/63'= 57=
60.#= &'= 105'5+</= 9= -#= ('%*#= #= -#= 27'= *#%'= 3'('3'/%+#= '/= 57= 3' %-#.#%+</= = &'= #$3+-=
&'= =
3b /IF5IPE:2-2b /IFb ?Ib 28UKX3UWIb 3Fb 3?b -PW_/X?Ib 1b 23b ?-b #(! b [b 3Fb 3?b -PW_/XDIb
23?b &3-?b 3/P3WIb b 23b b 23b I/WX.P3b LIPb 3?b OX3b U3b -MPX3.-b 3?b UW-WXWIb 23@
IFU3>Ib 23b (Q-FUL-Q3F/8-b \b X3Fb I.:3QFIb
b 3?b %P3U823FW3b 23b 3UW-b XWIS82-2
2E8 F:UWP-W8Y-b !F23K3F283FW3b 3Ub /IEK3W3FW3b K-Q-b P3UI? Y3Pb ?-Ub P3/?-E-/8IF3Ub NX3b 3F
-K?8/-/:`Fb 23?b -RW^/X?Ib b 23b ?-b $)" bU3bKQ3U3FW3Fb 5Q3FW3b -b ?-Ub P3UI?X/8IF3Ub 3ZKP3U-U
I KR 3UXFW-Ub R3/-_2-Ub 3Fb E-W3Q9-b 23b -//3UIb -b @-b 8F5IPE-/9`F
Fb Y8PWX2b 23?b -M-PW-2Ib b 23b ?-b 2:ULIU8/9`Fb -2:/8IF-@b /X-PW-b 23b ?-b $*!
D-U
/IEXF:2-23Ub -XW`FIE-Ub KX323Fb -WP8.X:Pb @-b /IEK3W3F/8-b K-P-b @-b P3UI@X/8`Fb 23b D-U
P3/?-E-/8IF3Ub -@b * b E328- FW3b ?-b /3A 3.P-/8`Fb 23@b /IQP3UKIF283FW3b /IFY3F9Ib /IHb ?-
9NO EL RSRV /C66L /PL1-I-2NV E:FV ;4!)$ NA@F -V
9 ONEL RRRV /C66L /PL2-JV -1N VE : E ;4!)%NAV @G+-V
9NOGL RSR/C66 L /PL1-I-2N E:G;4& G N A@4-2Q--V
*U8>.V V 57VV
#DBM7?DV 57V ,K.BMHI7B3=.V TV "P7AV 'D0<7IADV (V
3gg
(6.7/?@<$&.K7N )7)<$4N ()4N ?@$(8N 7N ()?$<<8548N ()N (/&,$N 9<)B/?/K7N )C/?@)N &87B)7/8
B/+)7@)N ?A?&</@8N &87N 4$?N &86A7/($()?N $A@K786$?N ()N ?@A</$?N $7@$%</$N $N /81$N
C@<)6$(A<$N $?@/45$$N $7&,$N )N 554)?N $4)$<?N $?HN &868N &87N 5$?N /A($()?N A@K786$ ?N
()N )A@$N DN )5/55$N
$N N )7N ?AN $=@I&A48N
MN <)+A5$N )4N ()<)'8N ()N @8($?N 5$?N 9)<?87$?N $N $&&)()<N $N 5$
/7*8<6$&.K7N 9L%5/&$N )7@)7(/($N ?)+L7N )4N $>J&A58N N ()N 4$N 6.?6$N 78<6$N &868N /&
(&6 6 )(&6 )!)$6 !)6 &6 &)6 "(6 6 & #(6 !)6 %6
"6 6 )6 6 &6 &) (&6 )&6 6 6 1(6 6 46 6 &(6 (2()6 ,6 !)
,6 &6 "&6 6 !)"&6 6 6 "6 6 &)&6 ) & 0
8<N 48N @$7@8N 4$N 4)DN ()*/7)N )4N 8%2)@8N ()N A7$N ?85.&/@A(N ()N $&&)?8N $N 5$N /7*8<6$&.K7N )7
<)5$&.K7N &87N .7*8<6$&.K7N ;A)N D$N )C/?@)N 98<N &A$7@8N )?@FN )7N 98?)?/K7N ()N A7N 8<+$7/?68
/7&4A.(8N )7N ?AN F6%.@8N ()N $94/&$&.K7N %/)7N 98<;A)N G5N 6.?68N 4$N ,$N )5$%8<$(8N %/)7
98<;A)N 5$N -$N 8%@)7/(8N )7N )1)<&/&/8N ()N 4$?N *A7&.87)?N DN &869)@)7&/$?N ;A)N @/)7)
)7&86)7($($?
7N )5N &$?8N ()N )?@$N <)&5$6$&.K7N 5$N /7*8<6$&/K7N ?85/&/@$($N @/)7)N 5$N &87?/()<$&/K7N ()
/7*8<6$&.K7N 9L%4/&$N D$N ;A)N 8%<$N )7N 98()<N ()N A7N ?A1)@8N 8%5/+$(8N :<N 5$N N !0N
!"?8&/$&.K7N 9$<$N )5N )?$<<8558N ()N 5$N 86$<&$N !$18$48<4687@)N )7N B/<@A(N ()4
$<@J&A48N .
N ;A/)7N (/?987)N ()N )54$N &87N 68@/B8N ()5N )1)<&/&/8N ()N 5$?N *A7&/87)?N ;A)
@/)7)N 4)+$46)7@)N <)&878&/($?
)7@$($N )?@$N &A)?@/K7N ()%)N /7(/&$<?)N ;A)N 4$N /7*8<6$&/K7N ?84/&.@$($N 9) <6/@)N &878&)<
46 &6 6 &6 &6 5&6 @$5N DN &868N <)&8+)N 5$N !N )7N ?AN 9<)F6%A48
<8&)()N <)&8<($<N ;A)N )4N $<@J&A58N N !N (/?987)N ;A)N # N 6 "&)46 6 6 !)6 '
6 6 )6 6 &6 "16 ( "&6 6 &((6 ,6 6 &6 (""&
(&6 !)6 &36 6 ,6 &(6 6 6 -6 1+6 6 )6 &6 &6 6 " 4
6 6 &()6 "6 6 4"6 ((6 "6 "&*"6 &(6 .6 "16 " &6 "
( "6 &6 6 6 &6 6 !)6 6 *)6 6 6 6 6 6 "46 !)6 &
&(6 &36 6 6 &"6 ,6 "*6 (46 6 &((
7N )4N &$?8N ()N )?@$N <)&4$6$&/K7N 4$N )7@.($(N <)&4$6$($N 78N <)?987(/KN $5N ?85/&/@$7@)N )7N )5
95$E8N 6FC/68N 5)+$56)7@)N )?@$%4)&/(8N ?.7N ;A)N &87?@)N &$A?$N 8N <$EK7N ;A)N 58N 3A?@.*/;A)
N 5$N B.?@$N ()N )548N )?N 8%5.+$(8N <)&8<($<N ;A)N 5$N 8%?)<B$7&.$N ()4N 95$E8N 6FC/68N ()
<ZZSY $ ``` 4QMY7FQ57ZV0NY T 0V7M4D0 7Y 4Zg ,QK77YZV0NYS0W7O4@0TQVZ0G[V0NYT0V7M4@0N9RWL04AQNc
74QN4QN_7N@QYQN_7MAQY**-=ZKGg
g
>ZZTY %```2Q77Y2]Y40V04Z U?T'B5 & )+("" ZN & T & "0Hg
).+(""!g I7ag #g 57g #g 57g 5 C4 @7L 2V7g 57g \W0MYS0V7PA0g 0447YQg 0g G0g AN9QXL04AeNg Uf2J@40g bg
2^7Mg :Q2A7VNQg
/d;E1g g 68g g
(>=F*EF&(0S=V *EV G=V *6*<*=F>V *E*=(0&7V )*6V (>=F*=/)>V )*6V )*A*(->V (>=EF0FG(0>=&7V )*V
&((*E>V &V 6&V /=+>A<&(0S=V ?T'60(& V F&6V JV (><>V *7V ?B>?/>V *,0E7&)>AV E*V *=(&B,SV )*V
EG'A&J&AV *=V *6V ?B*N<'G6>V )*V 6&V !V &8V <&=0+*EF&AV @G*V $ $ $ $ $ $
$ $ $ $ $ $ $ "$ # $ $ $ $ $
$ !$ $ $ $ $ $ $
>BV >FB&V ?&AF*V G=&V H*KV 0=F*C?G*EF&V A*(6&<&(0S=V &=F*V *EF&V GF>B/)&)V )</=/EFA&F0H&V
=)*?*=)0*=F*V JV E>8 0(0F&)>V *6V (>AB*E?>=)/*=F*V /=+>B<*V &V 7&V *=F0)&)V A*@G*B0)&V OEF&V E*V
-&V 90<1F&)>V &V FA&E:&)&AV G=V 0=+>A<*V )*V 6&V ,*A*=(/&V &6V !V *=V *6V @G*V E*V /=)/(&V @G*V =>V
E*V .&V ?*B(/'1)>V "$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ E0=V @G*V
(>=EF*V @G*V .&J&V )0(F&)>V A*E>8G(0S=V *I?B*E&V E>'B*V 6&V E>90(0FG)V )*V &((*E>V F&6V JV (><>V
*I0,*V *7V &DP(G8>V V !V B*?B>) G(/)>V EF&V ><0E0S=V (>=EF/FGJ*V G=&V /=+A&((0S=V
<&=0+/*EF&V )*V 8&V !V @G*V )*F*A<0=&V @G*V E*V )*'&V *EF0<&AV 8&V B*(;&<&(0S=V *V 0=EF&BV &8V
>A ,&=0E<>V B*@G*B/)>V &V @G*V )0(F*V G=&V A*E>6G(0S=V *I?A*E&V JV 8&V =>F0+/@G*V &V 8>EV
E>60(/F&=F*EV (>=+>B<*V &V 6>V *I/,/)>V ?>AV 7&V 6*JV
=V )*+0=/F0H&V )*V (>=+>B<0)&)V (>=V 8>V *I?G*EF>V )&)>V @G*V 7&V 0=+>A<&(/S=V E>8 /(0F&)&V *EV
0=+>B<&(0S=V ?T'60(&V @G*V 7&V *=F /)&)V A*@G*B0)&V =>V .&V (G<?8/)>V (>=V 8&V >'8/,&(/S=V )*V
B*E>6H*CV 8&V E>6/(0FG)V )*V &((*E>V &V 6&V 0=+>A<&( /S=V ?U'6/(&V F&7V JV (><>V *I0,*V *8V &AFP(G8>V
V !V ?B>(*)*V *EF0<&AV 6&V A*(6&<&( /S=V (>=V *6V +0=V )*V @G*V &@GO96&V )/(F*V A*E>6G(0S=V
*I?A*E&V JV +&(/6/F*V &6V B*(6 &<&=F*V *6V &((*E>V &V 8&V 0=+>A<&(0S=V JV 6&V )>(G<*=F&(0S=V
E>60(/F&)&V (>=V *6V <0E<>V (>=F*=0)>V (>=V *6V @G*V -&V )&)>V FA&E6&)>V &V *EF*V >=E*3>V *=V *6V
FBN<0 F*V )*V &8*,&(/>=*EV
=V &F*=(0S=V &V 8>EV &=F*(*)*=F*EV JV +G=)&<*= F>EV 3GBQ)0(>EV )*E(A/F>EV ?B> (*)*V
V "V 8&V B*(7&<&(/S=V ?B*E*=F&)&V +B*=F*V &V "# E>(0&(0S=V ?&A&V *8V
*E&AB>66>V )*V 6&V ><&A(&V !&4> &6>A6<>=F*V
$V "V &V !# E>(/&(0S=V ?&A&V *6V *E&BA>67>V )*V 6&V ><&A(&V !&5> &6>BM
7<>=F*V &V @G*V *=V *6V ?8&L>V <NI0<>V )*V H*/=F*V )R&EV -N'06*EV +&(/80F*V &7V A*(8&<&= F*V 7&V
E2 ,G0*=F *V 0=+>B<&(/S=V
=+>A<&(0S=V E>'B*V A*FB/'G(/>=*EV JV >FA>EV *<>6G<*=F>EV B*(/'0)>EV ?>AV 7&V
A*E0)*=(/&V *=V 8&V ?*AE>=&V )*V )GB&=F*V *8V ?*B/>)>V
(><?A*=) /)>V )*E)*V EGV F><&V )*V ?>E*E/S=V -&EF&V *;V V )*V &'A0 6V )*V V A*8& (0>=&)&EV
(>=V 6&EV ,*EF0>=*EV ?&A&V *6V JG=F&<0*=F>V )*V %086&V )*7V *JV JV !# V &ERV (><>V E0V E*V
&'>=&A>=V ?>CV ?&AF*V )*V *EF&V *=F1)&)V H2&3*EV JV )/*F&EV
4WW
7%3"%30t (.573t <t 8 ';6_T>E<>ErSt U<[<t @Kt $@_<[[TMLTt ?@t K<t #TR<[><t 8<HT6<LT\i
LRTS`@t <t Ya@t @St @Mt RE_RTt UL<hTt RlcERTt ?@t b@ES`@t ?n<_t Dl=EK@_t [@RE`<t <t @_`@t
#TS_@ITt ?@t 9\<S_U<[@S>E<t dt !a@St 'T=E@]STt >TUF<t ?@t L<t FSAT[R<>FrSt @SbE<?<t <Kt
\@>L<R<S`@t
$@t <>a@[?Tt >TSt @Lt <[`o>aNTt t SsR@[Tt Ot ?@t P<t ,@et t ?@t t ?@t ?E>E@R=[@t ?@t
`\<S_V<\@S>F<t <>>@_Tt <t K<t FSAT[R<>FrSt Ws=K F><t =a@St BT=E@[ST
t L<t [@>K<R<>FrSt
U[ @bE_`<t @St @Lt <[`p>aLTt t ?@t L<t RF_R<t `F@S@t L<t >TS_F?@[<>ErSt ?@t _a_`G`a`Eb<t ?@t MT_t
[@>a[_T_t <?RFSF _`\ <`FbT_t ?@t >TSAT\RF?<?t >TSt KTt ?E_Ua@_`Tt @St @Lt <[`o>aMTt t ?@t M<t
-@ft
?@t t ?@t T>`a =]@t ?@t 1[T>@?FRE@S`Tt ?RFS E_`[<`FbTt #TRsSt ?@t K<_t
?RESF_`]<>ETS@_t 2s=QF><_
t
#TS`[<t L<t U[@ _@S`@t [@_TLa>ErSt Ya@t UTS@t AESt <t M<t bq<t <?RESG_`[<`Fb<t _@t UT?[lt
ES`@[UTS@[t [@>a^_Tt >TS`@S>ET_T <?RESF_`[<`FbTt @St @Lt UL<hTt ?@t ?T_t R@_@_t
?F\@>`<R@S`@t <S`@t L<t 6<L<t ?@t LTt #TS`@S>ET_T<?RESF_`\<`EbTt ?@t L<t a?F@S>E<t /<>FTS<Kt
?@t >TSAT\RE?<?t >TSt LTt U\@bF_`Tt @St @Mt <X <]`<?Tt ZaFS`Tt ?@t L<t $E_X T_F>FrSt <?E>FTS<Kt
>a<\`<t ?@t L<t -@gt
?@t t ?@t JaKETt 4@BaL<?T^<t ?@t L<t *a[F_?G>>FrSt #TS`@S>FT_Tj
<?Rt FS F_`\<`Eb<
t
%,t 24%6)$%/:%t $%-t #7!'t
&?Tt +T_mt ,aF_t 4T?\pCa@ht kPb<[@ht
;PPFNUUU 2D99N2SN5/J05P G;HW $<7"'-*%PA"@G"/W
; PPFN UUUW 2D99N2RN5/J05P G;HW $<7"'-*%PB"@"/@W
;PPGN !UUU 2D9 9N2SN5/KW /5P G ;W F$=7#'-*% QB#@H# /W
)ECO:?EW 8:W .L1BOIM:B6<1W VW (T:CW +E3>:MBEW &&,W