El interesado solicitó acceso a información sobre la gestión de la calidad del aire y el impacto de la contaminación en la salud. Tras una respuesta insuficiente de la administración, el Consejo de Transparencia y Buen Gobierno estima la reclamación, obligando al organismo a proporcionar la información solicitada.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
El derecho de acceso a la información pública prevalece sobre la alegación de que la información se encuentra en proceso de elaboración o publicación general.
2
La administración no justificó adecuadamente la denegación, limitándose a alegar que la información estaba disponible en la web sin proporcionar los enlaces específicos.
3
Se determina que la respuesta administrativa fue insuficiente al no atender concretamente los puntos solicitados por el interesado.
4
El Consejo de Transparencia insta a la administración a facilitar la información solicitada en un plazo de diez días hábiles.
Texto completo
$'I?F1Q
$ "-Q 01Q :-Q 26C<-Q
!$
#$
!# $ 6G0-0Q GFO=><-Q 01Q #1:7;:-Q >=E181CM-Q 01Q &>:NF7/-EQ
)>/7-:1EQ )-;G0Q &P.;7/-Q JQ 61=1EF-DQ=6<-:Q
#$ !$ I?1061=F1Q 01Q 1=/-C4>Q -Q :-Q 1<?C1E-Q *()+Q 01;Q E1CH6/6>Q
01Q />=FC>:Q 01Q -=6<-;1EQ -.-=0>=-0>EQ
!$ $ $ "#$ ( ,%Q
)14P=Q E1Q 01E?C1=01Q 01Q ;-Q 0>/G<1=F-/6O=Q BG1Q >.C-Q 1=Q 1;Q 1I?1061=F1Q :-Q -E>/6-/6O=
C1/;-<-=F1Q E>;6/6FOQ -:Q -<?-D>Q 01Q :-Q "1KQ
01Q Q 01Q 06/61<.C1Q 01Q FC-=E@-C1=/7-
-//1E>Q -Q ;-Q 7=2>C<-/6O=Q AP.; 6 /-Q LQ .G1=Q 5>.61D=>Q
1=Q -01;-=F1Q "*!Q -Q :-Q >=E191CN-
01Q &>:MF6/-EQ )>/6-;1EQ )-:G0Q &P.:7/-Q JQ 61=1EF-CQ =6<-;Q 01Q ;-Q 6G0-0Q GFO=><-Q 01Q
#1;6;:-Q 1;Q Q 01Q 07/71<.C1Q 01Q Q ;-Q E64G71=F1Q 6=3>C<-/7O=Q
% % % % % % % % % % !% % % %
#% $% % % % #% % % !% % % !% % %
% % % #% $% !% % % % % % % %
% "% % % %
##" %%%& "$"!& # & & &
!" " " "
" " " " " " "
"
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( &( $( "(
( ( %( ( #( ( !( ( $( (
( ( ( !( $( ( ( ( !( ! '( (
(
/C&87*8@6)Q &87Q 3$Q @)C9E)CD$Q @)&0%0($Q 98@Q 9$@D)Q ()Q 4$Q $(6/70CDA$&0N7Q 4$Q $C8&/$&0N7
@)&3$6$7D)Q 9@)C)7DNQ F7$Q @)&4$6$&/N7Q $7D)Q )4Q 87C)18Q ()Q !@$7C9$@)7&0$Q IQ E)7
8%/)@78Q )7Q $()4$7D)Q "Q $Q 4$Q =E)Q C)Q ($Q )7D@$($Q )3Q Q ()Q *)%@)@8Q ()Q Q &87Q
7O6)@8Q ()Q )H9)(/)7D)Q Q
87Q $7D)@ /8@ /($(Q 3$Q 6/C6$Q $C8&0$&/N7Q @)&4$6$7D)Q -$%L$Q 9@)C)7D$(8Q E7$Q A)&4$6$&/N7
@)4$&/87$($Q &87Q )4Q 6 /C68Q )7&$@,8Q $Q 3$Q )69@)C$Q " "Q &87Q 7O6)@8Q ()
)H9)(0)7D)Q Q A)CE)3D$Q )7Q C)7D/(8Q )CD06$D8B/8Q 98BQ 4$Q Q !Q Q ()
Q ()Q C)9D0)6%@)
4Q Q ()Q *)%@)A8Q ()Q Q )3Q "Q A)6/D/NQ 4$Q @)&3$6$&/N7Q $Q 3$Q 87C)1)@L$Q ()Q 83MD/&$C
8&0$4)CQ $3E(Q P%4/&$Q IQ /)7)CD$AQ 7/6$3Q $4Q 8%1)D8Q ()Q =E)Q C)Q 9E(0)A$7Q 9@)C)7D$@Q 3$C
$4),$&/87)CQ =E)Q C)Q &87C/()@$C)7Q 898@DE7$C
7Q 4$Q +)&.$Q )7Q =E)Q C)Q (/&D$Q )CD$Q @)C84E&/N7Q 78Q C)Q -$Q @)&/%/(8Q &87D)CD$&/N7Q $4
@)=E)@06/)7D8Q ()Q $4),$&/87)CQ A)$3/K$(8
)Q &87+8@60($(Q &87Q 48Q (/C9E)CD8Q )7Q )4Q $@DM&E48Q 'Q ()Q 3$Q #Q IQ )7Q )3Q $@DM&E38Q
()3Q )$4Q )&@)D8Q Q ()Q Q ()Q 8&DE%@)Q :8AQ )3Q >F)Q C)Q $;@E)%$Q )4Q CD$DED8Q ()4
87C)28Q ()Q "@$7C:$B)7&0$Q JQ E)7Q 8%/)@78
Q )4Q @)C0()7D)Q ()Q )CD$Q $FD8@/($(
$(6/7/CD@$D/G$Q /7()9)7(/)7D)Q )CQ &869)D)7D)Q 9$@$Q @)C83G)@Q 3$CQ @)&3$6$&/87)CQ ?E)Q )7
$93/&$&/N7Q ()3Q $@DM&E38Q Q ()Q 4$Q "
C)Q 9@)C)7D)7Q *@)7D)Q $Q 4$CQ A)C83F&/87)C
)H9A)C$CQ 8Q 9A)CF7D$CQ @)&$M($CQ )7Q 6$D)A0$Q ()Q $&&)C8Q $Q 3$Q /7+8@6$&/N7
7Q G/@DE(Q ()4Q $<$@D$(8Q Q ()Q 3$Q (0C<8C /&0N7Q $(/&/87$5Q &E$@D$Q ()Q 3$Q "
Q 4$C
&86E70($()CQ $EDN786$CQ 9E)()7Q $D@/%E/@Q 3$Q &869)D)7&/$Q 9$@$Q 3$Q A)C83F&/N7Q ()Q 3$C
@)&3$6$&/87)CQ $4Q "Q 6)(/$7D)Q 3$Q &)3)%@$&0N7Q ()3Q &8B@)C987(/)7D)Q &87G)708Q &87Q 4$
_
; TVIR[[[_ 2G8 8R2YR40P_ 0 4T J<J_ "=6 %,(#TC _ BI .0
_
; TWKR [ [[_ 2G8 8R 2XR40P_ 0 4T L<L_ "=6 %,)#_ M!TD _ B0
;TV IR [[[_ 2G8 8R2YR40P_ 04TJ<J_ "=6 %,(#_ I TE _ B604X00
-^:>E1_ _ 79_ _
'HES9@H_ 79_ /Q1ESN1Q9E5>1_ ]_ &Z9E_ *H3?9QEH_ $$+_
\ 5HES9AH79UQ1FSO1Q9 E 5?1 9S_
&5-7->?;#%.I7K '7'<#1K &'1K >?#&8K 7K &'>#;<8118K &'K &-%*#K 9<'A.>-I7K 'B.>?'K %87A'7.8
A.)'7?'K >@>%<.?8K %87K 1#>K %85@7-&#&'>K #@?I785#>K &'K >?@;-#>K #7?#$;.#K #K -8/#K
B?<'5#&@<#K #>?-11##K #7%+#K 'K 411'>K #1'#<>K #>GK %858K %87K 1#>K %.@&#&'>K #@?I786#>K
&'K '@?#K CK '2-21#K
K ?'78;K &'K 28K &->9@'>?8K '7K >@K 9;'E5$@18K 1#K !K ?.'7'K 98;K 8$/'?8K %
% % % % % % $% % % % % %
% % % #% % % % % % % % %
% % % % % % % $% "% %
% % % % % 'K '>?'K 58&8K >@K #<?H%@18K
<'%878%'K '2K &'<'%*8K &'K ?8&#>K 2#>K 9'<>87#>K #K #%%'&'=K #K 1#K .7(8;6#%-I7K 9J$1.%#K '7K 18>
?F<5-78>K 9;'A->?8>K '7K '2K #<?G%@18K $K &'K 1#K 87>?-?@%-I7K CK &'>#;;811#&8>K 98<K &.%,#
78<5#K 1')#1K 7K '>?'K >'7?.&8K '1K #;?G%@18K K &'K 1#K "K &'(-7'K 1#K -7(8<5#%.I7
9J$2-%#K %868K 28>K %87?'7.&8>K 8K &8%@6'7?8>K %@#2:@.';#K :@'K >'#K >@K (8<5#?8K 8
>898<?'K :@'K 8$<'7K '7K 98&';K &'K # 1)@78K &'K 18>K >@/'?8>K .7%1@-&8>K '7K '1K E6$-?8K &'
#91.%#%-I7K &'K '>?'K ?H?@28K CK :@'K *#C#7K >-&8K '2#$8<#&8>K 8K #&:@.<.&8>K '7K '2K '0';%.%.8K &'
>@>K (@7%.87'>
'K #%@';&8K %87K '2K %.?#&8K #<?G%@28K K &'K 1#K "K %#$'K %87%1@-<K :@'K 3#K .7(8<5#%-I7
>81-%.?#&#K &'$'K %87>-&';#<>'K #% $!% 9@'>?8K :@'K 8$<#<G#K '7K 98&'<K &'
@7K >@0'?8K 8$1.)#&8K 98<K 2#K !K @7#K %87>'/'<H#K &'K 1#K -@&#&K @?I785#K &'K '1.21#
:@'K &->987&<H#K &'K '21#K '7K '2K '/'<%-%-8K &'K 2#>K (@7%-87'>K :@'K '7K 6#?'<-#K &'K >#7-&#&K '
*-).'7'K 1'K <'%878%'K 1#K 'CK ;)E7.%#K
K &'K K &'K 5#<D8K &'K >?#?@?8K &'
@?8785H#K &'K '2-12#
7K '1K %#>8K &'K '>?#K <'%1#5#%.I7K %868K >'K *#K -7&-%#&8K '7K 18>K #7?'%'&'7?'>K 1#
#&5-7->?<#%-I7K %87%'<7-&#K 78K +#K &#&8K <'>9@'>?#K #1K >81-%-?#7?'K CK ?#598%8K *#
%87?'>?#&8K #1K <':@'<-5.'7?8K &'K #2')#%-87'>K (8<5@2#&8K 98<K '>?'K 87>'/8 K >?'
9<8%'&'<K &.(-%@2?#K %87>-&';#$2'6'7?'K '1K %@592-6.'7?8K &'K 1#K (@7%-I7K &'K )#<#7?G#
'7%85'7&#&#K #K '>?#K #@?8<-&#&K #&5.7->?<#?.A#K -7&'9'7&.'7?'K #1K 78K 9;898<%-87#<2'K 7-
2#>K <#D87'>K 98<K 1#>K :@'K 78K >'K #?'7&.IK 1#K >82.%.?@&K &'K #%%'>8K 7-K 1#K A#28<#%-I7K &'K 1#>
%@'>?.87'>K 92#7?'#&#>K 98<K '1K <'%2#5#7?'K %87K '1K (-7K &'K :@'K 9@'&#K &->987';K &'K 18>
' 1'6'7?8>K &'K 0@-%.8K 7'%'>#<.8>K 9#=#K 9<87@7%-#<>'K >8$<'K 2#K 9;8%'&'7%.#K 8K 78K &'K
%87%'&'<K '2K #%%'>8K #K 1#K .7(8;5#%-I7K >82.%.?#&#K 858K %87>'%@'7%-#K &'K '328K '>?'
;
$5604999/,4 )/ 52-402 -& 45; /+ 46 2,402 ,'1/25*52-403 -'(-#/2+(/-:
!/. /-8!-(/4 /.8!-(/ 4 %5+*;
;
$5604 9 9 9 / 47430" /-4/*(/
0#
!" " " "
" " " " " " "
"
B@J/8B] 51@BG+] J6] /@] +K/@-5Z@] +] JL] -B@K/@ 6.B] -B@-LHH/] +;1L@+] -5G-L@JK+@-5+] EL/]
6?C6.+] JL] CL/JK+]+] .5JCBJ6-6Z@]
' B?B] O+] J/] 3+] G/J/Y+.B] <+] +JB-6+-6Z@] G/-;+?+@K/] CI/J/@KZ] LA+] JB;6-6KL.] G/;+-6BA+.+
-B@] /;] ?6J?B] B,8/KB] EL/] /@] /JK+] H/-;+?+-6Z@] EL/] .6B] <L1+H] +<] /NC/.6/AK/]
G/JL/<KB] /@] J/@K6.B] /JK6?+KBG 6B] CBH] /;] )] A] /;] J/@B] ./] +ELV<] J/] CGBCBG-5B@Z
+--/JB] +<] /NC/.5/AK/] G/;+K6MB] +;] /@-+G1B] +<] EL/] J/] G/06/I/] /JK+] G/->+?+-5Z@] ?BK5MB
CBH] /;] -L+<] /;] B,9/KB] ./] VJK+] ./,/] /AK/A./GJ/] -B?B] J+K5J0/-3B] +L@EL/] /;] +--/JB] 4+O+
K/@6.B] ;L1+H] ./@KGB] ./] BKGB] CGB-/.6?6/@KB] +.?6@6JKH+K6MB
@] -BA-<LJ6ZA] L@+] M/S] EL/] ;+] JB<6-6KL.] J/] 3+] M6JKB] J+K5J0/-3+] <+] H/->+?+-5Z@] 3+
C/G.5.B] JL] B,8/KB] CBG] ;B] EL/] CGB-/./] /@] ./05@6K6M+] JL] +G-36MB] O] =+] -B@-;LJ6Z@] ./>
CGB-/.5?6/@KB
@] +K/@-6Z@] +] >BJ] +@K/-/./@K/J] O] 0LA.+?/AKBJ] 8LGW.5-BJ] ./J-I5KBJ] CHB-/./]
;+] H/-;+?+-6ZA] CG/J/@K+.+] 0G/AK/] +] <+] B@J/8/GX+] ./] %B<XK6-+J] (B-6+</J] (+;L.] %[,<5-+] O]
5/@/JK+G] @6?+<] ./] <+] 6L.+.] LKZ@B?+] ./] #/<5<;+]
/] +-L/H.B] -B@] /<] +GKX-L;B] ] @[?/GB] ] ./] <+] !/P] ] ./] ] ./] .6-6/?,G/] ./]
)G+AJD+G/@-5+] --/JB] +] <+] @0BG?+-6Z@] %[,<5-+] Q] L/@] B,5/G@B
] <+] &/-<+?+-6Z@]
CG/M6JK+] /@] /;] +GKX-L<B] ] ./] <+] ?6J?+] K6/A/] <+] -B@J6./G+-7ZA] ./] JLJK5KLK6M+] ./] <BJ]
G/-LGJBJ] +.?5@6JKG+K6MBJ] ./] -B@0BI?6.+.] -B@] <B] .5JCL/JKB] /@] /<] +HKX-L<B] ] ./] \]
"/R] ] ./] ] ./] B-KL,G/] ./] %GB-/.5?6/@KB] .?5@6JKG+K6MB] B?[@] ./] <+J]
.? 6@5JKH+-5B@/J] %[,<6-+J
]
B@KG+] ;+] CG/J/@K/] I/JB<L-6Z@] EL/] CB@/] 06@] +] <+] MX+] +.?5A5JKH+K6M+] J/] CB.GU]
6@K/GCB@/G] G/-LGJB] -B@K/@-5BJB+.?6@6JKG+K5MB] /@] /<] C<+SB] ./] .BJ] ?/J/J]
.6G/-K+?/@K/] +@K/] ;+] (+<+] ./] <B] B@K/@-5BJB +.?6@6JKG+K6MB] ./] <+] L.6/A-6+] $+-5B@+<]
./] -B@0BG?6.+.] -B@] <B] CG/M5JKB] /A] /;] +D+GK+.B] FL6@KB] ./] ;+] 6JDBJ6-5Z@] +.5-5BA+;]
-L+GK+] ./] <+] !/P] ] ./] ] ./] :L<6B] &/2L;+.BH+] ./] <+] LG6J.5--5Z@] B@K/@-6BJBT
+.?6@6JKG+K6M+
]
"] %&($*] "] )]
`
@ VVLT #\ \\` 5J;;T5YT73R` 3 7V M?M` &A9%)/,'` VF%` L%3
`
@VXNT$\\\` 5J< <T 5ZT73R` 37V O?O` &A9%)/,'1VG%`N%3` `
!`
@ VXLT $\\\` 5J< ;T5ZT73R` 3 7V M?M` &A9%)/,'""VG%` L%3"
0_>BH4` ` :=` `
+KHU=DK` :=` 2S4HUP4S=H8B4`^` *[=H` -K6C=SHK` ((.`
] 8KHU=EK:=WS4IUQ4S= H 8C4 =U`
! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! ! !
!