El ciudadano solicitó la información relativa a los gastos de la entidad municipal de gestión de residuos. Tras la denegación de la administración, el Consejo de Transparencia resuelve estimar la reclamación, obligando a la administración a entregar la información solicitada.
Puntos clave de la argumentación
1
El Consejo determina que la información solicitada sobre gastos municipales es de naturaleza pública y no puede ser denegada basándose en la inexistencia de los documentos.
2
Se establece que la administración tiene la obligación de buscar la información en sus archivos y, en caso de no encontrarla, debe justificar debidamente la búsqueda realizada.
3
La resolución subraya que el derecho de acceso a la información pública prevalece cuando no se acredita un límite legal tasado que justifique la denegación.
Texto completo
( &#( X
( '2X 56X @2X 7<JC2X
$(
'(
"$ ' "( <FON24<UDX ,JEP<D4<2AX 56X #O252A2>2J2X 2MN<AA2(2X
*2D4;2X
'( "$( O6DN2MX 56X 4EJJ6EX 6A64NKUD=4EX 4EJFEJ2N=PEX 56X @2X =FON24<UDX
$( ( ( !"%'( !"/"/0$*0+.%X
/69VDX M6X 56MFJ6D56X 56X @2X 5E4OC6DN24=UDX IO6X E3J2X 6DX 6@X 6QF65=6DN6X 6DX 764;2X X 56
5=4=6C3J6X 56X X 6AX J64A2C2DN6X MEA=4=NUX 2AX 2CF2JEX 56X A2X )6RX X 56X X 56
5=4=6C3J6X 56X NJ2DMG2K6D4=2X 2446MEX 2X @2X =D8EKC24=UDX HW3A=42X SX 3O6DX :E3<6KDE
6D
256A2DN6X '1&#X 2@X !<FON24=UDX -JEP=D4=2AX 56X #O252@2?2J2X A2X M=9O=6DN6X <D8EKC24=UD
DN6X @2X 2OM6D4=2X 56X J6MFO6MN2X FEJX F2JN6X 56X @2X 25C<D=MNJ24=UDX 6AX MEA=4<N2DN6X FJ6M6DNU
OD2X J64@2C24=UDX 2DN6X 6BX EDM6?EX 56X 1J2DMF2J6D4=2X TX O6DX #E3=6JDEX 6DX 256@2DN6
1#X 2X A2X IO6X M6X 52X 6DNJ252X 6AX X 56X 863J6LEX 56X X 4EDX DVC6LEX 56X 6QF65=6DN6
##" %%%& "$"!& # & & &
!" " " "
" " " " " " "
"
/ / / &&#/ / / / / & )./ / & .!/ / $*)."/ &#+!/
*&/ / #)#/ / %*/ (/ $*&!/ $&(!)&/ (/ #!(/ %*/ (
#!(&(!/ #$#&)*!(
"# # # #
/ / / ',#/ (/ &/ #")().!/ / &%*' !)#/ / #!(/ )*#/ #"
/ !+-#/ / *!/ #* ")#/ !/ / %*/ (/ !/ #/ (*!)
7 7 #&4 7 #7 ) 7 7 &0)&7 7 !&4 7 $6
7 * # 7 7 &)2*#7 7 7 -7 7 7 &7 7
)& ($& 7 (#7 7 7 !&4 7 $67 -7 * 7 #& #7 (7 ) 7 $#&7
!&4 7 $67 #(7 # ) #(7 #7 #* )#(7 *%*&7 %*7 (7 (*7 #&)#7 #7
(#$#&)7 %*7 #& 7 7 $#&7 7 * #7 7 #(7 (*)#(7 *#(7 7 7 0)#7 7
$4 7 7 ()7 )2)*#7 -7 %*7 - 7 (#7 #&#(7 #7 %*&#(7 7 7  7
(*(7 * # (7
(7 * )(7 7 7 #&$#&)+(7 #7 # ())*- 7 #&4 7 $67 ( #7 %*7 (7
)&)7 7 * 7 #7 )'#7 7 #* 4 7 )&7 7 $&(# 7 7 7 $*)4 7
&#+ 7 $&7 * 7 0(7 .7  7 (*(7* # (7
&( 7 7 )#(7 $&(# (7 7 7 #* )4 7 (#)
(7 &# (7 7 #&&#(7 )&4 #(7 + 7 #(7 7 7 )7 7 (7 $&(# (7
%*7 $&() 7 (&+#(7 7 7 $*)4 7 $&#+ 7 ( #7 $#&7 ) )#7 * 7 (*$*()#7
 7 #&4 7 # 7 ,() 7 )#(7 $&(# (7 *-7 $&#)4 7 7
$&+&7 (#&7 7 (#7 7 #(7 * #(7
(#7 7 *)/4 7 *(+7 -7 #7 $&7 $#&7 7 7 7 7 -7
)& ($& 7 7 (#7 7 ()4 7 7 7 &4 7
# 7 7 7 &7 7 (7 &7 )&(7 2(7 ($*1(7 7 $&( )&7 7
(#)*7 7 #&4 7 %*7 7 #& 7 7 ()7 ,$ )7 7 & )7 &47
#& )&4 #7 7 +&(#(7 $#(7 $*)#(7 $&#+ (7 -7 #)&(7 )(7
# 7 7 )2)*#7
(* )#7 7 )&1(7 $&7 (7 * )(7 #&$#&)+(7 7 7 $*)4 7 7
*&7 #7 * )7 7 7 #$ 4 7 7 &) )7 #7 (#(7 7 #&&*$4 7
#7 7 #(7 *(7 7 ,() 7 7 )#(7 $&(# (7 (7 (*($)7 7 # ())*&7 * 7
"5 7 7 7 #&)+7(#&7 $&#)4 7 7 )#(7
7 * )7 #$7 7 (3#7 #& )&4 #7 7 )#(7 7 (*7 +#&4 7 7 7
# + )#7 7 %*7 7 *).4 7 7 (7 * )(7 #&$#&)+(7 7 #(7 $#(7
7 7 $*)4 7 &#+ 7 7 7 &()& &(7 7 *()# (7 &# (7 # 7 (*(7
* # (7 -7 #7 7 7 &$4 7 7 ()7 )$#7 7 #&4 7 %*7 (*$# 7 * 7
*)/4 7 *(+7 7 7 #&4 7 #7 $&7 $#&7 7 -7 7 )& ($& 7
# # # !# # # #
#
-T +<;/<C:2,),T +<;T 8<T ,3G=I-GH<T -;T -8T )CHP+I8<T +T ,-T 9)T &T LT -;T -9T )CHP+I9<T
,-9T $-)8T -+C-H<T T ,-T T ,-T <+HI*C-T ><CT -9T AI-T G-T )>CI-*)T -9T GH)HIH<T ,-9
<;G-5<T ,-T 'C);G?)D-;+2)T MT I-;T <* 3-C;<
T -8T #C-G2,-;H-T ,-T -GH)T )IH<E3,),
),:3;3GHC)H3J)T 3;,-=-;,3-;H-T -GT +<:=-H-;H-T =)C)T C-G<8J-CT 8)GT C-+8):)+3<;-GT BI-T -;
)=93+)+3R;T ,-9T )CHP+I9<T T ,-T 8)T '
G-T =C-G-;H-;T .C-;H-T )T 9)GT C-G<8I+3<;-G
-K=E-G)GT <T =C-GI;H)GT C-+)P,)GT -;T :)H-C2)T ,-T )++-G<T )T 9)T 3;/<C:)+3R;
;T J3FI,T ,-8T )@)CH),<T T ,-T 9)T ,2G@<G3+2R;T ),3+3<;)8T +I)CH)T ,-T 8)T '
8)G
+<:I;2,),-GT )IHR;<:)GT =I-,-;T )HC3*I3CT 9)T +<:=-H-;+3)T =)C)T 8)T E-G<9I+3R;T ,-T 9)G
C-+9):)+3<;-GT )8T 'T :-,3);H-T 9)T +-9-*C)+2R;T ,-9T +<DC-G=<;,2-;H-T +<;J-;2<T +<;T 8)
,:3;3GHE)+2R;T -;-C)9T ,-9T GH),<T ;T ,-G)CC<99<T ,-T ,3+1)T =C-J2G3R;T -K2GH-T +<;J-;2<
J20-;H-T GIG+C2H<T +<;T 9)GT +<:I;3,),-GT )IHR;<:)GT ,-T GHIE3)GT );H)*E2)T )T $3<6)
KHC-:),IC)T )GH399) )T ");+1)T -T 999-GT )9-)CGT )GQT +<:<T +<;T 9)GT +2I,),-GT )IHR;<:)G
,-T -IH)T LT "-8389)
!)T (T -;T GIT )CHQ+I9<T T C-0I8)T -8T ,-C-+1<T ,-T H<,)GT 9)GT =-CG<;)GT )T )++-,-CT )T 9)
3;/<C:)+3R;T =S*93+)T -;H-;,3,)T G-0S;T -9T )CHQ+I9<T T ,-T 8)T :3G:)T ;<C:)T +<:<T
#<ET 9<T H);H<T 8)T 9-LT ,-/2;-T -9T <*7-H<T ,-T I;)T G<93+2HI,T ,-T )++-G<T )T 9)T 3;.<C:)+3R;T -;
C-8)+3R;T +<;T 2;/<C:)+3R;T BI-T L)T -K3GH-T =<ET +I);H<T -GHNT -;T =<G-G3R;T ,-T I;T <C0);4G:<
3;+8I3,<T -;T GIT N:*3H<T ,-T )=83+)+3R;T *2-;T =<CBI-T O9T :3G:<T 8)T 1)T -9)*<C),<T *3-;
=<CBI-T 9)T 1)T <*H-;2,<T -;T -7-C+2+3<T ,-T 9)GT .I;+3<;-GT LT +<:=-H-;+2)GT BI-T H2-;-
-;+<:-;,),)G
%-0S;T G-T -K=C-G)T -;T -9T =E-N:*I8<T ,-T 9)T !'T 9)T HC);G=)C-;+3)T -8T )++-G<T )T 8)
3;/<C:)+3R;T =S*83+)T LT 8)GT ;<C:)GT ,-T *I-;T 0<*3-C;<T ,-*-;T G-ET 8<GT -7-GT /I;,):-;H)9-G
,-T H<,)T )++2R;T =<9PH2+)T %R8<T +I);,<T 9)T )++3R;T ,-T 9<GT D-G=<;G)*8-GT =S*83+<GT G-T G<:-H-
)T -G+DIH2;3<T +I);,<T 9<GT +3I,),);<GT =I-,-;T +<;<+-CT +R:<T G-T H<:);T 9)GT ,-+2G3<;-G
> \[QY bbbg 4O: :Y 4^Y62Vg 2 6\ R?Rg #@8&.*$[Kg GQ02g
g
> \[QY bbbg 4O: :Y 4^Y62Vg 2 6\ R?Rg #A8 &.*$g Q!\L"gG2
g
>\[QYbbbg 4O::Y4^Y62Vg 26\R?Rg #@8&.*$g Q\Lg G826_22
>\[QYbbb6OKY:DO8:\V2LYQ2V:L6C2:Y6\g ,OI: :Y [V2KYQ2V:K6B2 SOV\2H\V2LYQ2W:L6B2@L<OVI26@OLe
:6OK6OLa:LBOY6OLa:L@OY(($$ ?\JHg
> \[QY bbbg 4O: :Y 4^Y62Vg 2 6\ R?Rg #@8&.*$g \Kg GQ2g g
/f=BM3g g 9;g g
)PMZ;EPg 9;g 1X3MZT3X;M7B3g dg '`;Mg +P5C;XMPg %%-g
c 7PMZ;FP9;]X3NZU3X; M 7C3 ;Zg
6<#H ,#:H $#!;2H !F14H :#H 12#*2H -4:H %42"4:H 5G ,)!4:H 4H +4H 6<CH !7(;#7)4:H !;G2H
2<#:;8:H )2:;);<!)42#:H 54"8#14:H ' ,8H "#,H )2(!(4H "#H <2H 584!#:4H #2H #-H 6<#H ,4:H 54"#8#:H
5G -(!4:H !41)#2@2H H 8#:542"#8H H <2H :4!(#""H 6<#H #:H !8D;)!H #>(#H ?H 6<#H
"#12"H 58;(!(5!)F2H "#H ,4:H 54"#8#:H 5G ,(!4:H
2H #,H !:4H "#H #:;H 8#!,1!)F2H !414H :#H 'H (2"(!"4H #2H -4:H 2;#!#"#2;#:H #,
8#!,12;#H :4-)!);H -H 8#,!)F2H "#H !488#4:H # ,#!;8F2)!4:H !48548;(=4:H "#H ,H )5<;!)F2
A:;H #2H :<:H -#&!)42#:H -#&H 6<#H -H )2%481!(F3H :4-(!(;"H 24H #:H )2%481!(F2
5G -(!H 6<#H %#!;H H ";4:H "#H !8B!;#8H 5#8:42.H 7;D!<,4H
H ?H 6<#H ,
:4,(!);<"H ;(#2#H !7B!;#7H <:(=4
2H 8#,!)F2H !42H #-H ,D1);#H "#,H 8;D!<-4H H "#H ,H H "# #H (2"(!8:#H 6<#H #,H H '
#, 48"4H #2H #-H #*#8!(!(4H "#H ,:H %<2!(42#:H 6<#H ;(#2#H #2!41#2"":H 547H #-H 8;D!<,4
"#H ,H H #,H !8(;#8)4H (2;#858#;;)=4H , H "#H H "#H +<2(4H :4 8#
5,(!!(F2H "#H ,4:H -D1(;#:H ,H "#7#!'4H "#H !!#:4H H -H (2%491!)F2H 58#=):;4:H #2H ,4:
8;D!<,4:H
?H H "#H ,H
#H !<#8"4H !42H #:;#H !8(;#8(4H #,H 584!#:4H "#H 5,(!!)F2H "#H ,4H " (:5<#:;4H #2H #/H 8;E!<04H
!4158#2"#H ,:H :(&<(#2;#:H #;5:H 4H %:#:H :<!#:)=:
%),,9 -"9 %9 "'),&"7'9 -)%"".9 )9 -)&."9 9 */%""9 ."09 )'."'
) ')9 .)-9 9 ,4.,9 *,-)'%9 '.'"5')-9 *),9 5-.)-9 %)-9 '")-9 '9 %9 ,.6/%)
9 9 %9 29 , 4'"9 9 9 9 9 ""&,9 9 ,)."7'9 9 .)-9 9
,4.,9 ,-)'%9 '9 %'.9 9
'9 -)9 ",&."0)9 0%),,9 -"9 %)-9 .)-9 -)'9 )9 ')9 .)-9 -*"%&'.
*,). ")-9 '9 %)-9 .5,&"')-9 %9 ,.6/%)9 9 %9 9 99 9
"9 %)-9 .)-9 9 ,4.,9 *,-)'%9 )'.'")-9 '9 %9 "'),&"7'9 ')9 /,'
.)-9 -*"%&'.9 *,). ")-9 0%),,9 -"9 -)'9 )9 ')9 1%/-"0&'.9 .)-9
&,&'.9 "'.$#."0)-9 ,%")')-9 )'9 %9 ), '"3"7'9 %9 /'")'&"'.)9 )9 %9
."0"9 *8%"9 %9 7, ')9 )9 '."9 ),,-*)'"'.9
"9 %)-9 .)-9 )'.'")-9 -)'9 1%/-"0&'.9 "'.""."0)-9 ,%")')-9 )'
%9 ), '"3"7'9 %9 /'")'&"'.)9 )9 %9 ."0"9 *8%"9 %9 7, ')9 )9 '."9 %9
"(,&"7'9 -9 */%",49 )9 "%".,49 )'9 ,4.,9 ',%9 -%0)9 +/9 '9 %9 -)9
)',.)9 *,0%39 %9 *,)."7'9 9 .)-9 *,-)'%-9 29 ).,)-9 ,!)-9
)'-."./")'%&'.9 *,). ")-9 -),9 %9 "'.,5-9 *8%")9 '9 %9 "0/% "7'9
R
4JJ @ H NN N +>11H +LH-)FR )-JR @5CR 6/ &#J;R @)R
4JJAHNNN +>1 1H +LH-)FR )-JR A5BR 6/ &#J;A)R
4JJ@H NN N +>1 1H+LH-)FR )-J R@5CR 6/ &#J;R @)R R
'Q36<*R R 02R R
"?<I29?R 02R (G*<ID*G2<.6*R PR !M2<R $?,72G<?R %R
O .?<I2:?02KG*=IE*G2 < .8* 2IR
, !, "!, , (" , !, , # , ", ""$!, &
!, , , '*, , #", , , "$, +, ,
* , , , , # , %#!$", "# , , *, $!", , ,
")#, , + , , , , ,
/I 5 *&G/I 0/I 900I ++0I /I 5 +&A58 I +8I 8&#;' /9 8I 0/8& 5&0/ 8I
/I 16&. 6I +;#5I +I I 8 I %I .08950I 15:&5&0I /I 5 80*;'0/ 8I /: 5&05 8I I
!&+'95I 908I 4; I 1 5.'9/I ' /9'!&5I I !;/&0/5'08I 1H*&08I 4; I %>/I &/: 6< /&0I
0 &/: 5< /#/I /I 9 5.'/08I 150 &.& /908I 105I +08I ;* 8I 15 #;/9 I ;/
5 +./: I 0I 08:/: I /I *I 80I I 8:I 5 *.&G/I /0I 8 I 80+''9I 8 I 9&10I
80I 8&/0I 4; I 8 I 1' /I 908I /I 5;90I 8&/I 0/5 'G/I I 1 680/8I /&I
150 '.' /:08I /'I I C5 8I I 9;&G/I 6I I *08I 055 08I + 95G/'08
051059&<08I +I 1 580/*I +I 8 5<&'0I I +I '1;9'G/
/I 8 #;/0I +;#5I /0I 8 I 959I :.100I I 055 08I + :5G/&08I 4; I +I 1501&I
&1;9&G/I >I %>I 1;* &0I I ./ 6I 150:&<I 15I 5I I 0/0 5I :++ 8I I 8;I
05#/&B'G/I I ./ 5I 4; I %>I % %0I ;/I ( 5''0I 16 <&0I I 95/816 /'I
150:'<I :58I % 5I : / &0I /I ; /9I *08I '/9 5 8 8I /I (; #0I0/;55 /9 8I
I +I <&89I I *0I =15 80I /I 1C75"08I /: 5'05 8I 8: I 0/8 (0I 0/8& 5I 4; I +I
10/ 7&G/I ,I 59E;+0I I 6 ! 5&I +I '/: 6D8I 1H+&0I /I +I '<;+#'G/I I *I
&/!05.&G/I >I +08I 5 %08I I *8I 1 780/8I ! 98I I 5 +&B58 I /I "<05I I
8908I H+9&.08I 0:&<0I 107I +I ;+I /I "&/'9&<I 150 I 8 8:'.5I +I 5 +.&G/I
15 8 /9I 8&/I 4; I 5 8;*9 I / 85'0I /*&B5I 09508I 5#;. /908I 4; I 8 I %/I 8#5&.&0I
105I 159 I I *I .&/&895'G/I
/I : /'G/I I *08I /9 /: 8I >I ";/. /908I );5 E'08I 85&:08I 150 I
+I 5 *.&G/I 15 8 /9I !5 /: I I *I &1;9'G/I 70<&/'+I I
;+(5I
I ; 60I 0/I +I 59E;*0I I /H. 50I I I *I ?I
I I I &' .5 I I
:6/825 /'I 80I I +I &/!05.'G/I 3H+'I @I ; /I $0& 5/0
I +I 6 -.'G/I
15 <&89I /I *I 59E;+0I I I +I .&8.I 9& / I +I 0/8& 5'G/I I 8;89':;:&<I I +08I
5 ;5808I .'/&8959&<08I I 0/"07.&I 0/I +0I &81; 890I /I +I 6:F;+0I I I *I
/AB:? FFF%8,,? &D?(#=#(B:/:0*B5:#J
!I.16$J J +-J J
96@-39J +-J ">$6@;$>-6)1$J HJ E-6J 9'2->69J J
G )96@-49+-C>$7@<$>- 6 )2$ -@J
%>I
$%I I $%I 3#;<"8%I $%I 83#%$*1+%2;3I $1*2+:;8!;+=3I 31H2I $%I 0!:I
$1 +2*:;9!#*32%:I H".+#!:
32;8!I /!I 48%:%2;%I 8%:3/<#+G2I 6<%I 432%I &*2I !I .!I =E!I !$1+2,:;8!;+=!I :%I 43$8CI
+2;%8432%8I 8%#<8:3I #32;%2#*3:3!$1+2+:;8!;*=3I %2I %.I 4.!?3I $%I $3:I 1%:%:I
$+8%#;!1%2;%I !2;%I /!I !.!I $%I .3I 32;%2#*3:3!$1+2+:;8!;+=3I $%I .!I <$+%2#+!I !#*32!.I
$%I #32'381+$!$I #32I .3I 48%=+:;3I %2I %.I !5!8;!$3I 7<*2;3I $%I .!I +:53:+#+G2I !$+#*32!.I
#<!8;!
$%I .!I %>I
$%I I $%I -</+3I %(<.!$38!I $%I /!I <8+:$+##+G2I 32;%2#+3:3A
!$1*2*:;8!;+=!I
I I I I
$3I 3:DI <+:I 3$8F)<%@I B0=!8%@I
6PQENUUU+C33N,SN.)KY ) .QE6FY 80&"Q@Y E )Y Y
7QPGN?UUU+C33N+SN.)LY ).QY G6HY 81&#GQ@Y >1).S)LQ)Y
'X59A*Y Y 24Y Y
!DAO4<DY 24Y (M*AOI*M4A/9*Y WY T4AY $D-:4MADY %Y
V /DAO4=D24RM*BOJ*M4 A /;* 4OY